Essay on Brooklyn and the short story Silence

Essay on Brooklyn and the short story Silence

Length: 1043 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the novel Brooklyn and the short story Silence, both of the lead female characters live their lives in silence. Although, they have very strong feelings towards the things they experience, they do not outright express them to anyone. Neither one of them really lets anyone in to know how they are feeling; they hold in their emotions. Eilis from the novel Brooklyn is being sent to America for work by her mother and sister. She is opposed and she wished her sister would take her place. Instead of voicing her feelings to her family she keeps quite and goes along with what they have planned for her. When Lady Gregory from Silence was cheating on her husband and realized she didn’t really like him much she also kept quite. Lady Gregory’s story took place in the 1880’s and Eilis’ takes place in the 1900’s. During these times women were limited in power and this explains their characteristic of being submissive.

In the early 1900’s and long before then women were not treated equally to men. Your feelings were not valid because of your gender and any ideas or beliefs you had were ignored. In the novel Brooklyn and the short story Silence the female characters show just how unfairly a woman was treated. Eilis from Brooklyn was a very indecisive and submissive main character. She allowed others to make important life decisions for her. Specifically, when her sister Rose decides to send her from Ireland to America to work. (Toibin, pg 27) Lady Gregory from Silence knew her intelligence, but was also aware she couldn’t upstage her husband. If her husband and his colleagues were discussing a topic she had knowledge on she couldn’t speak, because she had to seem feeble minded. “She had read all the latest books and she chose her words slowl...

... middle of paper ... and afraid to speak their minds. Our society has grown tremendously and allows women and men to be considered each other’s equals. Women are now allowed to do things they could never dream of before 1920’s. Women no longer need to fall silent when there is something they need to say.

Works Cited

• "The Fight for Women's Suffrage." A&E Television Networks, n.d. Web. 09 Dec. 2013.
• "Gender Roles in the 20th Century." By Megan Worley. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Dec. 2013.

• Toibin, C. (2009). Brooklyn. New York, NY: Scribner.
• Toibin, C. (2011). Silence. New York, NY: Scribner.
• (n.d.). Retrieved from Amendment to the U.S. Constitution: Women's Right to Vote
• Social change in twentieth century ireland. (2008). Retrieved from

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Short Story : ' Silence Or Revolt ' Essay

- Silence or revolt Different environment makes people gradually different way of thinking and values, the roles have their own experience of background influence in the formation of their personality. Maggie and Dee has an opposite trait to generate their mother’s attitude toward different way. Alice has cleverly written with black people of generation complex attitude on the ideas and cultural heritage in Everyday Use. Mother-daughter relationship also is complicated in those two articles. In No Name Woman, the mother tells the daughter a story about her aunt and do not allow tell anyone else....   [tags: Culture, African American, Family, Black people]

Strong Essays
1007 words (2.9 pages)

The Story Of An Short Story By Kate Chopin Essay

- The short story novelist, Kate Chopin, enlightens her readers about the reality of many married women during the 1800s. Chopin 's story revolves around Mrs.Mallard who drastically loses her husband in an accident. Throughout the story, Chopin expresses the various emotional changes that her character Mrs.Mallard undergoes. Initially a humble housewife, Mrs. Mallard evolves into a confident women when exposed to freedom. Kate Chopin launches her short story by introducing the main character, Mrs....   [tags: Marriage, Short story, Husband, Wife]

Strong Essays
1180 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about What Is A Short Story?

- Short Stories What is a short story. A short story is a fictional piece of writing that can range from 1,000 to 20,000 words. Unlike a novel, he reader should be able to read a short story within a short amount of time. Because the length of a short story is shorter than a novel, it usually has one main character (minor characters can be added in limited amounts) and focuses on one plot, setting, and central theme. Why do we write short stories. The answer is simple, they’re practice. Almost all of the best writers started out writing short stories....   [tags: Short story, Fiction, Character, Essay]

Strong Essays
1087 words (3.1 pages)

Short Story : ' The Test ' Essay

- Short Story Re Do writing quiz Theme and stereotype Thesis statement The short story the Test and the frill both deal with the theme of how by human human being have predictive and stereotype other individuals and groups that is based on ignorance and limited educational experience . The driving instructor in the short story the Test is a stereotype of typical old fashioned Archie Bunker who is stubborn in his old fashioned views on race and sex . who has a old fashioned attitudes . The driving instructor is a stereotype of a white man who believes that whites are more educated and knowledgeable than African Americans ....   [tags: Short story, Fiction, Human, Guy de Maupassant]

Strong Essays
1004 words (2.9 pages)

Analysis Of Short Story ' A & P ' Essay example

- Critical Analysis of Short Story “A &P” In the short story “A & P” by John Updike, the main character Sammy shows a sense of growth from the story’s opening to its conclusion. This certain change in him started taking place after the visit from the three girls, where he starts to ponder the future of his life. Sammy develops as a more prominent character both by the voice and the mood of the story, suggesting his vast change from rather flat to someone with more personal features and attributes....   [tags: Short story, John Updike, John Cheever]

Strong Essays
1269 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Silence- Short Story

- Silence- Short Story “Aghhahahhhah!” screaming, Jade sprinted towards the exit door, she tried to push it open; but it wouldn’t obey her. Jade started to run around the library. She was petrified, scared as well as alone. The thing—or whatever it was gaining on her. She managed to halt, and then turn the corner. She stopped. Nothing— nothing was there; no door; no windows; just a blank black wide wall. She was stuck. Twisting her head, in front of her, stood the nightmare that she was running from....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
623 words (1.8 pages)

Silence And Insanity - Silence Insanity Essay

- Silence Insanity He wondered if he had gone mad. He covered his ears with both of his hands, but he could still hear the garbled voices that were echoing around the room. He sat for a moment behind his desk and slowed his breathing, telling himself that he was simply tired. A sudden knock at the door caused his heart to skip a beat and with trembling hands he opened it. "Boo!" His receptionist teased and then watched in dismay as he nearly jumped out of his skin. "Is everything alright Doctor Andersen....   [tags: Grandparent, Family, Storytelling, A Story]

Strong Essays
1612 words (4.6 pages)

Marianne Villanueva's Siko and Silence Essay

- The theme that will be explored in this essay will be the dominant culture, prevailing cultural attitudes, and the mental environment/state. The two short stories that will be discussed in this essay are Marianne Villanueva's Siko and Silence. In both short stories the leading characters show signs of breaking down because of physical, but also their mental stress. Marian Villanueva's Short stories Siko, and Silance can relate in many ways. For instance the main characters of both stories seem to face relatively similar struggle, but in different context....   [tags: Compare Contrast Short Story]

Free Essays
1306 words (3.7 pages)

Essay A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

-             A Tree Grows in Brooklyn is an appropriate name for the book. It’s about 7 years of Frances Nolan’s life. The book’s title is highly symbolical and took me several passes through it before I understood it completely. In the beginning of the book the author talks about the “Tree of Heaven”. “No matter where the seed fell, it made a tree which struggled to reach the sky”, is an excerpt from the first page of Book One. Until you finish the book or at least most of it you think the author is talking about a type of tree and the title makes absolutely positively no sense whatsoever because of that....   [tags: A Tree Grows in Brooklyn Essays]

Free Essays
471 words (1.3 pages)

Short Story Essay

- Synopsis On an afternoon, in the quarters of the sakadas, Mang Sixto is playing a guitar with the chords of an emotional song, "Walay Angay", while her daughter, is playing outside the quarters. They were indifferent of each other for a while, but there is a sudden change in the mood of the two. The daughter of Mang Sixto finally notices the chords that her father was playing and along with the music is her father's very emotional presence. They were then engaged in a sudden conversation. The daughter interrogated her father of the about the sad song he was playing along with his guitars....   [tags: Short Story]

Free Essays
1037 words (3 pages)