Aristotle 's Claim That The State Of Nature Essay

Aristotle 's Claim That The State Of Nature Essay

Length: 1786 words (5.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Compare Aristotle’s claim that man is a ‘political animal’ with Hobbes’s claim that the state of nature is a state of war. How would you summarize their respective views of the relation between nature and politics? Which is the more persuasive and why?
Fundamentally, Aristotle’s and Hobbes’s principles represent two contradictory interpretations of the philosophy of human nature and why men gather and constitute government. For Aristotle, man is naturally a social and political animal, structured toward living in a community; whereas for Hobbes, it is natural for man to live for himself, and the state is an artificially created concept to prevent war. In the following essay, I will argue that Hobbes’s claim that the state of nature is a state of war is a more persuasive and logical argument than Aristotle’s claim that man is a political animal. Humankind is naturally in a state of war and men artificially created politics to protect their rights and achieve a state of equilibrium and freedom from external domination. I will support this thesis by arguing that the equality between men and their goals of self-preservation render the state of nature as every man for himself and politics as an artificial creation.
Aristotle interprets man’s nature as one that consists of social and political characteristics (Aristotle, The Politics, Book 1 Part 1, 1253a1, pg. 59). This interpretation carries some weight. One factor that supports this argument is the obvious fact that all men live in a society and are not born and raised in solitude. “Anyone who by his nature and not simply by ill-luck has no state is either too bad or too good, either subhuman or superhuman” (Aristotle, The Politics, Book 1 Part 1, 1253a1, pg. 59).What Aristotle mean...


... middle of paper ...


...the government are man-made concepts. There is no authority that exists naturally in the environment as all men share natural rights to self-preservation.
As seen in the above arguments, it is clear that Hobbes’s assertion that man is in a state of war and that politics is artificial is a significantly more persuasive claim than Aristotle’s argument that man is by nature a political animal and that politics exists as a natural culmination. This conclusion is based on man’s equality in nature and their innate desires for self-preservation.









Bibliography
Aristotle, The Politics, T.Sinclair (transl) T. Saunders (revised) Book 1 Part 1
Hobbes, The Leviathan, C. Macpherson (ed.) 1651
The need to belong: Desire for interpersonal attachments as a fundamental human motivation. Baumeister, Roy F.; Leary, Mark R. Psychological Bulletin, Vol 117(3), May 1995, 497-529

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Aristotle 's Aristotle On Nature Essay

- Gerald E. Wright JR PHIL-386R 08 Mar 2016 Aristotle on Nature (Nature?s Motion) Aristotle discusses in Physics Book 2 that nature has motion. He clearly states ?Of things that exist, some exit by nature, some from other causes. By nature the animals and their parts exist, and the plants and the simple bodies (earth, fire, air, water) . for we say that these exist by nature. (Physics, Book II, Chapter I, 192b 9-11). I claim that even when things of nature are turned into artifacts (desks, statues, buildings, etc.) that the inherent motion that nature has given the base materials remains and that nothing man can do will change the end....   [tags: Causality, Aristotle, Philosophical concepts]

Strong Essays
3097 words (8.8 pages)

Essay on Human Nature: Aristotle vs Plato

- Modern sciences have either directly emerged from philosophy or are very closely related to multiple philosophical questions. Understanding philosophy, as well as the way problems are addressed by philosophers, is the key to understanding science as we know it today and in the future. There are as many definitions of philosophy as there are philosophers – perhaps there are even more. Philosophy is said to be the mother of all disciplines. It is also the oldest of all disciplines and has given a rise to modern science, both social and natural conclusions....   [tags: Human Nature Essays]

Strong Essays
2002 words (5.7 pages)

Aristotle and Islam: Two Views of Women's Rights Essay

- Aristotle is one of the most famous philosophers around the world. He is Greek; he lived between 384 BC and 322 BC . He wrote in many aspects such as physics, metaphysics, logic, politics, government and ethics . While concerning politics and government, it is clear that Aristotle has some effective ideas to the state and the human society. On the other hand, Islam is one of the religious that take about how the society works and how to keep the state. They both talk about justice and equality between the members of the society....   [tags: Aristotle, philosophy, women, feminism, ]

Strong Essays
1052 words (3 pages)

Book VII of the Nichomachean Ethics by Aristotle Essay

- Book VII of the Nichomachean Ethics by Aristotle Introduction In book seven of the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle sets out his theory of akrasia, or weakness of will. Aristotle attempts to explain both how such actions are possible (contra Socrates), and how we can dissolve the puzzles (aporiai) generated by our most important (kurios) commonly held beliefs, which arise in response to the actions of the incontinent person. This paper will review book VII of the Nichomachean Ethics (EN), and attempt to resolve some of the remaining questions left open by Aristotle’s critique....   [tags: Aristotle Nichomachean Ethics Philosophy Essays]

Strong Essays
2981 words (8.5 pages)

Aristotle's Argument of the Polis Essay

- In what follows, I shall consider Aristotle's’ argument of the polis, or the city-state, as presented in his Politics I.2, and expound on the philosophical implications of this particular thesis; namely, a thesis which claims that the city-state exists by nature, and correspondingly, that a human being is ‘by nature a political animal’. Along the way, I shall present two objections leveled against each claim. The first pertains to the invalidity of the argument on ends; specifically, I shall protest that when a thing’s process of coming to be is completed, even if we regard this as an end, this does not necessarily confer that such an end is a natural end, for artificial processes too, like...   [tags: argument analysis, philosophy]

Strong Essays
1743 words (5 pages)

analysis Thomas Hobbes?s claim ?a state of nature is, or would be, a state of war of everyone against everyone.?

- Thomas Hobbes argues that a state of nature will eventually become a state of war of everyone against everyone. According the Hobbes, the main reason behind this change will be the harsh competition over scarce resources caused by the nature of man. Through out this essay Hobbes’s reasons will be explained in greater detail. In order to truly understand the logic behind Hobbes’s claim, we must first understand his point of view of human nature. The key element in Hobbes’s view on human nature was the importance of desires....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1426 words (4.1 pages)

Aristotle's Ideal State: A Place of Hierarchy or One of Equality? Essay

- Introduction to Political theory Is Aristotle’s ideal state a place of hierarchy rather than equality. Discuss. Aristotle is a philosopher who was born in the Greek town of Stagirus in 384 BCE and is well known for being a thinker who presented his views on a range of things, ranging from philosophy to politics. One of the key areas in Politics he addressed was the ideal city and what he believed it consisted of. The ideal city could be viewed as the ‘end of associations’ and why this is, I will later explore in the text....   [tags: introduction to political theory]

Strong Essays
2073 words (5.9 pages)

Essay about State and Morality: The Necessity of Injustice

- Governing ourselves is an important issue that has been discussed since the beginning of History. With Aristotle came the idea that we are “political animals” and that we are therefore forced to form a society. That is how we came to form states that need to be governed according to laws. The aim of these laws is problematic: for classical philosophers, the aim of the laws is and must be the Common Good: happiness for everyone in the state, which is regarded as a perfect community. This conception puts the benefit of all above the benefit of each and gives to the state the responsibility to be rational and moral....   [tags: Aristotle, governing ourselves, ibertarianism]

Strong Essays
1468 words (4.2 pages)

Aristotle 's Views On Politics Essay

- Aristotle begins his discussion of politics by concerning herself with the setting of human interaction and politics itself: the city. He precedes to define the city as a community of sorts with the specific quality of being for the sake of some good. Aristotle basis this claim on his observations of his own city of Athens, and the philosophy of his mentor Plato. A community works for the good because humans individually seek what is good so a community ought to work towards the good. More specifically, “…the good that most of all controls all the other goods…” (930) Aristotle is seeking to critically analyze politics – in order to do so, he must break politics into their component parts the...   [tags: Human, Religion, Reason, Africa]

Strong Essays
1300 words (3.7 pages)

Comparing Aristotle And Thomas Hobbes Essay

- Two of the most influential political theorists in history were Aristotle and Thomas Hobbes. Each man created his own school of thought which would shape the way men viewed politics thereafter. However, both men held vastly different views on the actions of man and for which end man exists and acts. They differed on how states came into being and why they existed in the first place. Aristotle holds the theory that man, by nature, is a social animal and that a political state exists for the common good of man....   [tags: Political philosophy, Government, Leviathan]

Strong Essays
1762 words (5 pages)