Argument Regarding The Divine Command Theory Essay

Argument Regarding The Divine Command Theory Essay

Length: 1045 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The divine command theory is an ethical theory relating to God and how his commandments should guide the morality of humankind. Objections to this theory include objections to the nature or existence of God or to the nature of his character or commands. For the purposes of this paper, I will present the divine command theory, introduce a serious objection evident in Genesis 22, propose and explain an alternative to the divine command theory that is the divine will theory, explain why this theory avoids the objection, and critique and respond from the perspective of a divine will theorist.
Broadly, the divine command theory is a religious moral code in which God’s commands determine what human beings should or should not do. As such, it is expected for theists to subscribe to the divine command theory of morality. The deontological interpretation of the divine command theory separates actions into one of the following categories: mandatory for human beings to perform, prohibited for human beings to perform, or optional for human beings to perform. Those actions that are mandatory to perform are ones which have been expressly commanded by God. Failing to commit a mandatory action would be defying God’s commands, and thus, according to the divine command theory of morality, immoral. Actions that are prohibited are ones that God expressly commands human beings do not perform. Consequently, to perform a prohibited action would be immoral. Finally, those actions that God does not expressly command that human beings should perform or should avoid performing are optional; there are no moral implications to performing or not performing such acts. The rightness or wrongness of an action is inherently and wholly dependent upon th...

... middle of paper ...

...eradicating the element of fear. It would always be reasonable to maintain the typical conception of an omnibenevolent God who would never intend for moral wrongs to be done.
The divine command theorist’s presumed critique of the divine will theory is twofold: first, what would happen in an instance in which the command and the will of God are not expressing the same thing? If God’s commands are his only way of communicating intent, but his commands are not perfect reflections of his intention, then how can human beings possibly know what actions are morally mandatory or prohibited? Second, in such an instance, what is the point of a command if not to communicate God’s will? The divine command theorist would charge that the point of a command under the divine will theory becomes arbitrary, and theists altogether reject the notion that God ever acts arbitrarily.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Divine Command : Divine Doctrine Essay

- Divine Command Ethics Divine Command hypothesis highlights in the ethics of numerous current religions, including Judaism, Islam, the Baha 'i Faith, and Christianity, and also being a part of various more established polytheistic religions. In antiquated Athens, it was usually held that ethical truth was attached specifically to divine commands, and religious devotion was practically equal to profound quality. In spite of the fact that Christianity does not involve divine command hypothesis, it is normally connected with it....   [tags: God, Religion, Divine command theory, Ethics]

Strong Essays
880 words (2.5 pages)

The Divine Command Theory : An Argument Essay

- Divine Command Theory: (When employing the DCT in an argument, you must always cite a specific source ie. scripture, doctrine etc. to validate your claim.) The Divine Command Theory says that any action, whether good or bad, is morally right if God is the one commanding the action (Vaughn 71). This theory belongs to the nonconsequentialist theory— an ethical theory that states that right and wrong are not determined by the consequences of an action (Vaughn 71). The Divine Command Theory is a Nonconsequentialist Theory because God is the source of truth and the rightness and wrongness of the action is based on the accepted rule of God’s words....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Philosophy, Immanuel Kant]

Strong Essays
823 words (2.4 pages)

The Divine Command Theory : The Ethical Theory Essay

- 3. My Arguments The Divine Command theory is the ethical theory that I believe is the best ethical theory to live by. One problem with this theory, as stated by several philosophers, is whether or not that theory would make God the originator of morality. Many believe that if this were the case, then God could will any crime to become morally right. According to some, if this were the case, it would mean that God’s commands become arbitrary and have no real reason behind them. As a religious person, I am inclined to believe that a supreme being automatically knows what is best for his own creations simply because of the fact that he created them....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Immanuel Kant, Religion]

Strong Essays
1566 words (4.5 pages)

Divine Command Ethics : Divine Doctrine Essay

- Ethical Approaches Divine Command Ethics Divine command ethics is the idea a “divine being who has set down a finite series of rules that adherents claim can provide guidance to most, it not all, moral decisions” (Edge & Groves, 2006, p. 48). In this method of moral reasoning “religious belief remains a primary factor, indeed for many people the most important factor, in moral reasoning” (Widdows, 2007, p. 99). In Divine Command ethics the rules, beliefs and commandments of the religion guide followers in their decision making process and thus their actions....   [tags: Virtue ethics, Ethics, Utilitarianism]

Strong Essays
1233 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Meaning of The Divine Command Theory

- In this paper I am going to put forth the theory of Divine Command explaining its meaning and argument behind it. This Theory will be explained and expanded with my understanding to support the on going argument. It gives my thoughts on the Objection being made for the Divine Command Theory and I will show the objection made to my knowing to the Criticism/Objection. The Criticism is providing a view on the Theory that is very strong and hard to object to but I will be arguing how it will be invalid....   [tags: god permits or forbids, torture]

Strong Essays
808 words (2.3 pages)

The Doctrine Of The Divine Command Theory Essay

- It seems as if the constant argument of how much religion should play a role in our lives will never end. The Divine Command Theory is a theory in which one may receive a revelation from God telling them that doing a certain thing is good. This meta-ethical theory states that actions are only good if God deems they are good. This statement poses various advantages, disadvantages, and arguments as to whether we should conduct our morality based upon the acceptance of a higher being. Many religions are based upon the idea of reward and punishment for good and bad deeds, respectively, and this is a great problem that critics bring to the front....   [tags: God, Morality, Good and evil, Immanuel Kant]

Strong Essays
1584 words (4.5 pages)

The Doctrine Of The Divine Command Theory Essay

- Using religion as a moral basis is something that has been practiced, and is still practiced, for many years. The belief that God is all-knowing and has direct contact with morals means that we as humans try to base our actions off of His views, and this is part of the Divine Command Theory. To examine a statement such as “homosexuality is wrong”, many would turn to religious teachings as an infallible guide to base our morality off of. However, there is also the fact that not all religions agree on certain moral issues, and even some who do not practice any religion....   [tags: Religion, Morality, Ethics, Human]

Strong Essays
1001 words (2.9 pages)

On Euthyphro's Dilemma and Divine Command Essay examples

- ... Bertrand Russell argues If you are quite sure there is a difference between right and wrong, you are then in this situation: Is that difference due to God's fiat or is it not. If it is due to God's fiat, then for God Himself there is no difference between right and wrong, and it is no longer a significant statement to say that God is good If you are going to say, as theologians do, that God is good, you must then say that right and wrong have some meaning which is independent of God's fiat, because God's fiats are good and not good independently of the mere fact that he made them (12).Zellner 4 Russell brings up a valid point; To say that God is good, as was presupposed earlier, would be...   [tags: Plato, Socrates, philosophy]

Strong Essays
1747 words (5 pages)

Essay on Ethics And Divine Command Theory

- Ethics Ethics relates to what is morally right or wrong (Velasquez, Thomson-Wadsworth, 2011). Different schools of thought exist concerning ethics defined by their moral principles. Despite the three schools of thoughts all concerned with what is morally right or wrong, Act-Utilitarianism seems to present a more plausible argument than Natural Law and Divine Command Theory. This is because: Act-Utilitarianism is considered as one of the best known and the most influential moral theories; it is one of the forms of consequentialism which defines whether the actions are moral relying on their effects in the future....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Aesthetics, Religion]

Strong Essays
1384 words (4 pages)

The Divine Command Theory Essay

- In order to understand divine command theory we must first understand the nature of God and Morality. So we will start by taking a look at what makes an action moral. Once we understand what makes an action moral, we can then try to understand the author's’ viewpoint on the divine command theory of ethics. Understanding the viewpoint will allow us to dissect the author’s viewpoints and come up with counter-arguments that the author must then contend with. Divine command ethics is a theory that states, that an action's moral content is equivalent to if it was commanded by God....   [tags: morality, ontological, god]

Strong Essays
523 words (1.5 pages)