Essay on The Brady Sisters Defense Case Analysis

Essay on The Brady Sisters Defense Case Analysis

Length: 1061 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Two Utah sisters, Marcia and Jan Brady posted a message on Facebook in support of anti-globalization and anti-genetically organism (GMO) activists against McDonalds restaurants, who had incited riots in Europe. The sister’s message, sent to over 500 “friends”, asking them to join the sisters in two days at 10 p.m. at a McDonalds near the sister’s apartment for a “night of riot, pillage, and fun”. A secondary message was sent out asking the participants to bring items that could be used as weapons or cause property damage.
However, one of the “friends” that the message was sent to, turned the postings over to the Salt Lake Police Department. SLCPD officers set up an operation with six undercover officers at the scheduled place and time the sister’s has posted. Unfortunately for the officers nobody decided to show for the event, not even the sisters. Nevertheless, SLCPD arrested the sisters for incitement to mayhem, which was prosecuted by the District Attorney.
The Brady sisters defense is based on the fact that nobody showed up for the event and this was nothing more than a harmless posting to show their support. Their argument is based on the grounds that the arrest was an unconstitutional suppression of the First Amendment Free Speech Rights. The prosecution argument sees that the very nature of the message undermines any lightheartedness, with a possible outcome that could have reached completely different result.
Whether the messages sent by the Brady sisters were used in such a circumstance and are of such a nature as to incite imminent lawless action?
The messages posted by the Brady sisters was used in such a way that the threat if imminent lawless action can be established. The United States ...

... middle of paper ...

...o be read and passed along, with the possibly of attracting even those who the messages were not sent to. The threat of violence was serious enough for the SLCPD to take essential steps to arrest or detain any individual associated the agenda of the Brady’s. The arrest and convictions of the sisters is not an unconstitutional suppression of their First Amendment Free Speech. The Brady’s sent a clear message that had in imminent threat of violence, linked to a known terrorist organizations, with the intentions to further that organizations goals. The conviction of the Brady’s should be upheld.

Works Cited

Epstein, Lee, and Thomas Walker. Institutional Powers and Constraints. 8. Thousand Oaks: CQ Press, 2013. Print.

Epstein, Lee, and Thomas Walker. "Power Archive." Constitutional Law for a Changing America Resource Center. CQ Press, n.d. Web. 27 Oct 2013.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Freudian Analysis of The Fatal Sisters Essay

- A Freudian Analysis of The Fatal Sisters When the psychoanalytical approach is applied to Thomas Gray's "The Fatal Sisters,", each of Freud's three main theories are glaringly apparent. A major factor in the poem's psychoanalytical grisly texture is that the poem is sung by the giants at the loom as they weave. The language they use not only reflects upon the characters, but it offers new insight for Freudian analysis. The most obvious example of Freud's theories is phallic and yonic symbolism....   [tags: The Fatal Sisters]

Strong Essays
668 words (1.9 pages)

A Formalistic Analysis of The Fatal Sisters Essay

- A Formalistic Analysis of The Fatal Sisters     In “The Fatal Sisters” Thomas Gray has created a monologue pregnant with references to history, geography, and mythology. These reappearing references and allusions enrich the text, as they allow a closer look at the political situation surrounding eleventh century Britain.  The poems’ sixteen stanzas exhibit an ABAB rhyme scheme, which provides for systematic organization and positive aesthetic effects.  Closer examination of the setting, tone, and imagery of the poem permits insight into the text’s content and artistic genius....   [tags: The Fatal Sisters]

Strong Essays
673 words (1.9 pages)

Essay about Analysis of The Brady Bill

- Analysis of The Brady Bill Introduction      The legislative process in the United States Congress shows us an interesting drama in which a bill becomes a law through compromises made by diverse and sometimes conflicting interests in this country. There have been many controversial bills passed by Congress, but among all, I have taken a particular interest in the passage of the Brady bill. When the Brady debate was in full swing in Congress about three years ago, I was still back in my country, Japan, where the possession of guns is strictly restricted by laws....   [tags: Gun Control Rights Laws Jim Brady Essays]

Strong Essays
4294 words (12.3 pages)

Not The Brady Bunch - Original Writing Essays

- Not the Brady Bunch With every passing year, the blended family becomes a more common household dynamic. "When divorced parents remarry, they may hope their new family will be similar to the one on the 'Brady Bunch ' a 1960s- '70s sitcom in which a man with three sons marries a woman with three daughters. They all go on a honeymoon together and 'live happily ever after, '" explains Lisa Cohn in an article she wrote for the Christian Science Monitor. The idea of blending a family sounds easy, there are techniques that may help, but the reality proves much more difficult....   [tags: Family, Stepfamily, The Brady Bunch, Yours]

Strong Essays
1300 words (3.7 pages)

Case Study of Brady v. Salt Lake City Essay

- ... Their argument is based on the grounds that the arrest was an unconstitutional suppression of the First Amendment Free Speech Rights. The prosecution argument sees that the very nature of the message undermines any lightheartedness, with a possible outcome of a completely different results. Issue Whether the message sent by the Brady sisters were used in such a circumstance and are of such a nature as incite imminent lawless action. Conclusions The United States has a long history of hearing cases testing the limits of the First Amendments Free Speech Clause....   [tags: gmo, defense, mayhem]

Strong Essays
604 words (1.7 pages)

Essay about Mathew Brady: The Father of Photojournalism

- Born of Irish immigrants in 1823 in a little place called Warren County, New York; Mathew Brady is known as “The Father of Photojournalism.” While a student of Samuel Morse and a friend of Louis Daguerre (inventor of the “Daguerreotype,” a method of photography that the image is developed straight onto a metal coated surface), in which he had met while under the study of Morse, Brady took up his interest in photography in the year of 1839, while only seventeen years of age. Brady took what he had learned from these two talented and intellectual men to America where he furthered his interest in the then-growing art of photography....   [tags: Mathew Brady, photojournalism, ]

Strong Essays
859 words (2.5 pages)

Judy Brady's "I Want a Wife" Analysis Essay

- In this essay Judy Brady dives into the seemingly undesirable disposition of being a wife in a society that didn't allow women to do much of anything when compared to the liberty women have in society today. Judy Brady, formerly known as Judy Syfers at the time of the papers first presentation in August of 1970, introduced a fresh look at the duties of a wife in the 1960's and 1970's outlining these duties in what one can surmise in three basic categories. Brady's main complaints seem to be keenly focused on opportunities in education, lavish friendships, and overall liberty, particularly relief from her motherly duties to enjoy the festivities of life from time to time at least....   [tags: Wife, Society, Women, Author, Analysis]

Strong Essays
967 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about The Defense Mechanism

- Defense mechanism, in psychoanalysis, any of a variety of unconscious personality reactions which the ego uses to protect the conscious mind from threatening feelings and perceptions. Sigmund Freud first used defense as a psychoanalytic term (1894), but he did not break the notion into categories, viewing it as a singular phenomenon of repression. His daughter, Anna Freud, expanded on his theories in the 1930s, distinguishing some of the major defense mechanisms recognized today. Primary defense mechanisms include repression and denial, which serve to prevent unacceptable ideas or impulses from entering the conscience....   [tags: Defense Mechanisms]

Strong Essays
3474 words (9.9 pages)

Analysis of Hannah and Her Sisters Essay

- Analysis of Hannah and Her Sisters ‘Hannah and her Sisters’ is an American film set in the 1980’s directed by Woody Allen. Woody Allen was influenced by a Russian dramatist called Chekhov who wrote a play called ‘Three sisters’. Woody Allen based the film on the play, in which the sisters are close but there is still tension between them at the same time. ‘Hannah and her Sisters’ is a funny, swift, difficult yet beautiful film. All the characters lives seem to be uncontrollable....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1336 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Feminist and Dialogic Approaches in The Fatal Sisters

- Feminist and Dialogic Approaches in The Fatal Sisters      Thomas Gray's method of transforming monological poems into intense psyche films is fascinating. While reading The Fatal Sisters, readers can actually engage in a mind performance because of the choices of words, vivid actions, social aspects, and mythology that Gray displays here. The feminist and dialogic approaches, applied together, help shape the realm of this poem into a complex event in history that still takes place today. The feminist approach reveals many things about this poem that would otherwise be overlooked....   [tags: The Fatal Sisters]

Free Essays
928 words (2.7 pages)