Broken Window Policing And Crime Rates Essay

Broken Window Policing And Crime Rates Essay

Length: 1477 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Kelling created Broken Window Policing to maintain clean and organized neighborhoods in order to decrease possible crimes. Kelling designed the theory using vague language, which allowed for multiple interpretations when designing broken window policing. Instead of reducing crime rates, this policy over criminalized small crimes. The results of broken window policing did not meet Kelling’s expectations, which resulted in him blaming the negative results of the policy on bad policing. But the negative outcomes of the policy did not arise from just bad policing; Kelling’s broken window policing opened the door for discriminatory practices, and fed the prison system. Not only is the policy problematic, but it has not lead to a decrease in crime rates. Broken window policing created new problems while not solving the original ones.
The problem with broken window policing starts with the study that informed the policy. In the study, they neglect to factor in the financial needs of their subjects. The study of Broken Window was based on the results received from higher income neighborhoods; in those neighborhoods financial circumstances are not crucial to families. Financial factors vary from neighborhood to neighborhood and even from family to family within the same neighborhoods. Ignoring this financial need in the areas where the studies were done lead to fundamental misunderstandings in the theory. The study generalizes the outcome of one broken window. Having a broken window on any property does not automatically lead to more broken windows, like suggested by the results of the cars placed in California and the Bronx. The level of desperation of families due to their financial circumstances leads to increasing crime rates. ...

... middle of paper ... restructured. Police officers should be retrained and taught how to treat people with special needs, and other circumstances. Police officers are trained to use harsh tactics designed for rapists and robbers. Cops should not treat a man selling untaxed cigarettes the same way they treat a rapist; they should have different attitudes for different people.
Such a problematic policy starts from a weak foundation. Kelling purposely made this policy ambiguous in order to leave it open for interpretation of each state willing to practice it, for that reason he was able to blame bad policing for the negative effects of the policy. The vagueness of the policy lead to all the problems the policy has, it created discriminatory practices, and unintentionally fed the prison system. Broken window policing did not decrease crime rate, what it intentionally was set to achieve.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Crime Rates, Trends, And Variations Essay

- Introduction Every day we tend to here that crime rate is up, or that it seem like crime is taking over America, but is that really true. What do we really know about the crime rate. Do we even understand how the FBI receive their information in regards to the UCR. And what do we understand about violent crime rates, trends, and variations. We will discuss these issues to gain a better understanding about the UCR system. FBI UCR for Georgia When I checked my state, which is GA and compared what I have been told by some of my associates from the Augusta Georgia Richmond Country Sheriff department it was what I expected, which was that crime rates where going down....   [tags: Crime, Violent crime, Crime in the United States]

Better Essays
988 words (2.8 pages)

Stop And Frisk The Policing Of Latinos Essay

- In the reading “Stop-and-Frisk The Policing of Latinos in New York” by Andres Garcia, he writes about how Latinos/as are major targets for police. He mentions the interview with the police officers, a member of Operation impact, which is the procedure that aims high crime areas and hot spots. In the text he mentions, “His patrolling consisted mostly of what the NYPD calls the Roosevelt Corridor, which at the time consisted mostly of the impact zone in the multi-ethnic, heavily Latino Queens neighborhood of Jackson Heights” (Garcia 37) meaning, police officers were sent to the places were higher crime rates would happen....   [tags: Police, Crime, Fixing Broken Windows]

Better Essays
1124 words (3.2 pages)

Community Policing : Police Enforcement Essay

- Community Policing is a type of police that changed traditional policing in the late 20th century in The United States and abroad. In 1994 President Clinton created Violent Crime and Law Enforcement Act that allowed the COPS(Community Oriented Policing Services) program was created Congressional Digest February 2015. Listed in (Understanding Community Policing find source...) the ‘key three common features: police-community partnerships, a problem-solving approach and organisational decentralisation’....   [tags: Police, Crime, Crime prevention, Constable]

Better Essays
1686 words (4.8 pages)

Community Policing And Its Effectiveness Essay

- Community policing has faced challenges in measuring the effectiveness of its strategies. Community policing has led to officers making fewer arrest (Mastrofski et al., 1995). Some people may see this as a positive thing, but critics of community policing may see this as a fault. Many officers are evaluated on how many criminals they get off the streets and the fact that less arrests are made by community policing officers can be a reason for skepticism. When it comes to serving the public with non-crime fighting services, community policing officers and regular officers seem not to have any difference in positive interaction of the people in the community, dealing with problems that citizen...   [tags: Crime, Police, Criminology, Crime prevention]

Better Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Theories on Why Crime Occurs Essay example

- ... Wilson and Kelling (1982) ascertains that disorder and fear are closely linked, because there is disorder there is a fear or perception of crime which leads to community members taking precautionary measures and unattended disordered causes a break down in community control (Wagers, Sousa, & Kelling, 2008, p.254). Broken windows theory suggests that areas that suffer community breakdown by disorder are more vulnerable to crime as disorder shows opportunity for potential offenders to commit crime....   [tags: Broken Window, society, routine activity, ]

Better Essays
1303 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Crime in Relation to Sustainability

- Crime in Relation to Sustainability When discussing the sustainability of a community, we must consider the economic, social, and environmental well-being of the community and how these affect present and future residents. The social aspect of community sustainability relates to the rise and fall of crime rate, volunteer effort, and the number of people running for offices that represent the community. The economical aspect relates to the number of good paying jobs, the poverty rate, and the ability of people to find homes that they can afford....   [tags: Crime Essays]

Better Essays
1462 words (4.2 pages)

Crime Decline Of New York City Essay

- Kelly Duffe Mr. Digiovanni November 25, 2014 Crime Decline in New York City There are many different theories that have developed to explain the steep decline in crime that began in the 1990’s following decades of the highest crime rates in history. There have been numerous studies and forums to gather, discuss, and interpret data. The one consensus among them all is that there is no easy answer to the question- why has the crime rate dropped. Some of the many factors that have been considered as possible contributors to the decline include- demographics, the drug market, the economy, increased policing efforts, incarcerations, handguns, lead paint and legalized abortion....   [tags: Crime, Violent crime, Criminology]

Better Essays
1053 words (3 pages)

Community Resource Teams and Their Impact on at Risk Youth Essay

- Community oriented policing is the proactive deployment method used by patrol officers in order to find solutions to why crime is occurring within a given community. Officers use their critical thinking and problem solving skills to analyze and uncover the underlying issues of a community that are posing threats to public safety and address ways this can be prevented. In many communities throughout the United States, police officers strive to build better relationships with community members, yet building relationships with youth within a community, especially a community over run by gangs, crime and drugs is a much tougher issue....   [tags: community policing, crime, drugs, ]

Better Essays
1981 words (5.7 pages)

The Correlation Between Crime And Crime Essay

- The ability to accurately predict the spatial distribution of crime, or the probability that a crime will occur in a given location, can reduce policing expenses, streamline administration, and most importantly, increase citizen and officer safety. Over 130,000 crimes were committed in Bloomington, Illinois from December 2002 to December 2012. The location and the severity of these crimes were submitted to spatial statistical software to generate a series of crime distribution maps and to perform spatial Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) tests to determine if the spatial patterns of crime vary from year to year, between seasons, or with the time of day....   [tags: Statistics, Statistical significance]

Better Essays
1100 words (3.1 pages)

Police Shootings : A Common Connection Between Crime And Poverty Essay

- From Oakland to Orlando, the nationwide unjust of unarmed black men has spread like wildfire. Multiple instances of police shootings have taken place over recent years with the resting victims including Oscar Grant, Trayvon Martin and numerous others. The brutality that is being shown on display to the world via 20-second long clips we see on the news can barely speak for how gruesome and vile these acts are. The reaction from celebrities, the community and the media have been pouring in for years, as all we can hope for is a change....   [tags: White people, African American, Race]

Better Essays
774 words (2.2 pages)