Biology Cannot Be Reduced to Chemistry and Physics Essay

Biology Cannot Be Reduced to Chemistry and Physics Essay

Length: 1548 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Since the introduction of reductionism, science has greatly changed. Reductionism has captured the attention of many scientists, as well as philosophers of science for the reason that it seeks to accomplish such a large goal. However, we are posed with the question of whether or not reductionism is capable of sufficing enough information for all scientific inquiry. I will argue that biology is not capable of effectively being reduced to physics and or chemistry mainly because it cannot provide the sufficient quantities of information needed, mainly due to issues caused by incommensurability due to varying scientific meanings (which will be discussed with reference to Kuhn and Feyerabend) as well as issues with overall understanding of scientific terminology.
If we were to reduce biology to chemistry and physics, we would lose immense amounts of valuable information because biological processes often possess their own explanatory theories, which would be incompatible with physical or chemical theories. Biological principles differ so greatly from chemical and physical principles that should we attempt to reduce biology, we would likely make such a field dysfunctional. The complexity that we derive from biological laws would simply not be sufficed by chemistry or physics due to . An example of this would be maintenance of homeostasis in species; a species requires stable internal and external conditions for life. Our bodies have regulated and adapted ourselves to maintain homeostasis, as it is a requirement. Examples of homeostasis would be temperature and acidity regulations. However, this explanation is purely biological. Should I attempt to explain such a thing in a chemical matter, problems would arise that would preve...


... middle of paper ...


...Unity of Science. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner, and Co.

Feyerabend, P.K. (1962), “Explanation, reduction and empiricism”, in H. Feigl and G. Maxwell, Scientific explanation, space, and time. Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science, Vol. 3. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 28–97.

Kuhn, T. (1962), The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Putnam, Hilary. (1975). “The Nature of Mental States.” Mind Language and Reality: Philosophical Papers, Vol. 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Sober, Elliott. (1999). “The multiple realizability argument against reductionism.” Philosophy of Science. 542-564.

Unknown Author. (2013) Can biology really be reduced to chemistry?. (http://ssptmusing.wordpress.com/2013/02/27/can-biology-really-be-reduced-to-chemistry/) . Retrieved April 14th, 2014.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Why Are There Still So Few Women? Essay examples

- ... In the article “Why so few women in engineering?”, Gary Robbins interviews Meera Ramakrishnan and she states “Girls are given dolls and dresses while the boys play with Legos and puzzles. In middle school, moms might teach their daughters how to take care of a sick animal, while her father teaches her brothers how to replace a brake light or fix a radio”. This shows that at an early age women are pushed away for thing that might peak their interest in engineering. Young girls might be discouraged when they are told that fixing things is not something they should do....   [tags: Female, Woman, Boy, Physics]

Powerful Essays
700 words (2 pages)

The Physics Of Science And Science Essay

- We see our modern world filled with so many advances with technology and science. We usually do not think about science when using a smart phone or google to find information with one click of a button. Do we think about Chemistry when taking an antibiotic medication for an infection. Just about everything involves science and technology, but what would happen if one scientist didn’t discover one theory, a theory that can alter our advance society as we know today. This one man was credited as the founder of chemistry....   [tags: Atom, Chemistry, Chemical element, Physics]

Powerful Essays
999 words (2.9 pages)

The Chemistry Nobel Prize 2013 Essay

- The Chemistry Nobel Prize 2013 Chemistry is one of category of Nobel Prize given to chemists who have dedicated in chemistry science. For a chemist, Nobel Prize is one of most prestigious award. Nobel Prize for chemistry 2013 has been decided, chemistry prize goes to three theoretical chemists who have developed a multiscale computer model to predict complex chemical reaction. The three chemists are Michael Levitt from Stanford University, Martin Karplus, Strasbourg University, Harvard University, and Cambridge University, and Arieh Warshe from University of Southern California....   [tags: Chemistry Nobel Prize]

Free Essays
754 words (2.2 pages)

The Physics of Fishing Essay

- The Physics of Fishing The use of a boat while fishing and some of the physics applicable to boating will be included in exploring the various ways physics applies to the sport of fishing. Other topics will include the fishing rod, fishing lure, casting, and the fish itself. The boat floats on the water according to Archimedes Principle which states an immersed object is buoyed up by a force equal to the weight of the fluid it displaces. The force applied downwards by earth’s gravity coupled with the upward force of buoyancy allows the boat to float....   [tags: Physics ]

Powerful Essays
871 words (2.5 pages)

Chemistry of Biology Essay example

- Chemistry of Biology There are many parts to every living thing. These basic parts have specialized jobs, which give shape and function of everything in the universe. The basic building block for all mass is the atom. There are many different parts to the atom. The electron is a negatively charged particle that revolves around the nucleus in electron shells. The electron is one of the smallest particles that make up the atom. The counterpart to the electron is the proton. This is a larger positive charged particle....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
560 words (1.6 pages)

The Nobel Prize Of Chemistry Essay

- ... He is very experienced chemist who has published four books and 411 articles. Arieh Warshe, one of Martin Kaplus teammate in multiscale computer models for complex chemical system research was once his student . Arieh Warshel is 73 years old Israeli-American chemist who work as distinguished chemistry professor in University of Southern California. Arieh Warshel was once Michael Karplus student in Weizmann Institute Israel, the same place when all three chemists met . Many of Arieh Warshel’s researches are focused in development of computer simulations for biological molecule such as Simulations of Enzyme Catalysis and protein Action, Simulation of Chemical Reactions in Solution, Electro...   [tags: Chemistry, Chemical reaction, Computer graphics]

Powerful Essays
733 words (2.1 pages)

Medical School and Low Aceptance Rate Essay examples

- About less than 300 students get accepted per year, depending on the medical school it can be less than that. If they raised their acceptance rate, more students would be able to go to medical schools, including myself. Since I want to attend medical school in the future, I have researched the acceptance rates and have seen that it is very low. I understand that is very competitive, but the way I see it, it is too extreme. Medical schools in California should increase their acceptance rate because of how low their rate is....   [tags: students, biology, chemistry, physics]

Powerful Essays
1523 words (4.4 pages)

Organic Chemistry Essay

- Chemistry has been called the science of what things are. Its intent is the exploration of the nature of the materials that fabricate our physical environment, why they hold the different properties that depict them, how their atomic structure may be fathomed, and how they may be manipulated and changed. Although organic reactions have been conducted by man since the discovery of fire, the science of Organic chemistry did not develop until the turn of the eighteenth century, mainly in France at first, then in Germany, later on in England....   [tags: Chemistry]

Powerful Essays
1119 words (3.2 pages)

Physics chemistry Essay

- ATHENS, Ohio -- Today's computers and other technological gizmos operate on electronic charges, but researchers predict that a new generation of smaller, faster, more efficient devices could be developed based on another scientific concept -- electronic "spin." The problem, however, is that researchers have found it challenging to control or predict spin – which keeps practical applications out of reach. But physicists in Europe, California and at Ohio University now have found a way to manipulate the spin of an electron with a jolt of voltage from a battery, according to research findings published in the recent issue of the journal Physical Review Letters....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
517 words (1.5 pages)

Biology Essay

- Biology is the science of living systems. It is inherently interdisciplinary, requiring knowledge of the physical sciences and mathematics, although specialities may be oriented toward a group of organisms or a level of organization. BOTANY is concerned with plant life, ZOOLOGY with animal life, algology with ALGAE, MYCOLOGY with fungi, MICROBIOLOGY with microorganisms such as protozoa and bacteria, CYTOLOGY with CELLS, and so on. All biological specialties, however, are concerned with life and its characteristics....   [tags: Biology]

Free Essays
2806 words (8 pages)