Business Theory Comparison Essay

Business Theory Comparison Essay

Length: 749 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

1. What is the purpose of business? This question can have an endless amount of answers and they all can be correct. The goal will not be to find a definite answer but to explore four main business ethics theories to get a better understanding of what the purpose of business is.
2. A solely profit based business model would define stockholder theory in which the paramount goal of the business is to produce the most earnings for their stockholders. Prioritizing profits over a positive public image Goldman Sachs becomes an excellent example of stockholder theory. Entitlement and Desert theory can be used to support stockholder theory.
3. When stock is purchased in a company that person is entitled to the profits or loses that those shares in stock are worth, entitlement theory supports stockholder theory in which stockholders are entitled to reap the benefits of stock as long as it has been purchased justly. Desert theory states that if the action is morally right, then the person should be able to reap the benefits and take the loses. Stockholder theory supports this as being a stockholder in a company is morally accepted, but if an unethical act is preformed in buy or selling stock Desert Theory would not support Stockholder Theory. When Martha Stewart was arrested for insider trading she demonstrated that doing an in-moral act voids Desert Theory.
4. Stockholder theory revolves around pleasing one stakeholder, the stockholders; Stakeholder Theory broadens up that view to try and please all of the stakeholders. The Ben and Jerry's company was a good example of Stakeholder Theory as they kept the pay differences between the CEO and lowest paid worker to only ten fold. Utilitarianism and Virtue Ethics Theory can be used to suppo...

... middle of paper ...

...n company and benefit from the earnings that stock can bring.
9. Stockholder and Stakeholder Theory being vastly different become the extremes on a business ethics spectrum, between these lie the Kantian Minimum view and Rawlsian Position. Kantian Minimum view lies closer to Stockholder view, but the main difference is to not treat any stakeholder group as a mere means to a end. The Rawlsian Position lies closer to Stakeholder view in which life is not fair, but if you did not have knowledge in what position you would be in, you would choose the situation that would benefit your best interest. Upon overview of the four views the Rawlsian Position would be most ethically justified. It is benefiting from net happiness in which there is no vast difference between stakeholder groups, and there is also room for promotion between groups as all stakeholders are not even.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Comparison of a Coal Mining Company to an Autocracy Essay

- A Comparison of a Coal Mining Company to an Autocracy A tragic event occurred on April 5, 2010 in Montcoal, West Virginia. Twenty-nine miners went underground on the morning of April 5, 2010, similar to every work day, except this morning was their last. Upper Big Branch Mine was owned and operated by Massey Energy Corporation, a company that never took other people’s lives and families into consideration. The disastrous explosion could have easily been prevented if Massey Energy Company followed the necessary safety measures that were invented to prevent deaths and accidents....   [tags: Economics, Business Theory]

Better Essays
1988 words (5.7 pages)

Business Policy Essay

- Strategic decisions are the decisions that are made within the entire operational roles within a corporation. They deal with the entire resources as well as the human capital within a corporation and act as the interface between the resources and the human capital (Kuhn, 2006). They entail the major resource propositions for a corporation (Baden-Fuller, 2004). This may entail the taking into possession new resources as well as organizing and reallocating other resources. Further to the above role, strategic decisions ensure there is harmony in regards to the organizational resource capabilities in contrast to its threats and opportunities....   [tags: Business Management ]

Better Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

British Airway Dispute Theory and Practice Essay

- BA Dispute Theory and Practice 1. Introduction Since the 1980s the situation in the civil aviation industry has changed dramatically, and although the government still retains some form of in-direct control over the aviation sector and the ‘former’ national airlines in specific, issues related to economization and efficiency of the business enterprise take primacy in dictating strategic and operational decisions of the airline operators. This shift in the approach to the regulation of the aviation sector around the globe has also greatly influenced issues related to workforce organization in this industry, especially in the Western world....   [tags: Business Analysis ]

Better Essays
1947 words (5.6 pages)

Efficient Market Theory and Behavioural Finance Essay

- The behaviour of markets and investors, the decision making in the market place and the dynamics of demand and supply in any given market cannot be determined with a hundred percent accuracy. However master minds in the past have designed various techniques and theories that help investors make a particular buying decision, or to make choices logically. These theories and techniques help today’s investors to peep into the future and make almost immaculate predictions regarding the future behaviour of the market and the ongoing trends....   [tags: Business, Global Financial Crisis]

Better Essays
1796 words (5.1 pages)

Theory on Marketing for Great Wall X-Series Essay

- Introduction As requested by the marketing manager for Great Wall Motors this report relates the theory of marketing to the Great Wall X-series and evaluates the current marketing mix with a view to making suggestions and recommendations regarding current tactics. Great Wall Motors has been recognized for over a decade in China as the market leader in dual cab utes and SUVs and continues to build a reputation for producing tough and reliable vehicles. Employing over 22,000 people, exporting to more than 120 countries, investing heavily in state-of-the-art technology, a strong research and development program, it’s not surprising that Great Wall Motors is producing highly specified, well buil...   [tags: Business Marketing Analysis]

Better Essays
2023 words (5.8 pages)

Contingency Theory Essay

- In this assignment I shall discuss three theories explaining structure choice; management choice, population ecology theory and contingency theory including their strengths and weaknesses. I shall outline and compare functional and team structures as they are the two greatest opposites, using sources to support or disprove statements. Comparisons will then be made between centralised and decentralised structures, commenting on how they relate to the contingencies outlined by the contingency theory whilst also taking into account related issues such as motivation and competitiveness....   [tags: Business Management ]

Better Essays
1886 words (5.4 pages)

Comparison Between Two Episodes of the Shows Bing Bang Theory and Fresh Mean

- How are characters are identified. The Big Bang Theory: (BB) Simon Helberg (as Howard Wolowitz): short geek with thick hair but no glasses on. Kunal Nayyar (as Rajesh “Raj” Koothrappali) The only asian guy with a strong indian accent. Melissa Rauch = (as Bernadette Rostenkowski-Wolowitz) she is the short blonde witha squeaky voice. Mayim Bialik (as Amy Fowler Emily) brunette so fiesty, empowered and outspoken. Fresh Meat: (FM) Jack Peter Benedict Whitehall (as Jonathan Pembersley, JP): As the tall guy who is a posh wannabe....   [tags: TV, Shows, College]

Better Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)

A Comparison of Classical Management Theorists and Contingency Theorists

- A Comparison of Classical Management Theorists and Contingency Theorists The management field is characterised by a wide variety of theories, schools and directions. This essay examines the classical and contingency schools of thought -- the approaches to organization that have had the greatest impact on management today. Firstly the essay delineates and criticises the important theories propounded by classical writers. The essay continues with an account of the contingency school, and finally evaluates its impacts on managerial thought....   [tags: Business Management Studies Managing]

Better Essays
2637 words (7.5 pages)

A Comparison of George Orwell's Totalitarian World of 1984 and America in 2004

- Orwell's Totalitarian World of 1984 is America in 2004 Orwell's allegorical critique of Stalinism in 1984 is often used in capitalist nations as a poignant literary attack on Communism and other collectivist economic and political systems. The argument often follows the lines of "This is socialism, and as you can see, it doesn't work and just leads to oppression. We're in a nice capitalist democracy, therefore we are better off." But is that conclusion the truth. Orwell didn't just intend 1984 as an attack on communism or socialism; instead it is both an attack and a rather prophetic warning against any authoritarian structure, including the authoritarian structure of capitalist demo...   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Better Essays
766 words (2.2 pages)

Unspoken Comparison in Tacitus's Germania Essay

- Unspoken Comparison in Tacitus's Germania Tacitus's Germania is a thoroughly itemized ethnographic text detailing the geography, climate and social structure of Germany and its people. Unlike his Histories and Annales Tacitus doesn't offer a story line to be followed, but instead, he nudges forth an unspoken comparison to be made between two cultures. Each of the Germania's 46 passages deals with a particular area of German civilization among which Tacitus develops a two-tiered theme. The two points he tries to make generally clear are the following: A) The Germans are barbaric, savage and stupid…but… B) The Germans are quaint, noble and have some redeeming qualities that mak...   [tags: Germania]

Better Essays
2072 words (5.9 pages)