Attic Vs. Asiatic Literary Style

Attic Vs. Asiatic Literary Style

Length: 1278 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Attic vs. Asiatic
Attic style in Greek literature and art was replaced, for a time, by the more decorative and florid Asiatic style. Attic would resurface again, as the ideal, suggesting a more ascetic, brief, and witty concise style. Both styles influenced writers and speakers in Rome, and much later in Britain. Writers like Matthew Arnold made use of an Attic prose style, while the more florid Asiatic style had its proponents as well. In the Roman era, Cicero analyzed these styles and suggested there were several Attic styles and the simple style was not the only one. Cicero became embroiled in the Attic-Asiatic debate; he was said to be an Asiatic writer by those who wanted to discredit him.
Cicero wrote a treatise on rhetoric. Rhetoric is the art of meaning, speech, writing, and language. Roman rhetoricians, such as Cicero and Quintilian, used Aristotelian concepts in their writings, as would later commentators. Cicero's works served as a link between Aristotle and later generations, carrying ideas through the Hellenistic age which otherwise would be lost to us: "They furnish, accordingly, some notion, incomplete to be sure but nevertheless valuable, of the ideas about government which passed from Greece to Rome in the three centuries before the Christian era and produced such profound effects upon Roman law" (Cicero 40).
Cicero’s works influenced St. Augustine in the Middle Ages. Before converting to Christianity, Augustine taught rhetoric. Augustine revived interest in rhetoric--an important contribution, after the early Christians foreswore it as a pagan art. He embodied rhetorical concepts in his writings and teachings and argued that preachers needed to be able to teach, delight, and move--the same notions held by Cicero. Augustine said paying attention to the rules of effective expression was necessary to accomplish the aims of Christianity. And such rules were to be used only in service of the truth and so revitalized the philosophic basis of rhetoric (Bizzell and Herzberg 382-383).
As noted, some saw Cicero as more Asiatic than Attic, one of these people being Francis Bacon. Francis Bacon argued for world empirical examination by promoting a revival of secular knowledge. He rejected fables, myths, and other narratives as highly inaccurate. His definition of rhetoric suggests he attempted to bring the language power under rational control. Bacon also furthered the rhetorical scientific approach; his ideas were important in three strands of modern rhetorical thought--epistemological, belletristic, and elocutionist (Foss, Foss, and Trapp 8).

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Attic Vs. Asiatic Literary Style." 17 Feb 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Plot and Literary Style Must Interact in an Effective Way

- Both the plot and literary style are elements that are unique to each author and his or her works. If these interact in an effective way, the reader will be able to fully understand both the story line and the message that the author is trying to communicate in the piece. Both “Blindness” by José Saramago and “The New York Trilogy” by Paul Auster are novels in which the literary style used enhances the plot of the story. Similarly, the storyline justifies the reasons behind the use of that author’s particular style....   [tags: plot, literary style, writers, authors,]

Research Papers
851 words (2.4 pages)

Exposing the Role of Women in The Madwoman in the Attic Essay

- Exposing the Role of Women in The Madwoman in the Attic       In their book The Madwoman in the Attic, Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar address the issue of literary potential for women in a world shaped by and for men. Specifically, Gilbert and Gubar are concerned with the nineteenth century woman and how her role was based on her association with the symbols of angels, monsters, or sometimes both. Because the role of angel was ideally passive and the role of monster was naturally evil, both limited a woman’s behavior into quiet content, with few words to object....   [tags: Madwoman Attic Essays]

Research Papers
1698 words (4.9 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' Flowers From The Attic ' Essay

- Cleo Virginia Andrews, more widely known as V.C. Andrews, was born in Portsmouth, Virginia in 1932. Andrews was the youngest of all her siblings, and also the only daughter (V.C. Andrews). When she was a child she developed crippling arthritis after having surgery to treat injuries from a falling accident. Even with her limited writing ability that came with her arthritis, Andrews progressed to become a 20th century novelist. While her success and popularity came from her writing, she was also had a career as an illustrator/artist, she attempted to write a graphic science fiction novel, but it wasn’t picked up by any publishers (V.C....   [tags: Novel, Fiction, Flowers in the Attic, Short story]

Research Papers
1040 words (3 pages)

Essay about Flowers in the Attic by V.C. Andrews

- Flowers in the Attic by V.C. Andrews Have you ever imagined living locked up in an attic for 3 years and 5 months. Have you ever imagined not growing up with your mother's care and love at the time you were 5....   [tags: Book Report Flowers Attic Andrews]

Free Essays
1400 words (4 pages)

Tony Horwitz’s Confederates in the Attic, History, and Reconciliation Essay

- Tony Horwitz’s Confederates in the Attic, History, and Reconciliation Long after the Civil War we are still fascinated by it. In some circles, the "War of Northern Agression" or the "Lost Cause" is thought of, discussed, brought to life daily. While every war has its fanbase, the Civil War has a special distinction for America. It was the war for the preservation of the Union in some classes, a violent and tyrranical putting-down of a justified rebellion in others. I have never been particularly interested in the war, or any war for that matter....   [tags: Confederates Attic]

Free Essays
3617 words (10.3 pages)

Analysis of Flowers in the Attic by V.C. Andrews Essay

- Analysis of Flowers in the Attic by V.C. Andrews Flowers in the attic that’s what four children thought of themselves. They were born so brightly colored, but fading duller as their long dreary nightmarish days, held prisoners of hope, and kept captive by greed. The Dollengangers were a loving and happy family. Chris had meet Corrine when she was fourteen. After she turned eighteen they eloped. They had four beautiful children. They all had blond hair, blue eyes, and fair skin. Christopher was the oldest....   [tags: Flowers in the Attic V.C. Andrews Essays]

Research Papers
1080 words (3.1 pages)

On Style Essay

- On Style Style is a very ambiguous word. Asking the question, “What is Style?” is almost a philosophical endeavor, comparable with “What is Truth?” Asking the question, “What is Good Style?” is even harder. Society’s boundaries are constantly shifting to accept or banish items from the definition, in art and writing specifically. Yet there are certain elements that remain constant in all these changes, and these are the elements that style manuals try to pin down. Before the class reading/blogging project began, I thought of style as the method a writer uses to communicate his/her ideas to the reader....   [tags: Style Toward Clarity Elements Writing Essays]

Free Essays
932 words (2.7 pages)

Dante's Literary Style Essay

- Dante's Literary Style Dante was a genius, having being said at the cost of sounding trite. He was also the master who wrote the masterpiece appropriately called La Comedia which, most clearly of all his works demonstrates his genius profoundly. Dante lived in Florence, Italy in the late 13th and early 14th century. This was at a time when Florence was in political turmoil. Dante, however, was not a commoner. In fact, Dante's party, who were called the Guelfs, took control of Florence during Dante's time in 1266 (Fergusson, Francis, 26)....   [tags: Dante Comedia]

Free Essays
1432 words (4.1 pages)

Style Essay

- Style I often wonder what style is, and how does a person know when they are in possession of it. Style is one of the many things that seem to change form day to day for me, and I'm never sure where it might lead me. I think we all have our own style, but how can we get away from having the same style that other people have. When I look through magazines, all I read is the same thing over and over, in a little different style, or voice. Then, when I look out the window, I see people dressed in about the same fashions....   [tags: Style Personality Individuality Papers]

Research Papers
1804 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about Style

- Style After reading Strunk and White’s, The Elements of Style, Williams’, Style: Toward Clarity and Grace, and my peers’ reviews of these two books, I have come up with an all encompassing answer to the question: what is style, and what elements are most important to all writers. The answer is: there is no clear cut definition of style. It is ever changing; and is based on society’s views of what makes good writing, not necessarily the writer’s own thoughts on the matter. Therefore, the writer is better off following the set rules of grammar, punctuation, and sentence structure, determined by society; then adding her own voice....   [tags: Writing Styles Style Paper]

Free Essays
1566 words (4.5 pages)

Rejecting Ciceronian ornamentation, Bacon developed his own complexities by framing thought in aphoristic sentences (Bizzell and Herzberg 624).
Cicero paid particular attention to oratorical writing. Arthur Patch McKinlay considers Cicero’s view on clarity. He holds the idea that Cicero believed planning was an essential requirement:
He [Cicero] holds that a man who cannot apply the outline in every particular is entirely incapacitated to excel as an orator, and that no amount of understanding can make up for a lack of organization. In this unequivocal language does Cicero state the case for an outline. (McKinlay 245-246)
The Attic ideal strives for simplicity and clarity. Cicero may have been mistaken as Asiatic because he divided stylistic principles into “diversity of structure and embellishment of thought. He lays great stress on the need of variety in composition. He calls that quality a distinguishing trait of the orator” (McKinlay 246). However, there was considerable difference between florid prose and the variety sought by Cicero, who was noted for using situations, digressions, characters, and humor in speech. Cicero holds “that wit is peculiarly a gift of nature” (McKinlay 248). Wit has long been thought to be an Attic characteristic in epigram writing. Views that Cicero was too florid in his speech may have come from certain annoyed Atticists, as G.M.A. Grube writes:
It was his condescending estimate of Calvus, the leader of the Atticists, who had recently died, which probably embittered the dispute. (Grube 183)
Feeling Cicero had not shown proper respect for their leader, they decided he was an Asiatic writer and disseminated the idea.
Grant Showerman considers the elements of Cicero’s style, noting that one trait stands out above all else: “This quality is simply a marvelous fluency. Whether in oration, essay, or formal epistle, Ciceronian eloquence is a full-flowing, unceasing current. It streams-smoothly, steadily, reposefully” (Showerman 181). Showerman believes fluency not only lives in language but in thought as well. He says, “thinking which streams easily and continuously, and there is thinking which leaps, or halts, or strays and loses time in getting back again, or never gets back” (Showerman 181). This idea suggests the prose is simple and easy to follow, clean in line and without linguistic diversions compared to the more florid prose. Showerman describes Cicero’s prose style as the Attic ideal:
Few writers so effectively conserve the energy of the reader by leading him gently and noiselessly and effortlessly from the beginning to the end of his thought. There are no haltings, no leaps and jerks, no lacunae or ellipses. All is amplitude and fullness. Cicero does not scruple to use all the words he needs. (Showerman 182)
Linguistic devices Cicero uses have been cited as showing Asiatic style, such as repetition, word series, and rhythmical quality. However, as Showerman notes, when Cicero uses these devices, he does so for greater clarity and to guide the listeners understanding (Showerman 183). And this is why no absolute distinction can be made between Attic and Asiatic style.
Eric Laughton refers to the Asianism-Atticism controversy as he considers how well Cicero knew Greek orators who had gone before him. Laughton shows the two issues are related when he writes,
The attitude of the Atticist reactionaries at Rome was plainly wrong-headed, and for our purpose its chief importance was that it drew forth from Cicero, during his later years, a voluminous counterblast, which included many, indeed the majority, of his recorded remarks on the Greek orators. (Laughton 27)
The Romans always made a distinction between the orator and the rhetorician, while the Greeks had one word for both roles. Romans considered the orator a man of action and responsibility--one whose words influenced events--while the rhetorician was a teacher of rhetoric. Cicero’s rhetorical hero was Pericles, the Attic politician and orator “in whom eloquence was combined with integrity, wisdom, and statesmanship, and who for forty years guided the destinies of Athens, both in domestic affairs and in the conduct of war” (Laughton 29).
The Attic-Asiatic controversy, developed around Cicero, was somewhat different from the Attic-Asiatic debates that emerged at different times and were waged by various neo-classicists in the seventeenth century. The latter were writers who chose one particular style to define them. The controversy around Cicero was created by those who wanted to define him and who would not accept his rhetoric or stylistic views. To a degree, this became a political debate melding the political and literary in a way that is not usually seen today. Cicero wrote extensively about his vision of proper oratory and effective speech writing and delivery; these works show an Attic rather than Asiatic disposition.
People tend to want to classify writers as either Attic or Asiatic. But Cicero has shown that this is not a black and white distinction and one must consider the shades of gray in between.

Works Cited
Bizzell, Patricia and Bruce Herzberg. The Rhetorical Tradition. Boston: Bedford Books, 1990.
Cicero. On the Commonwealth. New York: Macmillan, 1976.
Grube, G.M.A. The Greek and Roman Critics. Indianapolis, Indiana: Hackett, 1995.
Laughton, Eric. “Cicero and the Greek Orators.” The American Journal of Philology, Vol. 82, No. 1 (Jan., 1961), 27-49.
McKinlay, Arthur Patch. “Cicero's Conception of Literary Art.” The Classical Journal, Vol. 21, No. 4 (Jan., 1926), 244-259.
Showerman, Grant. “Cicero the Stylist: An Appreciation.” The Classical Journal, Vol. 8, No. 5 (Feb., 1913), 180-192.
Return to