Anne Applebaum argues that if the Japanese, who are “technologically brilliant,” cannot make a completely safe nuclear reactor, no one else can and that the benefits of using nuclear energy are not worth the risks and costs that can come with that technology. The earthquake and tsunami that struck Japan in 2011 caused the cooling capacity at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power station to fail. Engineers had to flood the plant with seawater which gave off radioactive steam and there were also two explosions at the plant. The scale of the earthquake is unprecedented and few places are as vulnerable as Japan to natural disasters, but she argues that there are other situations where unprecedented catastrophes can occur.
Consequently Applebaum mentions a company that began to build a “super-safe” “next-generation” nuclear reactor in Finland. The plant was meant to cost $4 billion and be comple...
... middle of paper ...
...ments, she never addresses why they could be the only people in the world who can handle nuclear power.
Ultimately I think that Applebaum’s fears are not irrational, of course a nuclear disaster is scary, especially if we look back at the Chernobyl incident but the author failed to even mention it. There is hardly anything in the world that is not dangerous, and the probability of a disaster occurring with nuclear power plant is significantly small. Even looking at the Fukushima Daiichi plant, Japan was struck by an unprecedented earthquake followed by a tsunami and still no major nuclear disaster arose. Finally I believe that if there is a reason why we should not adopt nuclear energy it is not because the incident that was presented to the Japanese, I think that the author could have found more facts rather than solely expression her opinions to support her view.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Introduction Words simply cannot appropriately depict the aftermath of the earthquake and tsunami that devastated Japan on March 11, 2011. Japan is a developed country with the third largest economy in the world, behind the United States and China. The northeast border of Japan encountered an overwhelming natural disaster in the form of an earthquake that also created a massive tsunami and many strong aftershocks, which has affected Japan domestically and internationally. The aftershocks continually delayed recovery and have increased difficulty for search and rescue teams combing the disaster area for the deceased and wounded.... [tags: Japanese Earthquake]
1925 words (5.5 pages)
- On August 6th, 1945, America dropped an atomic bomb on Hiroshima, Japan. Three days later on August 9th, a second was dropped on Nagasaki. This effectively was the definitive end to World War II. The catastrophic damage caused by this vulgar display of power killed over 100,000 people in Hiroshima alone and left both cities as practically nothing more than radioactive ash. The unimaginable destruction caused by these attacks had obvious economic repercussions. Japan was a closed country that upheld a strict policy of isolationism.... [tags: Japanese History ]
1864 words (5.3 pages)
- Summary of The Whale and the Reactor by Langdon Winner (pp. ix-39, 99-200). Winner states implicitly that he wishes to add his book to a surprisingly short list of works that can be characterized as "philosophy of technology" (which includes Marx and Heidegger). His book will deal primarily with the political and social aspects of this philosophy, pertinent since as he notes the world is changing because of tech., no longer comprised of national entities--a global economy, etc. In this context he will also look at language and determine how adequate it is presently for handling the state of the art high tech world.... [tags: The Whale and the Reactor]
3257 words (9.3 pages)
- Introduction Japanese politics until 1994 has always been characterised by a single party dominance; this party is the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP). The LDP ruled the country for more than three decades, it in fact stayed in power from 1955 to 1994. With the defeat of LDP in 1994 and the creation of a new electoral reform the stale Japanese political situation, characterised by a confused voting system and by a weak central body was reshaped and most of its typical element's functions were changed.... [tags: liberal democratic party, Japanese communist party]
2590 words (7.4 pages)
- Japanese post-war history, like America, has had enormous debate over the extent to which nationalistic bias should be allowed to interfere in objective history. However, Japanese orthodox historians in the context of Emperor-centred societies, imperialistic censorship and American occupation justified censorship to create a polemical national narrative which restored national identity based on honouring the Emperor. Nozaki Yoshiko and Inokuchi Hiromitsu’s academic article ‘Japanese Education, Nationalism, and Ienaga Saburo’s Textbook Lawsuits’ explores the perspective of ultra-nationalistic Japanese educators who value the traditionalist and emperor-centred interpretation under censorship.... [tags: World War II, Nationalism, Japanese war crimes]
1042 words (3 pages)
- Not only are nuclear power plants expensive to build and maintain, they are expensive to repair, decommission, and clean up after. After several decades of activity, nuclear power plants tend to require repairs because of wear and tear. These repairs, nonetheless, are expensive. Eight reactors are currently in decommission because companies find it too expensive to fix old reactors, as reported by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission in Gang’s article. When a nuclear reactor fails and there is an accident, extensive damages are done to the surrounding environment.... [tags: Nuclear power, Energy development]
711 words (2 pages)
- Nuclear energy is a fairly fresh energy source; in 1945 scientists industrialized a source of energy that would change the world for better or worst. Nuclear energy is made inside a nuclear reactor. Uranium is used in every reactor, its nuclei are split into two or more fragments in a process called nuclear fission. When the nuclei is split it releases a colossal amount of heat, the heat then is transferred to water. From there the water turns into steam which turns a set of turbines that supply power to thousands of homes.... [tags: Nuclear power, Chernobyl disaster]
1073 words (3.1 pages)
- Japanese Internment Review The Prosecution won for me, the major legal issues, as presented by the debaters, appeared to be the question of whether fair and just trials were made for the Japanese Americans that would later be interned. It seems to me, from the evidence presented, that no legal discourse took place for the vast majority of Nisei, which is a serious problem considering that the majority of Nisei would have been full fledged American citizens. The Defense attempts to remedy this issue with the Executive Order 9066; however, the text of the executive order is relatively vague in terms of interning US citizens.... [tags: Japanese American internment, Japanese American]
1331 words (3.8 pages)
- Japanese-Americans and the Constitution A Review of the Smithsonian's "A More Perfect Union" Website Brief Description and Museum's Purpose "A More Perfect Union: ..." is organized as a chronology of events centering around one basic theme: the confinement of Japanese-Americans to "concentration camps" during WWII. I believe the message being conveyed to the public is one of a major apology to these Japanese-Americans and their descendants for the great injustices forced upon them. In addition, the museum attempts to warn the overall public that since such a violation of the constitution has proven possible in the past, we cannot blindly rely on the fabric of our constitution to prevent... [tags: Japanese-Americans concentration camps WWII]
1941 words (5.5 pages)
- In the late 1860’s Japan was transitioning from feudalism to urbanization and industrialization. It changed from the Tokugawa-Meiji transition as the first Asian industrialized nation. At its peak, the Tokugawa period had the maximum for their required materials with the aid of foreign trade. Domestic commercial activities and limited foreign trade had met the demands for material culture in the Tokugawa period; the Meiji era had changed all of this with its development. Unlike the Tokugawa rulers, the Meiji rulers embraced the English and American notion of a market economy and adopted British and North American forms of free enterprise capitalism.... [tags: Japanese Immigrants]
1087 words (3.1 pages)