Brokeback Mountain

Brokeback Mountain

Length: 1242 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The major plot outline in both the short story and the movie
The central drama and point of conflict in any love story is the obstacle between the lovers. In the best known tragic love story in Western history, Romeo and Juliet, the obstacle is their feuding families; in the classic film Casablanca it's virtue and in Brief Encounter, it's the marriage of one of the lovers. This is a story of unfulfilled love in Wyoming. Ennis and Jack, a ranch hand and an aspiring rodeo rider, work together as sheep herders in the summer of 1963 on Brokeback Mountain in Wyoming. When both drunk in one cold night, they raised their friendships to a new level of intimacy. They tried hard to hide their loves behind the social society because they wouldn’t be accepted in those conservative days. But their loves still were alive. They spent over 20 years stealing moments to affair. Brokeback Mountain becomes their dreams in their minds, which they never fulfilled in again.

Both the story and the film represent the concept of homosexuality, and the intertwined literary traditions of elegy and nostalgic discourse, which are so central to the depiction of sex love and passion. But Brokeback Mountain, film is much more complicated, as many other characters attempt to manipulate Ennis and Jack along their way. It involves a detailed subplot about Ennis relationship with Alma and Jack relationship with Lureen, and how she involves him with life. It is important to note that, while the film has the same premise as the story, the story focuses on men who have loved another man and lost him. Nostalgia and longing is hidden under the unaffected style of short story and film. That is why the works make such a strong impact on the Audince.


Foreshadowing
Heavy with foreshadowing, the film's climax is even more poignant because it's been set up time and time again throughout the script. From the moment Joe Aguirre warns the men to obey his rules and sleep with the sheep, we know that by ignoring his warning things will go wrong. Ennis communicates his fear of repeating his parents' mistake and driving off the curve in the road. His stumbling upon a bear in the woods spells the first signs of approaching danger. A second warning from nature comes in the form of the disembowelled sheep, lost to a predator, when Ennis and Jack break Aguirre's rules and spend a night away from the sheep.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Brokeback Mountain." 123HelpMe.com. 26 Feb 2020
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=235813>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Brokeback Mountain

- The major plot outline in both the short story and the movie The central drama and point of conflict in any love story is the obstacle between the lovers. In the best known tragic love story in Western history, Romeo and Juliet, the obstacle is their feuding families; in the classic film Casablanca it's virtue and in Brief Encounter, it's the marriage of one of the lovers. This is a story of unfulfilled love in Wyoming. Ennis and Jack, a ranch hand and an aspiring rodeo rider, work together as sheep herders in the summer of 1963 on Brokeback Mountain in Wyoming....   [tags: Brokeback Mountain Essays]

Free Essays
1242 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Brokeback Mountain

- Setting "Brokeback mountain Mori" begins in a mental institution, passes through an anonymous motel room and tattoo parlor, and ends in the back of a police car. Brokeback mountain never explicitly mentions whether Leonard has been in a mental institution (though certain ambiguous clues indicate that perhaps he has). It also passes through motel rooms and tattoo parlors, but it adds other locations, such as Natalie's house, the bar where she works, a diner, and the abandoned building where Leonard kills both Jimmy and Teddy....   [tags: Brokeback Mountain Essays]

Free Essays
1801 words (5.1 pages)

Adaptation of Brokeback Mountain from Short Story to Feature Film Essays

- Literature is a one track medium, invoking "unfixed" images that is, many specific details are supplied by the reader. On the other hand, film is a five track medium of fixed, specific images and sounds. Invariably, this fixed experience does not exactly mirror that invoked by the literary source material. Therefore, we cannot view an adaptation as a literal transposing, but should instead consider it as a kind of translation. Yet even a casual "translation" of "Brokeback mountain`s short story " would not produce the expanded Brokeback mountain....   [tags: Brokeback Mountain Essays]

Research Papers
1055 words (3 pages)

A Timeless Struggle in Brokeback Mountain Essay

- Author Isaac Asimov once wrote,” Never let your sense of morals prevent you from doing what's right.” This saying came to mind while reading both Montana 1948 and Brokeback Mountain. The authors, Larry Watson (Montana 1948) and Annie Proulx (Brokeback Mountain) both write stories with the internal conflict of man vs. himself. In Montana 1948 Larry Watson’s main characters the Hayden family cope with a situation of sexual abuse that forces them to search for their moral base and choose between right and wrong....   [tags: Brokeback Mountain Essays]

Research Papers
1302 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Annie Proulx's Brokeback Mountain

- Michael Warner states in his book The Trouble with Normal that "the [American] culture has thousands of ways for people to govern the sex of others," that a certain regulation of sexuality and desire can be designed "directly, through prohibition and regulation, and indirectly, by embracing one identity or one set of tastes as though they were universally shared, or should be" (Warner 1). According to Warner, the logical process that follows such a regulation ensures a certain shame attaches to any "taste" that is not "universally shared." That this one "taste" "should be" shared implies that it is not universal....   [tags: Brokeback Mountain Essays]

Research Papers
2326 words (6.6 pages)

Essay Brokeback Mountain by Annie Proulx

- Many literary works deal with the issue of homosexuality and society’s response to it, and each of the works of literature have a different take on the issue. Therefore, the authors create and design their main characters with the traits and characteristics that are most fit to convey their perception of the issue. One of the most well known literary works that deal with homosexuality is “Brokeback Mountain” by Annie Proulx, in which the main characters are two male cowboys that are in love. In fact, the story was controversial enough that director Ang Lee decided to produce an adaptation of the story....   [tags: homosexuality and society's response to it]

Research Papers
930 words (2.7 pages)

Film Analysis: Brokeback Mountain Essay

- ... Jack has a son with a cowgirl called Lureen whose father is wealthy because he has a business that sells machineries for farmers. Later on, Ennis and Jack get in touch again, and they start doing “fishing trips.” Alma sees Ennis and Jack kiss the first time Jack comes back to Wyoming and visit Ennis. She gets suspicious about the trips and later realize the truth about the fishing trips. Alma and Ennis get divorced, and Ennis can only see his daughters once a month. After the divorce, Ennis starts going out with Cassie a waitress, and Jack and Ennis start drifting apart and seeing each other less....   [tags: ennis, alma, homosexual people]

Research Papers
581 words (1.7 pages)

Movie Analysis: Brokeback Mountain and The Love of Siam Essay

- Brokeback Mountain and The Love of Siam are two movies, which two main characters from each film, namely Ennis and Jack from Brokeback Mountain and Mew and Tong from The Love of Siam, all four of them have a connection that goes from friendship to a homosexual relationship, respectively. Four of them are commoners that end up being infatuated with each other. These commoners have situations that they breeze along that directed them to a same-sex relationship amongst them. In particular, Ennis and Jack takes on shepherding job on Brokeback Mountain together, and while being there together for a long time and having each other’s back, their friendship becomes stronger....   [tags: Ennis and Jack, western culture]

Research Papers
547 words (1.6 pages)

Movie Analysis : ' Brokeback Mountain And American Me Essay

- In every film, there is one significant scene that shifts the remaining portion of the film. In the movies, Brokeback Mountain and American Me, the scenes include strong representations of sex and violence. In the scenes, the characters’ perspectives are completely changed and they are able to find out a little more about themselves. Nonetheless, both of these scenes are turning points in the movies and alter the atmosphere of the remainder of the films. The film, American Me, the most momentous scene in the movie occurs when the protagonist, Montoya Santana, loses his virginity with a female for the first time while his gang members are simultaneously raping a man is prison....   [tags: Rape, Sexual intercourse, Sexual assault]

Research Papers
1460 words (4.2 pages)

Brokeback Mountain by Annie Proulx and Society´s Reponse Essay examples

- Many literary works deal with the issue of homosexuality and society’s response to it, and each of the works of literature has a different take on the issue. Therefore, the authors create and design their main characters with the traits and characteristics that are most fit to convey their perception of the issue. One of the most well known literary works that deal with homosexuality is “Brokeback Mountain” by Annie Proulx, in which the main characters are two male cowboys that are in love....   [tags: homosexuality, perception, issue, book]

Research Papers
1185 words (3.4 pages)

After spending their second night together, Aguirre's sheep become entangled with another herd and impossible to separate, as do the lives of the two men. In his story of the gay couple beaten to death in his childhood village, Ennis warns Jack of the dangers of coming out, a message that couldn't be more poignant when Ennis learns of Jack's death, apparently trying to fix a flat tire.
Above all, Brokeback Mountain excels as a meticulously crafted but simple story expressing a universal theme: regret for love lost. By devoting the majority of the script to its primary plot, Ossana and McMurtry create space to develop their characters. Dialogue is only ever used where necessary, giving far more emphasis to the spoken lines. In leaving the film's emotional climax to the last moments and spending the rest of the film building up towards that point, the end result is far more powerful than had the audience's energy been spent at an emotional low point at the end of Act Two. Like Casablanca and Brief Encounter, classic love stories of the '40s, the result leaves the audience walking away filled with empathy.


Characters:

Ennis Del Mar as a Protagonist is an ordinary ma, he fall in the situations which turns him to be homosexual a man who emit sweat, semen, and even tears for his love, Jack Twist which identifies as a man having sex with women and men and expresses time after time his willingness to share his life with Ennis. Jack plans to experience something real with his Texas neighbor, eventually he will die because of his unacceptable desire of love.
In original short story, the author (Proulx) described their first sex as ”quick, rough, laughing and
snorting.(BpM8)” That was exactly what happened in Ang Lee’s film. The next Ennis say "I'm not no queer," and Jack jumped in with "Me neither.” Still, they did it again, and again, in the daylight as they did in night. Ennis has terrible fear to be known as a homosexual so he could not escape from the cage which society had locked him in because of his terrible childhood memory in mind. When Ennis was a child his father took him to witness the intolerance of society on gay beside this also his father was taught him to hate homosexuals, so Ennis was taught to hate his own feelings as well.
On the other hand, Jack’s understanding of a homosexual family was different from Ennis. ”I’m not you…I can’t make it on a couple high-altitude fucks once or twice a year! You are too much for me, Ennis…I wish I knew how to quit you.” (BpM23-24) Jack sincerely wanted to build a family with Ennis. He didn’t care about giving up his wife, child and being looked by different eyes in the society even he did not care about be killed in the way he think is right. For Jack it does not matter what would happened, he still wanted to fulfill his dream with Ennis.

Some metaphor in the story (5):
Metaphor in storytelling draws audience into the character's inner felt experience without words and creates an artistry of inarticulateness and powerful non-verbal expression. (Trevor Whittock)
1 Joe Aguirre`s (The sheep owner) authority symbolizes the Wyoming society and Joe Aquirre, himself is like their judge. At the beginning of the movie, Joe set a lot of rules like” No fire”, while Jack said, ”He got no business making us to do something against the rules.” However, they not only made a fire, but let the fire in their mind burning and Brokeback Mountain symbolizes Jack and Ennis’s heaven.

2 After the night that Ennis and Jack having sex for first time, Ennis found a dead sheep on the next day, a dead sheep means, Ennis lost his innocence. The sheep skin had been cut open, means their secret would be exposed, at that mean while; this dead sheep means the dead man who was killed by Ennis’s father when Ennis was young, and also determines Jack’s last ending the sheep which were isolated from the flock would come to a tragic end.

3 Jack and Ennis jumped into the river nakedly, it means that they fell in love at the same time without any boundaries.

4 Ennis used his own clothes to wrap Jack’s shirt, it was the action that Ennis show his love to Jack.

5 Lureen’s blonde and beautiful wig is symbolic of her shameful marriage with Jack. Besides, when she was talking with Ennis on the telephone, director purposely took a close up shot a Lureen’s fake, red nails. In English, “fake nails” means “a fake story”, so Jack’s cause of death was likely to be instructed by her.

6 The movie took the scene out of the window in the end, which means “To come out.” or “To
Stay in.”, was Ennis his own choice.

7 Jack and Ennis always stayed outside of the flock, not a part of them. A flock means a society, “Following like sheep.” in English can mean “To go with the current”.


Writer style and film style:
In the film clearly we see the absence of female characteristic as we see in the story.
The absence of female character in the text of a female author is often interpreted as a notably masculine style which is trying to highlight the negative role of men in the society. Before this film Cowboy was representing a model of masculinity.

Brokeback Mountain is another example of the classical Three-Act Structure. In the first Act, Ennis and Jack's characters are established and the two men set off on their journey.
The second Act begins when the men embark on their sexual relationship. The first turning point arrives as summer ends when it's time to leave Brokeback Mountain and the couple are separated. By the film's midpoint, the pair have been apart some time.
They're reunited when Jack sends Ennis a postcard saying he's passing through town.
The second turning point occurs when Jack learns Ennis is getting divorced and assumes the pair can be together.
The transition into Act Three comes when Jack realizes that's never going to happen.


Iconic film
Brokeback Mountain is important because it evoked a national discussion about gender and sexuality, about love and homophobia. Cowboys are an icon of masculinity, and here we have two cowboys in love, challenging the assumption that being attracted to another man unmans you that you cannot both want a man and be a man.

Return to 123HelpMe.com