Wurtman’s paper (2011) “can genes really make you fat?” describes the discovery of the FTO gene, which is supposed to be the causative agent of obesity among people. The article goes on to explain that those with the gene, which only adds 1kg (2.2lbs) to your overall weight, are 23% more likely to be obese than those without. Wurtman (2011) feels that if people know they have the FTO gene, then they will be more motivated to exercise and be healthier overall. Although what this paper is suggesting may be true in some cases, overall calculating an individuals Body Mass Index (BMI) is a better determinant of obesity of a subject.
I feel that BMI is a better course of action to determine obesity in individuals rather than the FTO process. For a gene that only adds 1kg cannot determine the percentage of people with obesity within the population. Even companies such as the Heart and Stroke foundation use BMI to determine whether someone suffers from obesity. Now keep in mind obesity and overweight have different meanings, obesity leads to other disease such as cardiovascular disease, Diabetes and stroke, whereas overweight is where you have a few extra pounds on you compared to your height. Daniels (2009) states that calculating BMI is the recommended approach used to determine whether children or adolescence are obese. This being a large concern for Canada, and the world, as obesity rates are rising and it is difficult to believe this because the FTO gene, as described in Wurtman’s paper, is more common and that those individuals are just exercising less.
I feel that it is possible to be obese without this gene. Becoming obese, for the most part, is due to overeating and lack of exercise. BMI is a practical and cheaper way to det...
... middle of paper ...
...besity. I must disagree with this because of how lazy our society has become. Wurtman (2011) stated that people were becoming more obese and Bar-or (2000) said that it is rising in children too; clearly this is becoming an epidemic. Overall, I feel that people wait until they are already suffering from cardiovascular disease and diabetes, before they get help and at this point, it is to late. I believe that the way to collect data to determine if someone has the FTO gene or not is to invasive, and there are better alternatives. Where I agree with Daniels (2009) that collection of height and weight is much less invasive and it determines a simple number, if within a certain range this will let you know how at-risk you are of obesity. Unlike testing for the gene, it is easier and more adequate to determine your BMI and control your food portions and physical activity.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- It isn't unfamiliar that obesity is a problem in the United States. Fast food is said to be a major cause of this predicament, but is there a point where it's not the food's fault but the person who is choosing to eat it. People who have problems with obesity and blame fast food don't realize there are so many other attributes that are put into play and that fast food can't possibly be the only reason of it all. Obesity can be influenced by lack of exercise, the surrounding environment, genes, health conditions, cruel kindness, and diet.... [tags: obesity, body fat]
1026 words (2.9 pages)
- When it comes to the topic of a Fat Tax for being overweight in the United States, most of us will readily agree that people should not be taxed for being overweight or obese. Where this agreement usually ends, however, is on the topic of how overweight and obese people will have a higher risk of health problems such as diabetes, heart disease, high blood pressure and/or a stroke. Being taxed for being overweight is outrageous because they could be suffering from depression or have an eating disorder, but it is true that some of them could be really lazy and just eat a lot.... [tags: Nutrition, Obesity, Dieting, Physical exercise]
1699 words (4.9 pages)
- ... Nine out of ten of the patients with Anorexia are girls. Most people develop Anorexia a few years after puberty, or when growing into young adults. However, having Anorexia might be related to something in your genes. Studies show that most people who have family members which have Anorexia are likely to have it themselves. Even though Anorexia can be treated, the later the sickness is treated, the harder it is to recover. 40% of patients will develop Bulimia Nervosa later during their lifetime.... [tags: fat, skinny, eating, disorder, worth]
572 words (1.6 pages)
- ... Sorensen states in her article “Obesity occurs in over one-third of adults age 20 or over. […]More remarkable is the dramatic weight increase in America’s adolescent youth.” The obesity epidemic is affecting most people regardless of their gender, age, and geographical location. Moreover, obesity is the first step to many chronic diseases like cancer, heart attacks, and diabetes. Also it leads to efficacious psychological and social disorders like depression. According to Eric A. Finkelstein, Justin G.... [tags: fat, active, eat, menu, choices, food]
806 words (2.3 pages)
- What is a gene. From outside in, we will work towards what a gene is, how they work and where they have come from. In the following paragraphs we will look at what is a gene. DNA In every prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell on the earth, there is deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). In eukaryotic cells the DNA is contained within the nucleus of the cell. Eukaryotic organisms containing mitochondria also have extra DNA as mitochondria replicate by themselves without any instruction form the nucleus of the cell.... [tags: Genes, eukaryotic, prokaryotic, DNA]
1334 words (3.8 pages)
- As I was listening to the podcast, I found that I really liked the arguments that the author was making regarding science and the mistakes that were made in the past, particularly in the dietary recommendations adopted by the nutritional field. Since the purpose of her book The Big Fat Surprise: Why Butter, Meat, and Cheese Belong in a Healthy Diet is to disprove the “myth” that fats (including butter, meat, and cheese) do not belong in a healthy diet, her book includes evidence that supports the opposite view of the issue (that these products can belong in a healthy diet).... [tags: Nutrition, Health, Epidemiology, Fat]
779 words (2.2 pages)
- The film that I chose was My Big Fat Greek Wedding. The movie is a romantic comedy about a 30-year-old single woman Toula living in Chicago with her family. As a Greek girl, being raised by a very traditional Greek family she always wanted to be like the other girls instead of going to Greek School she wanted to attend traditional public school and eat American. She was looked down upon by her family because she was supposed to be married to a Greek man, have Greek children, and feed people, which she had not yet accomplished at 30.... [tags: Sociology, Culture, My Big Fat Greek Wedding]
943 words (2.7 pages)
- Are processed foods created by science really healthy. In Michael Pollan’s book, Food Rules, Pollan suggests that science is controlling our dietary choices resulting in poor health. Pollan further suggests that we need to revert to a more traditional diet form. Unfortunately, we have become accustomed to trusting scientists and believing what we are told to be true. These scientists attended many years of schooling to learn their profession . They do research to come up with the right answers to nagging questions.... [tags: Nutrition, Fat, Eating, Food]
1162 words (3.3 pages)
- (2)Weakness The evidence was found from other papers,and there are some methodology drawbacks.When compared the low fat and low carbohydrate diet,researcher collect data from 17 trails without specific patient-level data.The other research based on the CHD rate only had 148 men and women participants and only 119 of them finished the trail,so that the sample size is not representative to draw a conclusion.Moreover,the result is lack of heart disease end point.The trail for women was lack of long-term intervention data.It just focus on women aged 50-79,the data can not represent all age groups.When focus on saturated fat，the trail collect the data from 6 RCT,but only one of them had healt... [tags: Nutrition, Fatty acid, Saturated fat, Fat]
1213 words (3.5 pages)
- Are genetic factors more likely to make one person perform violent acts. Many doctors and researchers in the field of genetics have searched for a answer to this question. During 1989-93 one such researcher named Dr. Sullivan found some interesting points about genetics and crime. Sullivan while working for the Bush administration’s secretary of health and human services during 1989-1993 was appalled by the epidemic of violent crimes he saw taking place in American cities. According to Dr. Sullivan, "more than 26,000 Americans were murdered, and six million violent crimes were committed with young men and minorities falling victim most frequently".... [tags: Genetics and Crime]
906 words (2.6 pages)