Comparison Between Elvis And Elvis

1030 Words3 Pages

Upon further analysis of both videos, I agree with Riley’s observation. The Beatles were more influenced by Buddy Holly rather than Elvis, based on a comparison of the Beatles overall product (i.e. song, video, and dance motions) and the videos presented of each in the prompt. The two singers differ in appearance, physicality, musicality, source of music, and in how each served as inspiration to the Beatles.
When a person thinks of rock music in the 50s, they usually think of Elvis Presley, “the King of rock and roll”. However, he seems to exhibit a more stereotypical American approach to music. As Americans, we like everything that entertains us to be bigger and better than before. Presley certainly delivers this idea through his outfit, …show more content…

His outfit, as well as his mannerisms, does not follow what was acceptable in society’s point of view at that time. His open jacket and partially opened shirt underneath shows some skin. Presley also has a chiseled appearance, and was known by host Ed Sullivan as “Elvis the Pelvis.” These examples indicate that while people came for his music, many people were also drawn to his sex appeal. Elvis moved around on stage which accentuated the beat of the music, as well as showcased the high energy and fast rhythm of the song. However, as he moved around on stage, the camera would focus on his actions, and not on his group, showing that Elvis had the primary importance and priority in the group. His musicality is apparent in this video, but not obvious due to the distracting dance moves that he does. He sings the song with the proper rhythm, but his tone and professionalism on stage is affected by the sensual dance moves he performs. Presley’s source of inspiration is a song first made popular by Little Richard in 1956, but was written by two other songwriters: Robert Blackwell and John Marascalco. Elvis is famous for mainly singing covers of singles, rather than writing his own songs. I believe that the influence of Elvis on the Beatles is that Elvis tied …show more content…

Though he was an American, his performance provided a sort of subtle style of rock and roll. At this point in time, the subtle style of rock and roll was more associated with the British who tried to not go over the top in their performances. Buddy appeared to be more of a “British rock and roller” by his appearance, performance, non-distracting dance moves, and the instruments, music, and tone used in his performance. Appearance wise, he and his band were dressed in matching black tie suits, providing an uniform appearance of his group and showing that they are all equals. This is especially shown in parts where there is an instrumental break and the camera pans to the band members who are enjoying their time on stage performing. The black tuxedos help Holly to exhibit a professionalism on stage that was usually associated with British stars. British performers at that time, at least for me, appeared to be more subdued and not as exaggerated when they perform. Buddy Holly captures this characteristic by just focusing on the music he is performing and not on his stage presence. He sways in time with the music, and has small dance moves such as a tapping leg which kept the beat, and some head bops in time with the music. This was very different from Elvis’s dancing and hopping around the stage as he sang. Holly was more calm and just enjoyed performing his song. Additionally,

More about Comparison Between Elvis And Elvis

Open Document