The Articles Of Confederation Established A Weak National Government And Strong State Governments

The Articles Of Confederation Established A Weak National Government And Strong State Governments

Length: 1286 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Many individuals are familiar with the Constitution or, at the very least, the concept of the Constitution. However, many are not knowledgeable of how the United States was governed prior to the Constitution. They are not knowledgeable of the documents that dictated the laws of its governing nor the factors that influenced such decisions. Many likely do not even consider the idea that the United States was governed under a different system prior to the establishment of the Constitution. However, for six years (1781-1787), the United States was governed by a radically different document known as the Articles of Confederations.
After removing themselves from the rule of Great Britain and its king, the Colonies needed to form their own government. They, however, feared forming a government that would ultimately result in them being back under the thumb of a ruler that they viewed as a tyrant. This was reflective in the decisions made in the Articles of Confederation. The Articles of Confederation established a weak national government and strong state governments, unlike the Constitution which established a strong national government and weaker state government. Under the Articles, states were more like individual nations allied with each other. This state-focused mentality causes state leaders to be apathetic toward the plights and problems of other states. Additionally, the Articles of Confederation did not establish a leader (e.g. president, king/queen, supreme leader) or even an executive branch in general. It also did not establish a national judicial branch. This meant that cases occurring between states, such as a person suing an individual from another state, had no established venue to take place in. The only ...


... middle of paper ...


...to prevent individuals from purchasing a massive amount of slaves to increase their voting power.
With these issues compromised, the convention concluded, papers were circulated to encourage support of the new plan, and the plan was eventually passed by Congress. While not a perfect plan it addressed many of the issues experienced by the early United States and by countries in general. Additionally, its guidelines for amendments allow such flaws to be amended and fixed and for further revisions to be made in the future. The checks and balances established by the Constitution, as mentioned prior, protect the United States from tyranny by keeping one individual from making corrupt/inept decisions without another individual/group interfering. The Constitution would safe guard the United States up to the present day and would become the model for many other nations.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Debate Between A Strong Centralized Government And Strong State And Local Governments

- The debate between a strong centralized government and strong state and local governments has been the topic of discussion since the beginning of the ratification of the constitution. Whether or not the Federalists were right about their opinion of a strong government or rather the Anti-federalists with their idea of strong, but small governments throughout our country are debatable. The constitution has evolved over the 228 years since the document was ratified, changing drastically between whether or not the idea was a valid decision....   [tags: United States Constitution, United States Congress]

Strong Essays
1084 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Federalism: A Happy Medium Between Unitary and Confederate Governments

- The United States Constitution established a form of government called federalism. In addition to the United States, Canada, Australia, Brazil, Germany, India, Malaysia, Mexico, Nigeria and Switzerland are all federalist governments. In a federalist government, political systems divide and share power and resources between central and regional governments. A federalist government is very unique and contrasts with other government types such as a unitary and confederate government. Overall the balance between a state and national government has kept our country strong....   [tags: government]

Strong Essays
524 words (1.5 pages)

Establishing Strong Enforcement Mechanisms Essay

- Fifth is “establishing strong enforcement mechanisms.” Currently there are few enforcement mechanisms because of the low rule of law. Having an independent judiciary and a state police force that can enforce the laws will allow the steps taken to be effective. The sixth mechanism is “monitoring” which goes with the seventh, “developing free media and civil-society mobilization.” The free flow of information to all parts of the state sheds light on the happenings in government and makes officials adhere to the laws of the state....   [tags: United States, Taliban, Government]

Strong Essays
1479 words (4.2 pages)

Military Governments Essay

- Military Governments Military governments have been around since the days of feudalism. It is the oldest and most common political state. According to Shively, a military government is one in which a group of officers use their troops to take over the governmental apparatus and run it themselves. Military governments are usually weak in appeasing the masses for they are known to be brutal and power hungry and are also rather fragile, both internally and externally. In its primitive state, existing as feudalism, the high ranking officials/nobility and the military itself was composed solely of the elite ruling class....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1122 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Governments Established by a Rebellion: The US and France

- France and the U.S. are both governments that were established from a rebellion. They created their forms of government because they wanted a voice in the government, wanted a fair tax structure, and wanted to get rid of their respective monarchs. France’s and the U.S.'s government are both fairly old, 1799 and 1783 respectively. They both are similar in many ways. The countries wanted a Republican form of governments to address thier concerns. The two governments wanted a voice in their governments....   [tags: king, world powers]

Strong Essays
514 words (1.5 pages)

The Is Not For The Weak Essay

- 22. Being Positive Is Not For The Weak "If you choose to become a positive detective, if you choose to spread positive news, be prepared for a negative backlash." - Lea Waters We already established that positive people are stronger than their negative counterparts because they have more courage and willingness to do what needs to be done. But, there is another reason that they are so much stronger than negative people - they have to deal with the negative people and their hateful words and constant negativity....   [tags: Thought, Mind, If You Have to Ask, Psychology]

Strong Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)

Should The Strong Support The Weak? Essay

- From reaching the cookie jar on the top shelf to donating to those living in poverty, every individual faces certain issues that require the guidance of someone older or stronger. Without the guidance of these people, it would be more difficult for the individual to efficiently solve any problems they may encounter. Whether the strong should support the weak is a topic that has raised many debates, with many fictional and real-life examples. Though society now emphasizes that the strong should support the weak, many still oppose that way of thinking....   [tags: stephen hawkings, human population]

Strong Essays
796 words (2.3 pages)

Starting Strong And Finishing Weak Essay

- Starting Strong & Finishing Weak On a typical Sunday morning while most were getting ready for church, the Japanese began a surprise attack on a US Navy base in Pearl Harbor on December 7th, 1941. The brutal attack would soon affect millions of people, of multiple nationalities. The attack was deliberate, strategic, and violent, all of which are desired by the offense in an ambush style attack on another country. Shortly after the attack, Emperor Showa, under the council of Prime Minister Hideki Tojo placed his official seal declaring war against the United States....   [tags: World War II, United States]

Strong Essays
1340 words (3.8 pages)

Macbeth: A Weak Man Essay

- ... While on the other hand, strength in the play could also mean how mentally or morally strong you are. In other words one can gain strength depending on, if he/she gets tricked easily, how he/she gains his/her power, or if they are mentally able to. Both definitions of the word strong apply to the situation. Macbeth is strong on the outside due to his power, but in the inside he is weak, morally ruined, and cowardly. While he may seem strong, Macbeth is in a way powerless. Throughout the play there is evidence of his non-powerful alter ego....   [tags: strong, cowardness, morally, mentally]

Strong Essays
699 words (2 pages)

Essay Strong Or Weak Dollar Is Better?

- Strong or Weak Dollar is Better. Strong is good. Weak is bad. These generalizations sound simple enough, but they can be very confusing when come to money. Is a "strong" U.S. dollar always good. Is a "weak" dollar always bad. Understanding of it is a necessary in marketplace. The term such as “Strong” and “weak” dollar is a “hot topic” which always bandied about by economist on a daily basis and also public. This issue is so important to almost every one. It seems like part and parcel of people who very concern about currency likes investors, economist, foreigners who study or working in the United State and so on....   [tags: Economics Economy]

Free Essays
1908 words (5.5 pages)