From the moment a man enacts violence against an innocent person, he has denounced the principle of individual rights. He chooses to no longer act as a rational being, but rather a predator among men, to harm and destroy those around him. Rationality is the human reasoning and the source of human rights. Those who contradict rationality are detrimental to society and have no rights. Sensibility dictates, when opposed by a subsequently harmful influence it should in turn be dealt with as an act of justice, or greater good (Laundauer, Rowlands).
The most complicated aspect of justice is the proportionality of the offense. When a thief takes another person’s property they can be charged with petty theft and be sentenced to a few months of incarceration, this is how the justice system equalizes the robber’s actions. If instead the thief kills the property owner in cold blood and assumes possession in this manner he then deserves a far more severe punishment, but what kind of punishment is equal to that of a human life? To properly proportion a brutal murder to even a substantial sentence such as life imprisonment does not quite suffice because the victim was not afforded the same option. The right to life cannot be dismissed in such a...
... middle of paper ...
...minals face their actions.
Budziszewski, J. “Capital Punishment: The Case for justice.” Orthodoxy Today. n.p. 2008. 22 April. 2014.
“Continued Majority Support for Death Penalty.” Pew research center. n.p. 2012. 2 May. 2014.
Fagan, Jeffrey. “Capital Punishment: Deterrent effects and Capital Costs.” Columbia law school. n.p. n.d. 30 May. 2014.
Laundauer, Jeff. Rowlands, Joseph. “The Death Penalty.” Importance of philosophy. n.p. copyright 2001. 9 May. 2014.
Pojman, Louis. “A Defense of the Death Penalty.” Colorado Edu. n.p. 2004. 8 May. 2014
Riley, Jim. “The Death Penalty Justified.” Academic Regis Edu. n.p. 2001. 8 May. 2014
Roberts, G. “Death Penalty.” Pros and Cons n.p. n.d. 22 April. 2014
Stewart, Steven. “Death Penalty.” Pros and Cons n.p. n.d. 22 April. 2014
“The Ethics of Capital Punishment.” Martin frost Scottish anatomy. n.p. n.d. 9 May. 2014.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Even before the twelve century when Christians were fed to lions in the amphitheaters of Europe, capital punishment has been a debate; the moral, social and history of capital punishment have been an ongoing discussion; and it will remain so until time ceases to exist. A few years ago an Iranian girl was disfigured with acid thrown on her by a would-be suitor. Her assailant was caught and on the day of the trial the judge asked her what punishment should be given to him; she told him, throw acid on him the way he did to her.... [tags: Justice, Inhumane, Death Penalty]
1357 words (3.9 pages)
- Capital Punishment Punishment and sentencing have gone through various phases throughout the history of Western civilization. Siegel and Senna (2009) reveal some changes reflect “custom, economic conditions, and religious and political ideals” (414). Typical punishment in early Greece and Rome was banishment or exile; however, this form of punishment was reserved for the elite, whereas slaves and common folk were subject to harsher forms of punishment. Crimes, such as murder, were viewed as a “private matter” (Siegel 415).... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison, Murder]
2109 words (6 pages)
- Exemptional Executions Brigg Trendler Period 6 Mrs. Monette 8 December 2014 Since 1967, a total of 1392 executions have occurred in the United States ("Executions by Year"). What a shocking amount. This staggering number creates questioning on the topic of capital punishment. Is the death penalty really constitutional. Research and study over the topic leads to the conclusion that capital punishment should not be instituted in the United States for various reasons.... [tags: Capital punishment]
1345 words (3.8 pages)
- 2. Capital Punishment has historically divided the United States; its meaning has changed throughout different time periods. Capital Punishment, is the “punishment by death for a crime.” It has existed in many societies throughout history, especially in the United States. The constitutionality of Capital Punishment is a debated topic, but the morality behind the death penalty is an often passionate and intense argument. There are relatively three positions one can hold towards the death penalty.... [tags: Capital punishment]
1282 words (3.7 pages)
- The death penalty, also referred to as capital punishment is a very controversial subject which has the United States relatively divided. Capital punishment can be defined as the legal authorized killing of someone as punishment for a heinous crimes against society. The death penalty is primarily reserved for individuals who have been convicted of murder. However, other capital offenses that could result in punishment of death include, espionage, treason, genocide, and kidnapping. Capital punishment has been a widely debated issue throughout history and still strongly argued in present day.... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Murder]
1024 words (2.9 pages)
- For or Against Capital Punishment. In The United States, there are currently 32 states in which the death penalty is legal and 18 states that have abolished it. The use of capital punishment is commonly used to deter citizens from continuing crimes such as murder, aggravated robberies, and rape. Many people’s greatest fear is death; therefore if death is a possible consequence for their actions, it is less likely people will commit these crimes. Ernest van den Haag, a professor at Fordham University, wrote about the issue of deterrence that capital punishment would prevent other punishments due to death being a fear of most.... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Penology, Prison]
921 words (2.6 pages)
- For centuries, the death penalty has been used by nations throughout the world. Practices such as stoning, the guillotine, firing squads, electrocution, and lethal injections have all been common practices to condemn criminals who had enacted heinous crimes. In concurrent society, however, capital punishment has begun to be viewed as a barbaric and inhumane. From these judgments, arguments and controversies have erupted over whether or not the United States should continue to practice the death penalty.... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Lethal injection]
1657 words (4.7 pages)
- In recent years, there have been approximately 311 inmates exonerated using DNA ("Innocence Project"). The Innocence Project website states statistically 65-75% of those convicted were wrongly accused. It could be argued that some death row inmates are innocent and received an unjust or even unconstitutional trial. It could also be argued that the appellate courts should halt placing inmates on death row until the DNA exoneration has taken effect. If this were possible, what affect would it have on the Criminal Justice System and capital punishment laws within the states, specifically Texas.... [tags: Pro Capital Punishment]
990 words (2.8 pages)
- The Effectiveness of Capital Punishment Capital punishment has been a widely argued issue throughout history but up to present day has become more and more debated. Effective punishments must be swift, certain, and severe. The death penalty in America today is certain and severe but is never swift as years pass before justice is carried out. There are some people who believe that putting people to death is cruel and unusual regardless of how humanly it is carried out. However there are others who believe that capital punishment is effective as it puts the fear of death into people which could prevent crime and would be a cheaper alternative than a life prison sentence.... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison, Penology]
1319 words (3.8 pages)
- One of the major problems many have with capital punishment is the cost. Death penalty trials are very complicated with many important parts, and as a result the death penalty is extremely expensive. Studies have shown that a “death-penalty trial costs $1 million more than one in which prosecutors seek life without parole (Barnes 1 of 2).” Duke University studied North Carolina’s death penalty and found that the state spent more, $2.1 million dollars more, on a death penalty case than a case seeking a life sentence (Barnes 1 of 2).... [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison, Death row]
2563 words (7.3 pages)