Banning of Books Such as Susan Patron children’s book, The Higher Power of Lucky

Banning of Books Such as Susan Patron children’s book, The Higher Power of Lucky

Length: 826 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Would you really ban a book for mentioning a word that is out of the norm for children? I sure wouldn’t. When the word “scrotum” was mentioned in Susan Patron children’s book, “The Higher Power of Lucky”, many librarians pledged to ban the book from elementary schools. Was it the right thing to do? In some cases it is but it all depends on how the book is being perceived. Although the book talks about Lucky growing up, it shouldn’t be a problem talking about this kind of language and body parts to children that are old enough to understand growing up. Librarians shouldn’t be losing focus on the big picture of the book instead of starting a controversy over something that has been done before in a children’s book.
Is it possible to talk about the good of this issue? In my opinion I find it as a way of teaching children who are soon to be teens what growing up means. It clearly explains that Lucky, the character in the book, is preparing herself to be a grown up. I personally find this as a good idea to slowly teach pre-teens of the body as they get older. So why ban the book? Ms. Patron clearly states that the book is aimed for children from nine to twelve years old. From my understanding these are about the last two years of elementary school and the start of your first year in middle school. There’s nothing bad about writing a book about growing up that is aimed at a young audience who can learn from it. One way I can relate this is with a health class in high school. The teachers in a health class will talk about and show pictures of sexually transmitted diseases. Does that mean that other teachers can go and complain about it? Well yes they can but they cannot start a petition to ban the class from schools. I understand that i...


... middle of paper ...


...d decided that it shouldn’t be a book for them to read.
Although the article sided with the bad things over the book, I completely disagree that Ms. Julie Bosman showed a fair and balanced report over the censorship issue. She was more in favor of the negative rather than showing the positive outcome that people may have on it. In a way I kind of thought that she would have an open mind for both good and bad over the issue but as I read she sided with the ones who thought badly of the censorship.




Works Cited
Althouse, Spencer. 15 Classic Children’s Books That Have Been Banned In America. 26 June 2013. 12 March 2014 .
Bosman, Julie. With One Word, Children's Book Sets off Uproar. 18 February 2007. 12 March 2014 .

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Book Censorship in American High Schools Essay

- Censorship in American High Schools Book banning has a long history and has made both positive and negative impact on readers. People have been trying to stop books from being banned, but there are also people that are trying to ban books to protect their children. Many books have been challenged and even banned because of the “inappropriate” content the books contain such as profanity. Books have started to get censored since the 1500’s and has threatened many cultures. The people who ban and censor books think that they are protecting the readers from the information, but it is secluding the readers from getting more ideas....   [tags: book banning, readers, protection]

Better Essays
1974 words (5.6 pages)

The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. SalingerCensorship and the Banning of Literature

- Our society has tried to protect the young minds of children over the years by banning certain books from school systems. This is occurring due to many people challenging books that obtain strong materials such as racism, sexual content, explicit language, religious affiliations, etc. The people testing books feel that certain books containing strong materials are not appropriate for young students to read. Some people feel the banning of books containing explicit materials prevents students from learning valuable life lessons....   [tags: censorship, banning of literature]

Better Essays
759 words (2.2 pages)

Book Banning: Against The Law Essay

- Books on the Wrong Side of the Law Every year, groups call to arms for the removal of written works. They label the book too dangerous for young readers. Unfortunately, these incensed groups refuse to acknowledge the entirety of the situation before jumping with both feet into this metaphorical river. This blind censorship needs to cease. Banned books should be allowed because the books give insight to the culture at the time, because banning brings attention to books that someone did not want anyone else to see, and because people have rights....   [tags: Censorship]

Better Essays
1292 words (3.7 pages)

Censorship and Book Banning Essay

- "Censorship cannot eliminate evil. It can only kill freedom. We believe Americans have the right to buy, stores have the right to sell, authors have the right to write and publishers have the right to publish constitutionally protected material. Period." (“Banned Books and Authors”). Harry Hoffman, president of Walden Book Co., Inc., is accurate in this aspect. When books are censored or banned, they are not eliminated from society; however, their message emanates to create an impact. Even if the public conceals the content in these books, the victims that these censors sequester from these works are rarely unexposed to what is being censored to them....   [tags: Literacy ]

Better Essays
1821 words (5.2 pages)

Book Banning and First Amendment Right Essay

- ... 20, 2013). As this concerns books, people should have the freedom to choose what they want to read and what they don't want to read. By banning books, our basic rights as US citizens are abused. Book banning affects many different people, from the people who read books to the people who write them. Why do people ban or try to ban books. 
 Most people ban books with the best intentions; they want to protect others from different ideas and information. Adults often do this because they feel that the book is frightening or has controversial ideas....   [tags: censorship in the US]

Better Essays
1699 words (4.9 pages)

Censorship In Public Schools and Libraries Essay

- Book banning seems an archaic notion to many. Yet as outmoded as banning may seem, censorship is still a huge part of the United States literary culture. Book banning is most often successful at the young adult literature level. Parents, and other objectors, utilize the censorship process in an effort to protect children and young adults from books that they deem dangerous. Public libraries, school libraries, and English classrooms are where these censorship attempts are being waged, often successfully....   [tags: Book Banning]

Better Essays
2567 words (7.3 pages)

Censorship and Book Banning Essay

- Censorship is a concept with several different meanings. To each individual censorship has its own meaning. Is it a violation of our rights or is it a protection for our well being. Censorship in the generic sense refers to the suppression of information, ideas, or opinions. It occurs in all forms of communication from technological media to print media. Each society, culture, or individual's belief is violated by the codes of censorship that our society instills. Book banning is a prime target for censorship....   [tags: Censorship Essays]

Better Essays
1822 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Censorship - The Negative Consequences of Book Banning

- The Negative Consequences of Book Banning If you were to ask a teacher what they thought the most important source of knowledge was they would probably answer: reading. When I think back to every classroom I sat in at school, I remember at least one poster on the wall promoting reading. Throughout my school years, teachers have pounded into my head how important it is to read. In high school I had a list of books that I was required to read over my summer break so that I would continuously be educated....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Argument Essays]

Better Essays
1495 words (4.3 pages)

El Patron in The House of the Scorpion Essay

- El Patron in The House of the Scorpion What if there was a world with clones. There would be a way to live for up to 100 years effortlessly, have easy transplants, and maintain a precise memory. But, the recipient would be taking organs from someone else. "So what", he or she may justify, "they're clones, they are inferior. They don't matter because they are stupid." But what if someone had the power to allow them to be of normal intelligence. He or she might think that he or she is doing the clone a favor, but when the clone is killed for spare parts it's an even worse situation than with a retarded clone....   [tags: Nancy Farmer]

Free Essays
746 words (2.1 pages)

Lucky Essay

- Lucky When I was little, I used to dream about being the Governor of Hong Kong. I still remember the composition I wrote in my primary school, in which I conveyed my vision and even outlined the policies I planned to carry out once I became the leader of the government. After a few years, I realized that it was almost impossible for me to be the Governor of Hong Kong, because the position was in fact appointed by the British government. This was a piece of disheartening news. I tried to console myself by saying that at least I had aimed at entering politics....   [tags: Personal Narrative Writing]

Free Essays
1718 words (4.9 pages)