This report analyzes the ICMR case study on the “Ban on Tobacco Ads by the Government of India”, found at, http://www.icmrindia.org/free%20resources/casestudies/ban-tobacco-ads11.htm. By reviewing this report, I will attempt to:
1. Summarize the arguments in favor of the ban on tobacco advertising in India
2. Summarize the arguments in opposition of the ban on tobacco advertising in India
3. Discuss the conflict of interest issue as it pertains to government in India
4. Give your opinion on what governments should do in regards to tobacco advertising
Section 1 – The Case for Banning Advertising (The Ayes’)
Tobacco deaths are real. The ICMR case study points to a statistic from the World Health Organization (WHO), that identifies 3 million Tobacco related deaths in 1990. By 1998, that figure had risen to over 4 million deaths. The WHO estimated that by 2030, Tobacco related deaths would rise to an astonishing 10 million people! With figures as graven as the ones from the WHO, the Indian government would have been negligent to just ignore the issue. Action on some level or another had to take place. In 2001, India’s plan for action included a ban on Tobacco advertising.
India wasn’t the first country to consider a ban on Tobacco advertis...
... middle of paper ...
... a society I believe we expect quick answers and solutions. Tobacco addiction is not a simple solution. Millions of people die every year from tobacco related issues. Over time, a ban on advertising has the potential to help reduce that number.
To me, the idea of free will being taken away is an issue that we sometimes fight against too much. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t want us to be brainless zombies that just follow and do everything that government tells us, but sometimes, common sense has to come into play. As a society, sometimes we have to recognize when something is for the greater good and support it. If we as a society always fall back to wanting to protect “rights” instead of protecting people, then we will always have trouble looking beyond ourselves and we will have failed as a society. A complete ban on tobacco advertising is the right thing to do.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Summarize the arguments in favor of the ban on tobacco advertising in India Part of the ban on tobacco was based on the "need to protect public health". Cigarettes are not in the best interest of the public, on the contrary they provoke high risk in serious or lethal illness. Also, there was a difference of 0.07% between the contribution (to the G.D.P) of cigarettes and the costs related to health care. The objective of the banning tobacco advertisements was to invert these results so that the health care costs would be reduced in the G.D.P as cigarette sales would decrease at the same time.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Nicotine]
919 words (2.6 pages)
- In February of 2001 the Government of India decided to put forward a bill, that if passed had the potential to have a major impact on the advertising abilities of Tobacco companies. The bill included a ban from advertising products, as well as sponsorships of sporting and cultural events. The reasoning behind the bill was to help the government stop tobacco companies from targeting a new generation of Indian youth, and to provide a launching point for a government led anti-Tobacco program. This report analyzes the ICMR case study on the “Ban on Tobacco Ads by the Government of India”, found at, http://www.icmrindia.org/free%20resources/casestudies/ban-tobacco-ads11.htm.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Tobacco industry]
1239 words (3.5 pages)
- Introduction Tobacco advertising refers to promotion display of tobacco products in media such as; radio, television, print, billboards and at retail stores. The ban on tobacco advertising by the Indian Government has many effects on the people as well as their ethics and freedom of choice. This paper will provide a summary argument in favour of the ban as well as opposing the ban. And to conclude with my opinions on what the government should do with tobacco advertising. 1. Summarize the arguments in favour of the ban on tobacco advertising in India Smoking kills.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Cigarette]
986 words (2.8 pages)
- The government of India has many arguments in favor of the ban on tobacco advertising. One of the arguments is the right of the government to step in and promote a healthier lifestyle. Many of the tobacco advertising companies stated that the ban on advertising was unconstitutional, but the supreme court in Belgium and France both agreed that the ban was not unconstitutional and was needed the ensure the public health. In 1990 tobacco attributed to over 3 million deaths and escalated to 4.023 million deaths in 1998.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Nicotine]
885 words (2.5 pages)
- Arguments in favour of the ban on tobacco advertising in India are based on international precedents as other countries like France, Finland and Norway had already imposed similar bans. With regards to the constitutionality of the ban on advertising as violation of citizens ' private lives the argument was that the government had the right to intervene in then overall interest of the citizens and the need to protect public health just as drugs like cocaine had been banned the world over. Statistics on tobacco related deaths according to the World Health Organisation and the expected rise also counted in favour of the ban.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Cigarette]
724 words (2.1 pages)
- Tobacco advertising bans have become commonplace in developed nations but are less prevalent in developing countries. The importance of advertising bans as part of comprehensive tobacco control strategies has been emphasized by the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control which calls for comprehensive bans on tobacco advertising. The empirical literature suggests that comprehensive advertising bans have played a role in reducing consumption in developed countries but that limited policies have not.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Cigarette]
1215 words (3.5 pages)
- This case study summarize the argument in favor of the ban on tobacco advertising in Indian such as using animated camel, encouraging them to smoke, by damaging their health and enhancing the states expenditure, question where also raise about the economic impact, because the tobacco company contributed to the growth of the employment issue to 26 million people, so they argued that tobacco consumption and employment show policies are likely to reduce smoking and not decreased employment, because even if people stop smoking the money will be spend on other expenditures such as goods and services which were more labour intensive and produce more jobs.... [tags: Tobacco, Nicotine, Tobacco advertising]
813 words (2.3 pages)
- Ban on Tobacco Advertising in India Tobacco consumption has become a widely known health risk over the past few decades. Many Governments and organizations have started to take action is reducing the consumption of tobacco products, and as result the divide between the tobacco industry and anti-tobacco movements has created much controversy. One example of this worldwide ethical struggle in regards to the tobacco industry is the ban on advertising of tobacco products in India. In 2001 The Indian government introduced a bill to ban the tobacco industry from advertising its products as well as prohibiting them from sponsoring sporting and cultural events.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Passive smoking]
1040 words (3 pages)
- The IBS Center for Research Management (ICMR) puts together a collection of management case studies from Asia. One such study involved a proposed bill that would ban tobacco advertising in India. The ICMR article, “Ban on Tobacco Ads by the Government of India” discussed the arguments for and against a ban, as well as raised some moral dilemmas. This essay will summarize these issues. The Indian Government justified the ban on tobacco advertising by focusing on how tobacco impacts the following topics: citizen’s health, the Indian economy, young people, and the effectiveness of the ban.... [tags: Tobacco advertising, Tobacco, Cigarette, Nicotine]
1170 words (3.3 pages)
- Throughout life, we experience many conflicts of interest in ethical issues as all people have different understandings with different surroundings. There are many ethical issues for ban on tobacco advertising with the conflict of interest that pertained to government in India. In this essay, I will discuss about agreements and disagreements of the ban on tobacco advertising in India with the conflict of interest issues. Lastly, I will present my opinions on what India government should do. Advocates believed that tobacco advertising may affect public health and induce children and young people to begin experimenting with tobacco products.... [tags: Tobacco, Cigarette, Tobacco advertising, Nicotine]
1069 words (3.1 pages)