Australia: Melbourne's Urban Consolidation Essay

Australia: Melbourne's Urban Consolidation Essay

Length: 971 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Urban consolidation refers to a diverse set of policies intended to make more efficient use of the existing urbanised areas instead of developing non-urbanised land, thus limiting urban sprawl. The recent publication of the Melbourne 2030 plan indicates that Melbourne is adopting an urban consolidated direction for further development. This has raised many debates over whether it is the right plan. There are two sides to this complex argument. People in favorite suggests that urban consolidation offers a range of solutions to pressing urban problems socially and environmentally, for example it reduces car use and provide better access to facilities, whilst the other point of view argues that urban consolidation has its limits in terms of consumer preference, land capacity and could actually bring negative social and environmental impact to the city.

This paper argues that urban consolidation should not be the focal point for future development in Melbourne. I will present this augment from 4 different environmental and social perspectives, which include urban consolidation limits green space, lack consumer preference, restricts freedom and rebuts that sprawl development is not necessarily bad for traffic.

In a social sense, consumers prefer low-density developments. Low density means more space and better standard of living. There are apartments available in every city for those who prefer them. However, many people choose to live in detached homes. Nobody forces people to buy house at outer suburbs (Holcombe 1999). Developers build those houses because that is where people want to live. Why? The answer is simple, those houses offer better space and comfort compare to living in the confine inner city. Many have suggeste...

... middle of paper ...

...ctivity centers in the Los Angeles only account for 17.5 percent of the area’s total employment. Most people both live and work in the suburbs and the average commute for individuals in the Los Angeles area is only 20 minutes (Gordon & Harry 1989). Traffic reduction stems primarily from a decision to drive (Engwight, 1992), a factor not easily adjustable by urban planning alone.

It is clear that urban consolidation can not solve the range of urban problems. It presents new dilemmas as it does not provide sufficient green space, limits people’s freedom, many people do not like living in an urban consolidated environment and it could potentially increase people’s time traveling out of the city. Planners must consider all these factors when assessing urban consolidation potential. Failure to do so could result in descent to achieve efficient, urban development.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Unaffordable Houisng in Melbourne Essay

- Within the housing market in Melbourne, and indeed throughout Australian cities, house prices have been rapidly rising to a level where today there is a severe lack of housing that is affordable to homebuyers on a median wage. In Melbourne, this has staggeringly seen the median house price to soar over $500,000. As will be put forth in this paper, the role of the planning system is undoubtedly a key protagonist for this lack of affordable housing. Within the data and evidence examined, it will be highlighted how the planning approval process with its, excessive ‘red tape’, inefficiencies and inconsistencies as well as other aspects of the statutory planning system in Melbourne, have undoubte...   [tags: Regulations, Inefficiency]

Good Essays
1839 words (5.3 pages)

Brimbank Park: Adaptive Nature of the Natural Environment in a Growing Urban Area

- Location Brimbank Park (coordinates 37.7340° S, 144.8370° E) is located in the Maribyrnong Valley (hollowed by the Maribyrnong River), near the Melbourne suburb Keilor. It is intersected by the Maribynong River and the M80 highway, which reveals the adaptive nature of the natural environment in a growing urban area. (Parks Victoria, 2013) Figure 1: Map of Brimbank Park (Google Maps, 2014) Geology Brimbank Park consists mainly of sedimentary rock, due to its close proximity to the Maribyrnong River....   [tags: Melbourne, Australia]

Good Essays
1619 words (4.6 pages)

Reasons to Support the Fact that Participatory Budget Policy is Not Feasible in Melbourne

- The budget is one of the most important economic and political policy instruments for the government. The budget reflects the government’s priorities and commitment to drive social and economic changes. Participatory budget policy allows the public to be directly involved in making decisions on the spending priorities. Porto Alegre have long used participatory budget to give its citizens more control over the quality of services delivered in their communities. The success of the policy has resulted in gaining acceptance throughout the world....   [tags: Australia, Australian]

Good Essays
2000 words (5.7 pages)

Essay about The Collapse of the Westgate Bridge, Located in Melbourne, Australia

- ... II. HISTORY The first time that a bridge was considered to cross the Yarra River was as early as 1957 to replace the Williamstown ferry service. Between then and 1961, there was lots of discussion, up until the Lower Yarra Crossing Company was founded. Discussions with the government about a new bridge across the Yarra River were held, but not much was agreed upon, until 1965, the Lower Yarra Crossing Company went bankrupt, and thus emerged the Lower Yarra Crossing Authority, whom in 1967 entered into an agreement with Melbourne based Maunsell & Partners, as well as London based Freeman Fox & Partners to be joint consulting engineers....   [tags: poor communication, engineering]

Good Essays
843 words (2.4 pages)

Melbourne, Australia Essays

- Melbourne, one of the most beautiful city's in the world. I have traveled through the USA, Canada & the Bahamas, and still, I find Melbourne is the greatest. In 1981 I was born in a New South Wales mid-coast town of Port Macquarie. I lived there until I was the age of four, and that's when we made the move to Victoria.I grew up in Kew, a suburb of Melbourne, not far from the actual city. Most of my family lived there, and was the main cause for the move. I went to school and met lots of friends....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
641 words (1.8 pages)

Changes due to Urban Renewal in Pyrmont-Ultimo Essay

- In 1900, Pyrmont was an important port and industrial area, with a population of almost 30 000 people. There was a wide range of industries and services present including wharves, dockyards, warehouses, abattoirs, wool stores, railway yards and even an incinerator for the disposal of Sydney’s waste. It was deemed a working-class suburb with a predominantly Irish/Catholic population. As the income for Pyrmont was only modest, semi-detached cottages were the most common type of housing present. In the 1960’s however, Pyrmont-Ultimo was deteriorating at a fast rate and became an unfortunate example of urban decay....   [tags: port, industrial area, urban decay, Australia]

Good Essays
1105 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Consolidation of Law Enforcement

- Comparative Overview Consolidated Municipalities When a city or town decides to consolidate their policing services, they are creating an entirely new department. Policies and procedures once used before, no longer translate to a consolidated force, and subsequently must be rewritten or altered. This altering or production of regulations must be done with extreme care, as a fluid unification of departments is a crucial aspect of success. Most municipalities chose consolidation for a number of reasons ranging from decreased population, tax revenue, and/or policing efficiency....   [tags: policies, procedures, consolidation]

Good Essays
1644 words (4.7 pages)

Life Style of Retirees in Melbourne, Australia Essay

- 1. INTRODUCTION: 1.1. Aim: The aim behind conducting the research is to study the life style of the retirees in Melbourne. The reason behind writing this report and conducting the study is to raise the awareness about the problems faced by the retirees and how they get to live after their retirement. The report will also states the importance of planning before the retirement age for the retired life. The report is written for the minister of [please complete the sentence] 1.2. Background: After retirement, mostly people live alone with their partners, live as senior of the family or as the grandparents....   [tags: Misconceptions About Retirement]

Free Essays
1228 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Urban Consolidation

- Urban Consolidation Factors and Fallacies in Urban Consolidation: Introduction As proponents of urban consolidation and consolidated living continue to manifest in our society, we must ensure that our acknowledgment of its benefits, and the problems of its agitator (sprawl), do not hinder our caution over its continually changing objectives. Definition Like much urban policy, the potential benefits that urban consolidation and the urban village concept seek to offer are substantially undermined by ambiguous definition....   [tags: essays papers]

Free Essays
2691 words (7.7 pages)

Australia Essay

- Australia Australia, the continent down under, filled with kangaroos, koala bears, and many more unique creatures. I always wanted to go to Australia, but never knew much about it, like the history behind it, and what there really is to do. So I decided to research it and talk to people that are familiar with it. I started my search off by looking in an encyclopedia called Encyclopedia International and looked up Australia. The encyclopedia was written back in 1970 but things have changed since that time....   [tags: Australia Research Papers]

Free Essays
2566 words (7.3 pages)