Business Regulation: Alumina

Business Regulation: Alumina

Length: 1685 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Business Regulation: Alumina Inc.

Since the creation of the Environmental Protection Agency in the 1970s, businesses in the US have been required to adhere to stringent federal environmental regulations. (Reed, 2005) Alumina Inc., a US-based aluminum manufacturing company, is not the exception. Alumina is faced with the challenge of remaining financially viable, while meeting EPA expectations, as well as stockholder expectations. The following is an analysis of those issues and opportunities as well as a proposed solution to the problems that face Alumina Inc. (University of Phoenix, 2008)
Situation Analysis
Issue Identification and Overview
Alumina Inc. is a USA-based aluminum maker with revenues in excess of $4 billion. Although 70% of Alumina’s sales derive from the USA, the company also boasts a substantial global reach with business ventures in eight countries worldwide. The company has customers, and other business interests, in the automotive components sector, manufacturing of packing materials, bauxite mining, alumina refining, and aluminum smelting.
Due to the nature of Alumina’s business, and the proximity of the company’s factory to Lake Dira, in the State of Erehwon, the company is heavily regulated by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The EPA’s goal is to “protect human health and environment.” (EPA, 2008) In this instance, the agency’s primary purpose is to ensure that Alumina maintains its responsibility to the environment and community by regulating, and monitorying the amount of harmful chemicals released into the surrounding water, air, and soil.
Five years ago, during a routine inspection, the EPA discovered that Alumina Inc. was in violation of environmental discharge norms. The agency’s report stated that Alumina discharged, into Lake Dira, higher than prescribed Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAH). However, following an EPA mandated clean up, subsequent evaluations determined that appropriate corrective actions were implemented and completed.
The company’s woes did not end there. Recently, a local woman claimed that Alumina continuously discharged unacceptable levels of PAH into the lake, and years of consuming this water resulted in her daughter’s leukemia. Enacting her “citizen enforcement rights” bestowed to all citizens by the EPA, the woman brought suit again Alumina for what she deemed to be unethical and irresponsible behavior resulting in her daughter’s illness. (Reed, 2005) Fortunately, through mediation the company was able to come to a win-win settlement. The woman and her family received payment for all medical bills and a trust was established for the daughter for future expenses. While the company was required to pay a substantial amount to the family, Alumina was able to avoid the cost of a legal battle which could “easily run into the tens of thousands of dollars for an organization.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Business Regulation: Alumina." 25 Jun 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Alumina Business Regulation Essay

- Alumina, Inc. is a USA-based aluminum maker that operates in eight countries around the world. The company receives 70% of its sales in the United States. Alumina's business interests include automotive components and manufacturing packaging materials, bauxite mining, alumina refining, and alumina smelting. Improper use of these materials can have an adverse affect on an environment and the people in the surrounding areas. Statutory and common laws are in place to govern businesses and how organizations do business....   [tags: Business Analysis Management]

Free Essays
1618 words (4.6 pages)

Business Regulation Simulation: Alumina Inc. Essay

- Business Regulation Simulation: Alumina Inc. Alumina is a 4 billion dollar aluminum manufacturer based in the US. Although the company operates out of 8 different countries, 70% of Alumina's sales derive from the US market. Five years ago, during a regular compliance inspection, Alumina was found to be in violation of environmental discharge norms due to high levels of PAH (Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon). Following this discovery, the EPA ordered a clean up and Alumina was found to be in compliance during subsequent inspections....   [tags: Business Regulation Simulation Analysis]

Free Essays
1026 words (2.9 pages)

Business Regulation: Alumina Essay

- Business Regulation: Alumina Inc. Since the creation of the Environmental Protection Agency in the 1970s, businesses in the US have been required to adhere to stringent federal environmental regulations. (Reed, 2005) Alumina Inc., a US-based aluminum manufacturing company, is not the exception. Alumina is faced with the challenge of remaining financially viable, while meeting EPA expectations, as well as stockholder expectations. The following is an analysis of those issues and opportunities as well as a proposed solution to the problems that face Alumina Inc....   [tags: Business Management Analysis]

Free Essays
1685 words (4.8 pages)

Business Regulation Study: Bates Versus Alumina Inc. Essay

- Business Regulation Study: Bates Versus Alumina Inc. Alumina Inc. has found itself on the receiving end of a lawsuit alleging that the company has repeatedly contaminated the waters of Lake Dira. A site study report completed by Alumina reveals the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PHA) levels are lower than the prescribed level of 5 milligrams per liter for all hydrocarbons ( University of Phoenix a , 2004). Although Alumina is not currently contaminating the lake, five years ago, the company was found to be in violation of environmental discharge norm during a routine EPA compliance....   [tags: Case Study, Business, Regulation, solution]

Free Essays
1812 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Alumina Inc Regulation Case Study

- Introduction Alumina Inc. (AI) is a U.S. based international aluminum company with eight locations worldwide, worth of $4 billion. Its business markets include “automotive components and manufacture of packaging materials, bauxite mining, alumina refining, and aluminum smelting” (University of Phoenix simulation, 2008) and the company falls under the following regulatory agencies and acts: The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), and Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA)....   [tags: Environmental Business Regulation]

Free Essays
2215 words (6.3 pages)

Alumina Inc: Recognizing And Minimizing Tort And Regulatory Risk Essay

- Alumina Inc. is a $4 billion aluminum maker, based in the United States and operates in eight countries around the world. The United States market constitutes of 70% of its sales. The company manufactures automotive components, alumina refining, bauxite mining and aluminum smelting. Alumina falls under the jurisdiction of region 6 of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). As the business manager in Alumina Inc., I am leading the effort in managing a crisis arising out of allegations of environmental damages....   [tags: Alumina Inc Case Study]

Research Papers
1171 words (3.3 pages)

Business Regulation Case Essay

- The challenges that surrounded Alumina, Inc. could have been detrimental to the corporation. Areas the management team needed to concentrate on were the corporation's image to the general public as well as competitors, current customers and potential customers. Management's duty was to manage the crisis by preventing extensive losses to the company while at the same time preserving the image of the company and doing right by the community. As a team we agreed upon the strategies and recommendations to solve the challenges for Alumina, Inc., although the timing of how the events would play out was slightly different....   [tags: Business Regulation]

Free Essays
1996 words (5.7 pages)

Alumina Inc: Recognizing And Minimizing Tort And Regulatory Risk Essay

- Many organizations contend with tort liability and management in the day-to-day business. The proper management and preventive measures to limit the organizations exposure tort liability has become a key to effective operating a business. This paper will identify the tort liability and regulatory risk of Alumina within a business plan to manage it. The prevention, detection, and corrective measures for each liability will be described. The best course of action to alleviate tort liability will be identified during this plan and the expected results of proper management for Alumina and any organization....   [tags: Alumina Inc Case Study]

Research Papers
1138 words (3.3 pages)

Business Regulation Simulation Essay

- Business Regulation Simulation Introduction According to the BNET business dictionary, regulation is “the use of laws or rules stipulated by a government or regulatory body, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission, to provide orderly procedures and to protect consumers and investors.” (BNET, 2008) Business regulation is not limited to these sorts of issues, though. As is the case with Alumina, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) also sets standards that need to be enforced to protect the business as well as the community in which it operates....   [tags: Business Management]

Free Essays
1387 words (4 pages)

Business Regulation Simulation Essay

- Business Regulation Simulation Situation Analysis Issue and Opportunity Identification Alumina Inc. is $4 billion manufacturing company operating in eight different countries around the world with the United States accounting for nearly 70% of their sales. Based in Erehwon near Lake Dira they manufacture packaging materials for the automotive industry, bauxite mining, alumina refining and aluminum smelting. The key players of the organization are Roger Lloyd Chairman, Chris Blake COO, Diane Richards Head of Public Relations and Arthur Todd Legal Council....   [tags: Business Management Finance Analysis Strategy]

Research Papers
1947 words (5.6 pages)

These costs often include expert witness fees, attorneys’ fees, lost employee productivity, and court fees. In addition, there is the uncertainty and risk associated with the outcome of the litigation.” (University of Phoenix, 2008) Moreover, choosing Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) to settle the woman’s claim allowed the company to avoid public scrutiny, as often times, court battles become front-page fodder. Additionally, “the publicity generated from a court battle, especially one brought about by a citizen, could cause significant harm to the organization and its reputation, especially if the organization is defeated in court.” (University of Phoenix, 2008) The cost of negative publicity can often be more detrimental than those of monetary value.
Stakeholder Perspectives/Ethical Dilemmas
All organizations have groups, or stakeholders, to whom they are responsible. These stakeholders are keenly aware of all, or most, of the decisions, financials, and ethical behavior of the corporation and its senior leadership, as these elements directly affect them. In the case of Alumina, there are many groups with certain stakes in how the company behaves and performs. For the purpose of this exercise, the focus will be on senior leadership, employees, customers, and community.
The first group to mention is Alumina’s senior leadership. This group has been called upon to enact their rights and responsibilities to direct the company in a way that will ultimately result in increased profits, larger revenues, and a greater competitive advantage for the company. Additionally, the group has a personal stake in the successful outcome of the company, as it would reflect negatively on them otherwise. The senior leadership team has the responsibility to act ethically in all business dealings. In doing so, the company will likely continue to be successful as “some of the most profitable businesses have also historically been the most ethical.” (Reed, 2005. pg 50)
Another group, with a significant stake in the business, is the employees of Alumina. This hardworking group has been the backbone of the organization. Primarily a blue-collar and manufacturing oriented workforce, they value being treated fairly by the company, and seem to trust the decisions of senior leadership. The group values job stability and expects the company to act in a fiscally responsible and environmentally ethical manner as not to jeopardize their positions with the firm.
One must also consider the company’s customers as stakeholders. The company’s customers, those who receive Alumina’s services and products, value the best product or service at the best price. The group also values new, innovative products with the utmost quality. This group has the right to, and expects the best customer service possible. Additionally, Alumina customers expect to be informed of changes in the company’s products and services.
Lastly, and seemingly at the heart of the issue, is the community which surrounds Alumina’s factory. This group is comprised of members from the aforementioned groups. This group sees little value in revenues and stock prices, but rather expects the company to be environmentally ethical above all. They expect the company to conduct business in a safe manner. Additionally, they expect the company to be honest and open regarding EPA regulations and infractions in that regard.
As evidenced above, these groups have different expectation for the company, as well as different ethical values and standards. Most striking is the ethical dilemma between Alumina and the community within which the organization operates. The company has accepted the discharge of “acceptable” amounts of PAH into the neighboring lake as a cost of doing business. From their perspective, it would be cost prohibitive to attempt to eliminate all PAH discharge from the company’s daily operations. Conversely, members of the community regard any discharge of PAH as unethical and potentially deadly. They believe that PAH should be eliminated at any cost.

Risk Assessment and Mitigation Techniques
In order to be considered a truly ethical company, Alumina’s senior management must “recognize and take into account the various stakeholders whose interests the corporation impacts,” especially those of the community. (Reed, 2005. pg 49) The following is a risk assessment of alternative solutions to the ethical dilemma facing Alumina.
The first alternative solution examined is the possibility of maintaining status quo. While this solution, at first glance, seems callus and malicious, the company desires to avoid the added costs of decreased discharge levels or monitoring current levels, and it is therefore very appealing to senior leadership. However, this solution is wrought potential risks as it does not parallel the values and expectations of the community. By selecting this solution, the company is at risk of further litigation from the members of the community. Associated with more litigation are court costs, negative public image, and probability of decreased business. If senior management chooses to maintain the status quo, the company will risk future financial stability.
The second alternative, and optimal, solution is derived from the subscription that “an ethical organization is a basic business asset.” (Reed, 2005, pg 50) To become recognized as an ethical business, Alumina’s senior management must hold the company to higher standards and only allow much lower than acceptable levels of PAH discharge. Additionally, to demonstrate to the community, customers, employees, and other stockholders the company’s commitment to ensuring a safe and healthy environment, the company will establish a new internal EPA standards office. The newly formed department will create company policy regarding work practices vis-à-vis environment protection. Also, this group will be responsible for conducting bi-annual evaluations of the company’s compliance to corporate environmental policies, as well as EPA policies. To offset the cost of this new venture, senior management will seek community funding to decrease the levels of PAH discharge from both the factory and the increased traffic. This solution results in a win-win scenario for all stakeholders, especially between the company and the community.
Not unlike many companies doing business in today’s environmentally conscious world, Alumina Inc. is faced with the challenge of balancing the goal of financial viability with the ethical commitments to its stakeholders. The future state of the company depends solely on Alumina’s senior leadership’s ability to effectively manage that balancing act. By implementing a community conscious environmental protection strategy, Alumina will be able to fulfill its financial goals while also securing their community’s confidence.


EPA. 2008. About EPA – US EPA. Retrieved on September 13, 2008 from
Reed, O.L., Shedd, P.J., Morehead, J.W., & Corley, R.N. (2004). The legal and regulatory environment of business (13th ed.). New York: The McGraw-Hill Companies.
University of Phoenix . ( 2007). Business Regulation Simulaton [Computer Software]. Retrieved September 14, 2008, from University of Phoenix, Simulation, MBA560 - Enterprise Risk Web site

Risk Analysis Matrix
Alternative Solution Risks and Probability Consequence and Severity Mitigation Techniques and Strategies
Continue to discharge “acceptable” levels of PAH…status quo • More litigation
• Negative public image
• Accidental discharge of higher than acceptable levels
• High • Increased costs associated with legal battles
• Decreased business due to negative image
• Overall decrease in revenue as a result of the above points
• High • Provide evaluation reports to the public to show the lack of danger
• Seek other ADR methods to avoid public scrutiny

Hold the company to higher standards and allow much lower than acceptable levels of PAH discharge • Inability to effectively decrease levels
• Cost prohibitive
• Medium • Increase cost=decreased revenue
• Displeased community
• Medium • Perform bi-annual audits with newly formed internal EPA standards team
• Seek community funds to assist in decreasing PAHs from both the company and increased traffic
Return to