Jacoby starts his essay by providing a background history on flogging by relating the punishment to crimes that would be insignificant in today’s society. He claims that imprisonment has become an “all purpose punishment” used for violent and nonviolent crimes alike (193). Citing a plethora of facts and research, Jacoby argues that the prison system is ineffective and too costly. To support his claim he advocates for a system of public humiliation and degradation to deter lower class criminals from becoming repeat offenders. Jacoby realizes that flogging’s “crimes of the day” are not our crimes, but maintains that flogging would be effective in current society and not any more brutal than being caged (194).
Jacoby is arguing for reintroducing a system of flogging. The main support of his argument stems from the ineffectiveness of the prison system. A statement by John DiIulio shows that, “about three of every four convicted criminals are on the streets without meaningful probation” (Jacoby 193). Jacoby uses this statement to show that most low level offenders do not receive adequate consequence to divert them from f...
... middle of paper ...
...gging “and determined to be inadequate. The material used to support the inadequacy is inadequate itself. Statistical data lacks credibility and opinions from authoritative figures do little in comparison to support the reasoning. Jacoby’s solution is to implement flogging into the punishment of low level offenders from becoming hardened criminals, but the solution falls short, failing to discuss the moral issues surrounding it. Jeff Jacoby attempts to replace an ineffective system with an outdated one, ultimately failing to convince the reader that flogging is a reasonable and practical solution.
Jacoby, Jeff. “Bring Back Flogging” Boston Globe. 26 Feb. 1978.
Rpt. in Current Issues and Enduring Questions: A Guide to Critical Thinking and Argument, with Readings. 9th ed. Ed. Sylvan Barnet and Hugo Bedau. Boston: St. Martin’s, 2011. 192-194. Print
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Flogging…What is it. What purpose does it serve. For those of us who have never heard of flogging, flogging refers to “beating with a whip or strap or rope as a form of punishment” (“Flogging” 1). Throughout the 1600s, flogging was utilized by “Boston’s Puritan Forefathers” (Jacoby 1) as a method of corporal punishment for various crimes. Progressing forward, Jeff Jacoby, columnist for The Boston Globe, provides readers with his view of “Boston’s Forefathers’” system of punishment in his essay, “Bring Back Flogging.” Within the contents of his work, Jacoby describes how flogging was utilized as punishment in its day.... [tags: Article Review, Jeff Jacoby]
1040 words (3 pages)
- In “Bring Back Flogging” Jeff Jacoby, a columnist for the Boston Globe, presents the use of corporal punishment as an alternative to the current system of imprisonment. Published in February of 1997, the article states that flogging would be a more effective means of punishment than jail. He insists it would be less expensive and serve as a deterrent to first time offenders. Jacoby’s thoughts on prison reform are legitimate, but his reasoning behind the use of corporal punishment is flawed. He fails to provide reasonable support for his argument which leaves the reader guessing as to the seriousness of his claim.... [tags: Criminal Justice]
1071 words (3.1 pages)
- In Jeff Jacoby’s essay Bring Flogging Back, he discusses whether flogging is the more humane punishment compared to prison. Jacoby uses clear and compelling evidence to describe why prisons are a terrible punishment, but he lacks detail and information on why flogging is better. In the essay he explains how crime has gotten out of hand over the past few decades, which has lead to the government building more prisons to lock up more criminals. His effort to prove that current criminal punishment is not perfect or even effective is nicely done, but he struggled with discussing ways that flogging could lower the crime rates and provide a safer environment for America.... [tags: Argument Analysis]
1009 words (2.9 pages)
- Bring Back Flogging" During seventeenth century flogging was a popular punishment for convicted people among Boston's Puritans. Fortunately, those times have passed and brutal and inhuman flogging was replaced by imprisonment. Columnist for the Boston Globe, Jeff Jacoby in his essay "Bring back flogging" asserts that flogging is superior to imprisonment and advocates flogging as an excellent means of punishment. He is convinced that flogging of offenders after their first conviction can prevent them from going into professional criminal career and has more educational value than imprisonment.... [tags: Personal Essays]
476 words (1.4 pages)
- “Bring Back Foolishness” Jeff Jacobys’ essay, entitled “Bring Back Flogging” was, in my sincere opinion, poorly constructed. There are numerous instances where I felt that he had either not supported his premises with valid information or had negated his support in later sentences. The essay begins by drawing forth images of Puritan punishment. He cites two instances of punishment, which were particularly torturous and radical in nature. He then draws a comparison between this inhumane punishment and imprisonment by stating with irony that, “Now we practice a more enlightened, more humane way of disciplining wrong doers: we lock them up in cages.” His use of the word “cages” was an a... [tags: essays research papers fc]
1217 words (3.5 pages)
- What is the best way to punish people. For centuries, humans have sought out for methods to reprimand wrongdoers. We, as a species, have allowed punishment to evolve along with us. From corporal punishment, or flogging as many may call it, to incarceration, humans have searched for the most effective technique to punish people. As time elapsed, imprisonment has become our staple for all crimes and transgressions. With this in mind, many writers have contended that we revisit corporal punishment.... [tags: Aleternative to Incarceration]
1284 words (3.7 pages)
- John 18:39- but it is your custom for me to release to you one prisoner at the time of the Passover. Do you want me to release `the king of the Jews'?"King of Jews- He's not the king of the Jews, He's slapping them in the face.The same thing Jesus was being accused of Barnabbas did.JN 19:1 Then Pilate took Jesus and had him flogged.  The soldiers twisted together a crown of thorns and put it on his head. They clothed him in a purple robe  and went up to him again and again, saying, "Hail, king of the Jews!" And they struck him in the face.Then Pilate took Jesus and had him flogged.This is your Messiah people, this is not VBS, or bible study, this is the Messiah that is... [tags: essays research papers]
1515 words (4.3 pages)
- Bring Back the Bracero Program Each day more and more immigrants legally or illegally cross the US border in search of better life. The United States of America is one of the most powerful countries in the world that treats immigrants better than any other country. The US government gives them a great personal and political freedom which is very important for most of the immigrants. Moreover, in this country they are able to get good jobs and to take advantages of America’s social services. There are thousands of immigrants from Mexico and Central America who live here legally or not.... [tags: alternatives to illegal immigration]
1545 words (4.4 pages)
- ... The sinister ticking of a pocket watch fills the eerie silence. "Fix Bayonets!" Again the sergeant shouted. On the final tick of the watch, Gordon and his battalion charged forward. German snipers unleashed fire and some men were shot down like dominos. Keep your cool, Gordon thought. He hacked through men as if they were trees. The worse combat was face to face. You could see the whites of their eyes burning into your soul. That never left you. Suddenly the air changed. He had reached German trenches.... [tags: personal narrative]
682 words (1.9 pages)
- Persuassive Essay: 104 words, including references written APA style Players Should Bring Hockey Back Players Should Bring Hockey Back Having reached another impasse in talks on January 26, in Toronto, between owners and players, there continues to be no NHL hockey season. The lack of an agreement centers on the owners’ desire for a salary cap and the players’ saying they will not budge on that particular point. Albeit this is not the only sticking point, other issues appear to center around this one (Lebrun, NoHockey.CA, 2005, para.... [tags: essays research papers]
1006 words (2.9 pages)