Caning in Singapore Schools to Be Replaced by Non-Violent Disciplines Essay

Caning in Singapore Schools to Be Replaced by Non-Violent Disciplines Essay

Length: 2147 words (6.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Caning in Singapore Schools to Be Replaced by Non-Violent Disciplines
A recent article in The Asian Parent Magazine reports that a student was publicly caned in a Singapore secondary school for repeatedly being late, and several Singaporean parents criticized the school policy on this issue (Chin, 2012, p.1). Such reports have been raising controversies on whether the Singapore Ministry of Education should continue allowing schools to administer such disciplinary action, a traditional corporal punishment since 1957 under the Schools Regulation Act. Canees are punished for offences such as theft, bullying, and vandalism of school facilities. Senior administrative staff in school can carry out for up to three hard strokes on the palm or on the buttocks with a light cane private, in class, or publicly during a school assembly. Many Singaporean educators and parents believe this form of correction is an appropriate disciplinary action. Meanwhile critics believe that it is an inhumane and ineffective method to teach the students how to behave (Sudderuddin, 2009, p.3). The Singapore Ministry of Education should abolish caning in school, because the canees could experience long-term psychological fallout and delinquent behaviors, it is educationally unproductive, it infringes children’s human rights, and abolition could improve Singapore’s international reputation.
Caning in front of class or school can cause destructive consequences on the students’ psychological health and emotional development. Researchers have found that corporal punishment can provoke depressive symptoms on school-aged children. They have also suggested that corporal punishment can harm the proper development of the children’s self-concept, lower their confidence,...


... middle of paper ...


...probably be a good idea for Singapore to find non-violent disciplinary methods to substitute such physical punishment. It could be difficult at the beginning and it takes time and effort to install effective alternative systems. However, there are successful instances in many other regions of the world, such as Sweden and Taiwan, from which Singapore could learn the strategies. If the discipline system in Singapore schools has smoothly reformed and achieved noteworthy results, the students would be enormously benefited. Moreover, the educational system itself would be considerably rewarded by nurturing more responsible and self-disciplined future citizens for the nation and by a better international recognition as a reputable education hub. Therefore, the Minister of Education of Singapore should abolish its caning policy and replace it with non-violent alternatives.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis of Singapore's Economy Recovery Essay

- If I was the consultant of Singapore, the economy would continue to grow fast as the country will keep its focus on Technology, Communications and Media as Subsistence. The Republic of Singapore is the second-smallest country in Asia and consists of Singapore Island and several smaller islands off the southern tip of the Malay Peninsula. Singapore’s geographic location gives it strategic importance in the region. It is mostly low lying and hilly, with sections of rain forest, and mangrove groves....   [tags: singapore, tcm industry, telecommunications]

Powerful Essays
2593 words (7.4 pages)

Essay on Keeping Singapore Clean

- The slogan “Singapore, a clean and green city” is not there for nothing. Singapore, one of the world’s busiest port and city with a constantly increasing population of over 4 million people, is also one of the world’s cleanest countries. Singapore has been constantly coming up with new campaigns to remind Singaporeans to keep the county clean. There is also recycling campaigns which promotes the 3’R’s, reuse, recycle, reduce. Such campaigns have been proved successful with the amount of litter on the streets decreasing as time goes by....   [tags: Singapore, environment]

Powerful Essays
669 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Singapore And The Republic Of Singapore

- Singapore, or the Republic of Singapore, is an island nation located just off the southern coast of Malaysia. This southeastern city-state is separated from its northern neighbor by the Johore Strait. Singapore is separated from Indonesia on the south side by the Singapore Strait (Ho, Winstedt, Leinbach, & Kenndard, 2016). The advanced logistics infrastructure of Singapore supports continued business growth and attraction to the developing country (“Comparing Logistics Infrastructure of Countries in ASEAN,” 2007)....   [tags: Singapore, Malaysia, Southeast Asia]

Powerful Essays
782 words (2.2 pages)

Students Should Not Be Disciplined Essay

- As a future educator I believe that all students who misbehave in the classroom must be disciplined in some matter. I believe in disciplining students with non-controlling methods to change the student’s behaviors with the goal of having the student’s accept ownership of their misbehavior. A non-controlling method I would use is Gordon’s six-step approach that would assist me with the first steps to understand and correct my student ’ s misbehavior. I believe that all students are good and can be good if they choose to be....   [tags: Education, Teacher, Discipline, School]

Powerful Essays
1051 words (3 pages)

Essay on Singapore, The Republic Of Singapore

- Singapore, officially named the Republic of Singapore, is an island country, composed of 63 islands, and city-state in Southeast Asia, located just off the southern tip of the Malay Peninsula and only 85 miles north of the equator. Singapore has made a name for itself as one of the world 's most important commercial hubs, financial centers, and busiest ports. The economy of Singapore primarily depends on trade, particularly manufacturing. “Singapore’s economy is vibrant, competitive, and innovative....   [tags: Singapore, Malaysia, Southeast Asia]

Powerful Essays
1401 words (4 pages)

Economics Of Singapore Essay

- Introduction The Republic of Singapore celebrated its 42 years of independence in year 2007. Situated at the southern tip of Malaysia, Singapore currently holds a population of 4.68 million as of June 2007. At 704.0km2, it is ranked 4th in the world for its population density. During the past four decades, the economy as measured by real Gross Domestic Product (GDP), multiplied by over 20 times (Ghesquiere, 2007, p.11). As a small and extremely open economy, Singapore long term survival is very much dependent on the ability to maintain its viable position and remain afloat in the sea of global competition (Mun Heng et al, 1998, p.14)....   [tags: Singapore Economy ]

Powerful Essays
1537 words (4.4 pages)

Singapore Essay examples

- In a sense, Singapore has always been driven by neoliberal ideology. In the 1960s and 1970s, Singapore’s economic competitiveness was based upon its ability to generate low-cost manufacturing assembly, its political stability, and geographical location (Yeung, 2000: 142). However, by the 1980s, Singapore was being outcompeted by other developing Asian countries, and met this ‘competitiveness crunch’ with national strategies promoting high-tech business services (Yeung, 2000: 142). Rigorous infocomm programmes were enacted as early as 1980, the IDA maintained sustained drives to promote and educate their citizens regarding ICTs....   [tags: Philosophy, Neoliberal Ideology]

Powerful Essays
1274 words (3.6 pages)

Singapore Essay example

- Can Singapore be described in terms of a Foucauldian ‘disciplinary society’ or a Deleuzian ‘control society’. Deleuze proposed that we are in the midst of shift from Foucault’s ‘society of discipline’ to a ‘society of control’ (1992: 3). Unlike the ‘disciplinary society’ where subjects progress from one ‘moulding’ institution to another (schools, college, factories, offices, etc.), a ‘control society’ is typified by constant modulation (Wise, 2002: 32). According to Rose, control operates by affiliating subjects to a variety of practices which by design encourage adherence to certain norms in modern liberal societies (2000: 325)....   [tags: Politics, Social Control ]

Powerful Essays
1976 words (5.6 pages)

Singapore Essay example

- How might the Singapore society differ were it not for these technologies – would the society be more or less heavily regulated. Lee recommends analysing politics and society by addressing how power struggles and relations were played out in the pre-Internet era, namely the maintenance of political control via public support (2005: 74). Foucault defines ‘governmentality’ as the point of contact where the technologies of power interact with the governed. This spurs Lee to postulate that, in order to retain power in the Internet era, 'governments need to be actively involved in shaping the design as well as the societal, cultural and regulatory environment in which the Internet and other new...   [tags: Singapore Politics, Government]

Powerful Essays
1910 words (5.5 pages)

Essay Singapore's Economy

- Singapore’s recent economic history Singapore is well located for international industry and trading. The development of the Singapore economy depends heavily on foreign capital, foreign technology and foreign workers. Foreign companies are attracted by an interesting tax system. The foreign investors profit from the fact that they pay lower tax rates than local residents. The Singaporean government has a big influence on the social and economic development. The authorities organized for example trainings for Singaporean workers in order to obtain trained, highly motivated residents....   [tags: Singapore Business Economics]

Powerful Essays
1093 words (3.1 pages)