Arguments Regarding Abortion Essay

Arguments Regarding Abortion Essay

Length: 1176 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In this paper, I will discuss the pro- abortion argument presented by Judith Thomson. The main idea of Thomson’s argument is that abortion is morally permissible. In supporting her position, Thomson presents several arguments regarding the implications of the right to life that she believes the anti- abortion might have dwelled on. As I explain her arguments, I will also attempt to criticize her view on the topic.
As Thomson observes, most of the common argument on abortion is to define whether or not a fetus is a person. This type of argument, Thomson believes, does not lead to the conclusion of whether or not abortion is permissible. Therefore, she assumes that a fetus is a person from the moment of conception for sake of her arguments. Since fetus is a person and a person has a right to life, fetus is, then, has a right to life. Rather than arguing for or against the statement, Thomson approaches by evaluating the right to life and criticizing the false implications that one might have on having the right to life.
The first implication is the idea of having the right to life can outweigh any other rights that come in conflict with it. By this, it means that your personal rights will not matter when they are compared to my right to life. This the extreme view, where abortion is still not allow even if the mother might die from bearing the fetus, since the fetus has the right to life. Thomson objects this implication of the right to life and proposes a scenario in such that the mother may take action to save her own life. In her scenario of the growing baby, the tiny house that you and this baby are stuck in is similar to a mother’s womb. If you continue to let the baby grow, you will be crushed to death but nothing will happe...


... middle of paper ...


...mine if it is an unjust killing? With this argument, Thomson turns towards the more common cases, where women are aware of pregnancy risks when they voluntarily engage in sexual activities.
Having knowledge of the risks but the woman still engage in the activities, wouldn’t that put her, at least, to be partially responsible for giving the fetus rights to use her body? In the people- seed scenario, a person has taken all the precaution measures to prevent the people- seed from drifting in, yet a seed roots itself inside the house. Thomson argues that the house owner cannot be fully responsible for this seed who will grow into a person. As a counter response to those that argue the owner could have live without windows, Thomson proposes that women may also have a hysterectomy to avoid becoming pregnant when being raped.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Debate Regarding Abortion And Abortion Essay

- In this assignment I will be discussing the debate regarding abortion, which has been controversially contested for decades. I will first explain what abortion is, before going on to discuss its legal position in the UK. In addition giving statistics to show the number of abortions carried out in this country. Furthermore putting forward a debate using the arguments for and against abortion, and also showing how abortion can be reduced by introducing government policies. Lastly analysing how abortion affects not only the NHS but the economy as a whole....   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, Birth control]

Better Essays
1276 words (3.6 pages)

The Issue Of The Abortion Essay example

- With the pre-abortion ultrasound bill in the process of being established, informed consent, cost, etc. it appears that there is a major infringement on a woman’s right to choose because there are many obstacles to go through before receiving an abortion. Causes of the problem According to pro-life arguments, some of the reasons people are against abortion is because they view abortion as murder because life begins at conception, which means unborn babies are human beings from the beginning. Another argument is that the fetus can feel pain during an abortion and there are plenty of arguments against abortion regarding religion....   [tags: Abortion, Abortion debate, Human, Human rights]

Better Essays
1169 words (3.3 pages)

Abortion Is The Termination Of The Unborn Essay

- Abortion is the termination of the unborn. There are three different types of abortion spontaneous, therapeutic and elective. Spontaneous abortion is a miscarriage, therapeutic abortion is an abortion for medical purposes. Elective abortion is any other type of abortion that’s not spontaneous or therapeutic. Elective is the one that we’re concerned with. On the matter of abortion the legal and moral aspects of it are completely different. The legal matter is the point that the state should intervene....   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Life, Reproduction]

Better Essays
1463 words (4.2 pages)

Abortion is Immoral Essay

- For centuries society has placed their own opinions on the topic of abortion. Some claim to be Pro Choice, and believe that the decision should lie only in the hands of the woman carrying the child. Others are Pro Life, and say that abortion is unethical and is considered as a form of homicide. All depending on one’s human dignity, the argument differs. Human dignity is the sense of self-worth and self-respect that one inhabits. With this being said, the way one feels about themselves as a human-being, as well as other human-beings, has an effect on one’s outlook on abortion....   [tags: Argument Against Abortion]

Better Essays
1514 words (4.3 pages)

Abortion Is The Voluntary Termination Of A Pregnancy Essay

- In the United States we are determined to execute the unalienable rights granted in the Declaration of Independence; life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. As citizens, we are presented with many privileges and can choose to utilize them as we want. One of the most controversial privileges we are granted in this country is the act of abortion. Abortion is legal throughout the United States, with some variations though state laws. Politically speaking, abortion is the voluntary termination of a pregnancy before the fetus can live outside of the mother....   [tags: Roe v. Wade, Abortion]

Better Essays
1954 words (5.6 pages)

The Controversial Issue Of Abortion Essay

- To kill an unborn baby with dreadful procedures is an immoral way to handle an unwanted pregnancy and should be illegal. Abortion has been a controversial issue since the 1960s. One of the duties of the U.S government is to protect lives of the innocent and this includes the ones of unborn babies. Fetuses have potential lives and deserve a chance in the world. Voluntarily killing a guiltless human without a reason regarding health concerns for either the woman or child is unethical. Abortion is an unsafe procedure....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Fetus, Fertility]

Better Essays
1869 words (5.3 pages)

Should Abortion Be Legal? Essay example

- Abortion is one of the many controversial topics and not only in the western world. Many people until now have presented strong argument in favor of legalizing abortion, yet many others continue to counter them just as strongly. Abortion, defined as the deliberate act of ending the life of a human pregnancy, usually happens during the first twenty eight weeks of pregnancy. While abortion can still be made after that period of time (during the third trimester), it usually accompanies serious life threatening problems that could affect the mother in the short or the long term....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Human, Religion]

Better Essays
1622 words (4.6 pages)

Should Abortion Be Legal? Essay

- Abortion is a touchy subject for many, with opinions ranging from each extreme side of the debate. The problem with some of these opinions on the subject is that many of them are uninformed in some way or the other. Many of those who oppose abortion ignore the fact that abortion is generally only legal up to about 25 weeks depending on which state is considered (New York Times, 2013), and after that it is only legal in situations regarding the health of the mother or fetus. The problem arises when those uninformed individuals form the opinion that an abortion under any circumstance is evil and unacceptable....   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, United States]

Better Essays
1026 words (2.9 pages)

Is Abortion Wrong or is it Right? Essay

- Abortion is defined as: "the termination of pregnancy and expulsion of an embryo or of a fetus that is incapable of survival." However, if only the debate over the abortion issue was as simple as the definition provided above. Much like every aspect of human life, a statement is neither right nor wrong, but simply left open for interpretation. There is no black and white in life, only gray areas. Some issues tend to provide us more gray areas than others. Abortion is a prime example of that....   [tags: abortion argumentative persuasive argument]

Free Essays
1165 words (3.3 pages)

Morals of Abortion Essay

- Morals of Abortion In Roman times, abortion and the destruction of unwanted children was permissible, but as out civilization has aged, it seems that such acts were no longer acceptable by rational human beings, so that in 1948, Canada along with most other nations in the world signed a declaration of the United Nations promising every human being the right to life. The World Medical Association meeting in Geneve at the same time, stated that the utmost respect for human life was to be from the moment of conception....   [tags: Abortion Pregnancy Motherhood Medical Essays]

Free Essays
4124 words (11.8 pages)