Bloody Sunday and Historical Interpretation from Two Sources Essay

Bloody Sunday and Historical Interpretation from Two Sources Essay

Length: 1182 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

'Bloody Sunday', as it became known, has produced many different
interpretations of events. Since January 1972 people have recorded
diverse versions of events depending on where they were or which
faction of society they belonged to.

The sources used for the purpose of this essay are all from the media.
The first two are from news paper reports written 27 years after the
event following new revelations made during the partial disclosure of
evidence submitted to the inquiry lead by Lord Saville, commissioned
by Tony Blair. Source (c) is taken from an ITN news report relating to
the same inquiry some 14 months later (than the other sources) in
November 2000.

Source (a) is an extract from the 'Daily Mail', written by the deputy
Political Editor. This newspaper is by tradition a conservative
newspaper, so it portrays some more right wing ideas in its stories,
and it has been known to support controversial issues like capital
punishment. The paper is aimed the more middle class people. In this
Northern Ireland case 'The Daily Mail' is Pro-Ulster, so this means
that although being a news paper it should be neutral, that it does
support the Protestants. The IRA is viewed as a terrorist
organisation, and is not seen them as a freedom fighting organisation.
The Saville Inquiry was commissioned by a Labour government who were
initiating peace talks with the radical Irish group Sinn Fein, the
daily mail would therefore analyse these events from a conservative
view point. There are some things that make the source a bit unfair,
the news papers have their own interpretations of the events, but in
their interviews they have another interpretation of the events that
happened. So it is two d...

... middle of paper ...

.... Things
that are said like that might not always add up to make sense with an
event that happens shortly after it is said.

This source is another example of an interpretation of the events of
bloody Sunday, but again this is just one of the many interpretations.

In conclusion there was a lot of people at the event who have
experienced different things, these have then been passed on to other
people and may be been changed. From this there is not any way that
the correct truth will come out. There are only three sources of so
many, the sources I have, were not at the time of Bloody Sunday, and
they were all almost 30 years after. Different stories come out for
different reasons, for example the paras would say that they were
fired upon so they returned fire, and other people will say that the
army had planned to do this all the time.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Historical Interpretations of Bloody Sunday Essay

- Historical Interpretations of Bloody Sunday There are lots of different views on Bloody Sunday about what actually happened on the 30th of January 1972. The arguments are all down to who shot first, the British Army or the IRA. The result of the shooting was that thirteen innocent people were killed. An inquiry was carried out by Lord Widgery, he criticised the shooting by the troops but the report accepted that the army was fired upon. This report did not please everyone and people thought that it was a cover up of what really happened....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1814 words (5.2 pages)

Different Historical Interpretations of Bloody Sunday Essay

- Different Historical Interpretations of Bloody Sunday On January 30th 1972, civil rights activists were involved in a protest march against internment through Londonderry. British paratroopers, who were deployed on the streets, shot and killed 13 of the marchers and wounded others. Many people have different views on what happened and why. The main conflicting views are those of the paratroopers and their supporters and the views of the marchers and the friends and family of those killed....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
907 words (2.6 pages)

Historical Interpretation Of International Conflict Essay

- 1. The Past in the Present: Historical Interpretation in International Conflict History is an important element of international studies and its purpose is to compile an accurate representation of the past. The subject of history is often broken into different categories, such as political and diplomatic, economic, labor, cultural and social, intellectual, and environmental history. The past can be discovered or recorded through written, oral, or visual means. While some aspects of history, such as an event and when it took place, may be “set in stone”, causation of an event is often debated between historians....   [tags: Anthropology, Culture, Sociology, Geography]

Strong Essays
1299 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Using Primary Sources in Research

- A common debate in the social studies classrooms and discussions in recent years revolves around the use of a particular type of resource, the primary source. Some are skeptical about the use of primary sources having a strong impact. Many believe that the use of primary sources allows students insight into the minds and personal stories of those who actually experienced the events and the stories behind all key concepts in social studies. The studies that are reviewed in the present paper provide evidence of the latter....   [tags: social studies, digital sources]

Strong Essays
1561 words (4.5 pages)

Essay on Historical Interpretation

- Although the subject of a particular historical event is based on facts the truth remains that the story of history is largely subjective. Loewen points out that “textbooks in American history stand in sharp contrast to other teaching materials,” what he does not point out is why (387). In the educational areas of grammar and math the subject matter is based on hard evidence and irrefutable facts, which are not open to interpretation. The way we are taught about historical events and the situations surrounding them are majorly based on the views of individuals relating personal accounts of a factual event....   [tags: U.S. History ]

Strong Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)

Reliable Historical Sources Essay example

- Reliable Historical Sources History is the study of the past, of what had really happened and who were involved. To study history itself, it is essential that the source from which the information were taken is factual as well as reliable. It is not acceptable if it contains errors and flaws or mixing the truth with some fictions. This essay will investigate and evaluate a piece of historical evidence, the Hollywood movie The Patriot starred by Mel Gibson and Heath Ledger in order to determine whether or not it is reliable and could be used to determine the events that really...   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
2758 words (7.9 pages)

Historical Interpretation of Economic-Social Change Essay

- Historical Interpretation of Economic-Social Change The problem when looking at historical interpretations of economic-social change is that it is very difficult for the historian to comment without any of his or her personal political bias, it is for this reason that both sides of the standard of living debate must be looked at side by side. Historians commenting on the standard of living debate can be classified into two categories, the 'pessimists' who believe that the conditions for the working classes deteriorated, and the 'optimists' who hold the view that conditions improved with industrialisation....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1822 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on The Bloody Sunday

- The Bloody Sunday January 1972 has produced such different historical interpretations of what happened on bloody Sunday for a number of different reasons. The two big divides in what happened on that day are down to politics, religion and culture and the social society at that time in Ireland. As we know Ireland was facing many troubles politically and religiously, there seemed to be many marches and protests against the discriminate laws that persecuted the catholic people in Ireland....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
842 words (2.4 pages)

Historical Perspective Essay examples

- Historical Perspective Unfortunately, all most Americans know about the event known as Bloody Sunday, they learned from U2's smash hit, "Sunday Bloody Sunday." The source of this song's popularity stems from its ability to evoke widespread sympathy for Irish by painting an unforgettable picture of death and despair in the minds of each of its listeners. So what is unfortunate about this song being the primary source of historical knowledge concerning Bloody Sunday for most Americans. It is unfortunate not because of its lack of information or authenticity, but because of its lack of historical perspective....   [tags: Bloody Sunday History Essays]

Strong Essays
1588 words (4.5 pages)

Essay on An Analysis of Sunday Morning

- An Analysis of Wallace Stevens' Sunday Morning         “Sunday Morning” by Wallace Stevens is a poem about a woman having a late breakfast and thinking about the purpose of religion. Stevens wants the readers to ask themselves the questions that the woman asks, and to explore their feelings towards Christianity. He also wants to spark an awareness of nature. The first stanza asks the first tentative questions before launching into a racy debate in the later stanzas.           Stevens uses stanza I to set the scene for the rest of the poem....   [tags: Sunday Morning]

Strong Essays
1349 words (3.9 pages)