Capital Punishment For Juvenile Offenders Essay

Capital Punishment For Juvenile Offenders Essay

Length: 1762 words (5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The death penalty is one of the most debated issues of our justice system. Although it is usually tolerated under international law, the same cannot be said of the execution of minors. It is required that the death penalty should only be reserved for those who have committed the most serious of crimes, and never to those under eighteen at the time of their crime. Nearly all countries in the world have ratified this treaty. The United States, however, is the only country consistently abiding by the Article forbidding the execution of juveniles. I believe that juveniles that commit a capital crime should be subjected to capital punishment.
Capital punishment for juvenile offenders started in English common law. In fourteenth century England the minimum age of criminal accountability was age seven. Any child below that age was set free because children at such a young age “knoweth not of good and evil”. From this period through the eighteenth century there was an assumption – one that was taken to be true unless someone comes forward to prove otherwise – made by the court that a child offender above the age of seven but below the age of fourteen could not form the criminal intent required for a death sentence. There was no rebuttable presumption for offenders over fourteen.
The first execution of a minor occurred in 1642. A sixteen year old boy was executed in Plymouth Colony, Massachusetts. Between the years 1642 and 1973, 344 minors were executed in the U.S. Almost half of them were between ages ten and fifteen at the time of their crimes. In the year 1972 twenty-two juveniles were executed. From 1642 to 2005, about 366 juveniles were executed out of almost 20,000 confirmed executions in U.S. history.
America has a long history o...


... middle of paper ...


..."only for the worst of the worst." (Roh)
Most family or friends of the victims of juveniles want a form of justice for their loved one that was taken away from them; similar to the saying “an eye for an eye”.
If a teenager of, say, seventeen were to go out on a walk one day and randomly murder a family of five human beings, that teenager would not be punished as severely as an “adult” of eighteen would be even though there is only a year difference. What kind of development could occur within one year that would allow the oldest to know the difference between right and wrong and the youngest not to? American’s pride themselves in their “faithful” practice of the constitution but, for this particular issue, set aside the centuries-old American practice of letting a twelve person jury decide on whether or not a juvenile should be put on death row for a particular case.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Juvenile Offenders And Juvenile Courts Essay

- According to the authors of And Justice for Some, between the years 1985 and 1997, the number of juveniles placed in state prison more than doubled (Poe-Yamagata & Jones, 2000). While they are separated from the adult population if they were tried in the juvenile courts, when a juvenile is waived to the adult court, they are incarcerated with adult inmates in jails and prisons. In the past years, the courts are moving away from case-specific decisions on waiving juveniles to the criminal courts and are now considering the waiver on offense seriousness....   [tags: Crime, Capital punishment, Roper v. Simmons]

Strong Essays
1193 words (3.4 pages)

Juvenile Offenders Tried As Adults Essay

- Coates 1 Juvenile Offenders Tried as Adults For the longest time minors guilty of a criminal act were sent to juvenile detention, but as the rate of violent crimes committed by adolescents in the past has increased, government officials have had to try juvenile offenders as adults. Since then, the rate of violent crimes committed by minors has decreased, and they resumed sending them to juvenile facilities. Today, depending on certain state laws, minors who are at least 16 years of age and guilty of a serious criminal act could be sentenced to time in prison, but not all states allow this....   [tags: Crime, Prison, Capital punishment]

Strong Essays
1266 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on We Should Not Impose the Death Penalty Juvenile Offenders

- “When a juvenile commits a heinous crime, the State can assert forfeiture of the most basic liberties, but the State cannot extinguish one’s life and his potential to attain a mature understanding of his own humanity.” - (U. S. Supreme Court: Roper v. Simmons- No. 03-633, 2005) In Roper v. Simmons Courts observed that juveniles are not adults and lack responsibility and can easily fall into peer pressure. (Champion, 2013) There are many different factors that attribute to juvenile offenders’ actions, most are not entirely under their control....   [tags: Capital Punishment Essays]

Strong Essays
1352 words (3.9 pages)

The Issues Of Capital Punishment And Delinquent Offenders Essay

- For the past few centuries, one area of crime that has always been an ardent interest of researchers is juvenile delinquency. Kansas Charley is a nonfiction book, written by Joan Jacobs Brumberg, a social historian at Cornell University, which tells the story of a young boy, in the nineteenth century, by the name of Charles Miller, who was executed at the age of seventeen in Cheyenne, Wyoming for double homicide. After thoroughly investigating Miller’s story and gathering evidence from multiple sources, such as newspaper accounts, trial transcripts, and archives from social service, Brumberg, through this case study, analyzes the issues of capital punishment and delinquent offenders....   [tags: Crime, Capital punishment, Murder]

Strong Essays
1368 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on The Problem Of Juvenile Offenders

- Many states have established laws to help deter youths from committing crimes. One measure put into effect specifically regarding juveniles is known in California as Proposition 21 and is intended to change the treatment of juvenile offenders to prosecute violent youths participating in gangs. This proposition was deliberated to require more youths to be prosecuted in adult court; change the type of probation available for juveniles and to increase the criminal penalties for certain offenses. Another measure California has put into effect is the STEP Act....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Gang, Juvenile delinquency]

Strong Essays
856 words (2.4 pages)

Capital Punishment And The Death Penalty Essay

- All countries at some point in time in their history have carried out or used the “death penalty” also known as Capital Punishment. In today’s time however more than two-thirds of the world’s nationalities some seventy-six countries have abandoned the use of the “death penalty”. Of the countries that still have Capital Punishment on the books it is reserved for all but the most heinous of crimes such as crimes of war, treason or insurrection crimes. In the United States juveniles, the mentally infirm and those that can prove certain mitigating circumstances are immune from imposition of death, however in 2003 thirteen prisoners were executed and another twenty-six were scheduled to die....   [tags: Crime, Capital punishment, Prison, Murder]

Strong Essays
1963 words (5.6 pages)

How to Best Manage Juvenile Offenders Essay

- ... “The primary difference between juvenile courts and adult courts was that the juvenile courts were ‘civil’ in nature while adult courts were ‘criminal’.” (djs.state.md.us) Rehabilitative procedures remained steady until the 1980s when juvenile crime made a violent upsurge, instigating public opinion to deviate from genteel practices. Legal professionals once again began prosecuting the delinquents as adults, thus sending them to criminal court, and potentially adult prison. “But Scott and Steinberg note that lawmakers and the public appear now to be rethinking their views once more....   [tags: delinquents, punishment, crime]

Strong Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Juveniles And Juvenile Justice System Essay

- In most cases, the arrest of a juvenile will be handed over to the juvenile justice system. The juvenile justice system places an emphasis on rehabilitation, education, and treatment of the convicted offenders. Juveniles’ records are confidential and more easily esponged. This will hopefully allow these kids to turn their life around for the better. The adult justice system focuses on punishment, which does not emphasize sending convicts down the right path once, or if, they are released. Juveniles commit sixteen percent of violent crimes that lead to an arrest....   [tags: Prison, Crime, Capital punishment, Penology]

Strong Essays
1494 words (4.3 pages)

Juvenile Death Penalty Essay

- A 16 year old boy is at the peak of their adolescent life, learning and discovering about puberty, maturity, right and wrong and future life goals. On the other hand, a man of 25 has matured, lived long enough to have made both good and bad judgments and has already been in the process of achieving those life goals they once thought of as a teenager. In a given situation, is it ethical to hold these two age groups, with mentalities that are worlds apart, to the same standards and punishments in the justice system....   [tags: capital punishment, death penalty]

Strong Essays
3657 words (10.4 pages)

Should the Death Penalty Apply to Juvenile Criminals? Essay

- Day after day in this country there is a debate going on about the death penalty and whether we as people have the right to decide the fate of another persons life. When we examine this issue we usually consider those we are arguing about to be older men and women who are more than likely hardened criminals with rap sheets longer than the height we stand (Farley & Willwerth, 1998). They have made a career of crime, committing it rather than studying it, and somewhere along the line a jury of their peers decided enough was enough....   [tags: Juvenile Delinquency]

Strong Essays
2773 words (7.9 pages)