The Case Against Helping The Poor Essay

The Case Against Helping The Poor Essay

Length: 955 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Helping the Poor
Garrett Hardin puts forward an argument against helping the poor from the essay “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor”. He argues that helping the poor cannot decrease population. As we all know, despite efforts made by politicians and other leaders, problems are still affecting the poor in almost all countries around the world. In Hardin’s view, many of the richer countries are seen as which is only capable of carrying so many people. People in poorer countries are “in the water” and want to get into the lifeboat which represents the rich countries. By letting more people on the lifeboat than the boat can handle will drown everyone. Hardin believes that stopping or regulating immigration that it would help feed the poor, and help aliviate some the overpopulation occurring in certain areas with a limited amount of resources. Finally, when several countries created the World Food Bank to prevent hunger. It was created the notion that all the countries would contribute to a bank, and in turn draw from it if needed.
Hardin’s metaphor demonstrates that, overall, it would be devastating to help the poor; the world 's resources would be exhausted and no one would live. He refers to wealthier nations as the “lifeboat” because they are well-managed and independent. In the analogy of the life boat, however, the wealthier countries have limited resources, so they do not have the space to let everyone else on the boat. If they let only a select few in the boat, then some will live. If they let all of the people on the boat, everyone drowns.
Immigration contributes to the problems of the poor by increasing populations in certain areas that are already feeling a strain on their natural resources and exhaust the...


... middle of paper ...


...has shown, immigration is a system that cannot be stopped, but without it we would not have as much diversity in the world. The World Food Bank was created to help the poor around the world even though it is not working out to everyone’s benefit since it is unfairly distributed.
Hardin wrongly suggests that if wealthier countries are lifeboats with only a limited amount of room, it is better to save a few, rather than everyone drowning. But if we all work together we could help solve more issues that affect the poor rather than trying to separate ourselves from the issue. With regulated immigration we could be sure we are taking a responsible approach or prevent the issues that affect the poor directly like overpopulation. The World Food Bank did do some good for a select few, but need to find better programs to help the to the poor, because no one should go hungry.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Case Against Helping The Poor Essay

- Helping the Poor Garrett Hardin puts forward an argument against helping the poor from the essay “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor”. He argues that helping the poor cannot decrease population. As we all know, despite efforts made by politicians and other leaders, problems are still affecting the poor in almost all countries around the world. In Hardin’s view, many of the richer countries are seen as which is only capable of carrying so many people. People in poorer countries are “in the water” and want to get into the lifeboat which represents the rich countries....   [tags: Poverty, Overpopulation, Famine, Garrett Hardin]

Better Essays
955 words (2.7 pages)

The Case Against Helping The Poor Essay

- According to a memorable part of the inscription on the Statue of Liberty, With silent lips. "Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore, Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door.” Consequently, America invited immigrants to come. Yet, there is a manmade concern, “immigration could account for all the yearly increase in population. Should we not at least ask if that is what we want (Hardin, 1974)?” Well....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Better Essays
1138 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on The Case Against Helping The Poor

- “Immigration could account for all the yearly increase in population. Should we not at least ask if that is what we want (Hardin, 1974)?” Well. The audacity of Garrett Hardin’s 1974 essay, “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor” to ingeniously imply concern for illegal entry, but in all actuality supports partiality to who is advantaged to populates the United States. Thus, Immigration policies in America continuous changes reflects discriminatory processes of past and biased judgement by elected officials....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Better Essays
791 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about `` Lifeboat Ethics `` : The Case Against Helping The Poor

- There are several thought processes on the responsibility of the individual in relation to his station in society. One might advocate survival of the fittest while another takes the yoke of burden his brother carries as his own weighted responsibility. This timeless debate has been the focus of essays, books and heated arguments. Two authors, Garret Hardin and Nobel prize winner Muhammed Yunus, show juxtapositions on the subject and merit the examination of their opposing view points. Hardin makes a strong case against helping the poor in his essay entitled “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor.” Yunus has a completely different viewpoint in his writings and shows the merits o...   [tags: Poverty, Sociology, Third World, Wealth]

Better Essays
1406 words (4 pages)

Essay about Garrett Hardin 's Lifeboat Ethics : The Case Against Helping The Poor

- In Garrett Hardin’s “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor, Hardin argues that you should not help the poor because there are limited resources and if the poor continue to seek help they will continue to overpopulate, disrespecting all of limits. Hardin supports his argument by using the lifeboat metaphor while trying to convince the rich not to lend a helping hand to the poor. In the lifeboat metaphor Garrett Hardin uses the upper class and the lower class people to give us a visual of how the lifeboat scenario actually works....   [tags: Poverty, Working class, Garrett Hardin]

Better Essays
1552 words (4.4 pages)

Property and Hunger and Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor

- World Hunger School Lunches - White trays with five individually sized compartments, filled with whatever mystery meat, or previously defrosted sides came off the truck that month, accompanied with a carton of milk; where in most cases chocolate milk, which means the sugar content is higher. For a staggering number of children in the public school system this maybe their only meal for the day. When discussing world hunger, one need not look at commercials of a far away place for malnourished, large abdomen children, just have to look down to see America’s future, wasting away....   [tags: Amartya Sen and Garrett Hardin articles]

Free Essays
531 words (1.5 pages)

Justice vs. Reality in "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor" by Garrett Hardin

- The essay titled "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor" by Garrett Hardin, was very interesting. The first part of the essay used a metaphor of the rich people of the earth in a lifeboat and the poor people in the sea drowning. The rich people could only allow a few people in and if they let, too many people in they will sink the boat and all die. The best thing for the rich people to do is not to let anyone in so they will have adequate supplies and space for them to survive. Later in the essay, Hardin writes about the differences in the population growth between rich and poor nations....   [tags: Lifeboat Ethics, Garrett Hardin, poverty, ]

Better Essays
535 words (1.5 pages)

Supporting the Poor Essay

- In Hardin’s “Lifeboat Ethics” does not take a realistic account of world needs such as people being equipped with life sustaining tools knowledge and education in order to change the status of the poor so that there would be room for everyone in the lifeboat of society (Hardin 381-87). When Hardin claims that our nation has a limited capacity to support a population and that the current energy crisis has shown us how we have already exceeded the carrying capacity of our land, he could not be further from the truth....   [tags: Farming]

Better Essays
748 words (2.1 pages)

Obamacare is not Helping our Community Essay

- ... I believe that Obama Care is not helping our community, because it is making some people have less money. Some people also are buying the health care and don’t want it. Also some people can’t afford the health care that Obama is making us have to have. I think it’s stupid that Obama is making us have to have health care. Not to mention that some people could get poor from this or not have enough money to buy food for the family. Even though I think Obama Care has a bunch of negative effects....   [tags: preferred insurance, buying healthcare]

Better Essays
786 words (2.2 pages)

Robbing the Rich to Give to the Poor Essay

- Robbing the Rich to Give to the Poor Poverty has conquered nations around the world, striking the populations down through disease and starvation. Small children with sunken eyes are displayed on national television to remind those sitting in warm, luxiourious houses that living conditions are less than tolerable around the world. Though it is easy to empathize for the poor, it is sometimes harder to reach into our pocketbooks and support them. No one desires people to suffer, but do wealthy nations have a moral obligation to aid poor nations who are unable to help themselves....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)