The Argument For Utilitarianism And The Virtue Theory Essay examples

The Argument For Utilitarianism And The Virtue Theory Essay examples

Length: 1364 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Each of the theories from the second term of this class have pros and cons. I do not believe any theory is completely perfect, but there is one I felt that is superior. Between the utilitarian, the deontological, and the virtue theory; I believe the virtue theory has the most compelling arguments. The utilitarian and deontological theories have too many flaws they cannot argue against without changes to the theory itself. Aristotle’s virtue theory does not have many weaknesses that will cause it to fall flat. Because of this, the virtue theory remains strong against criticism, including Frankena’s.
The strongest argument for utilitarianism would be in Nielsen’s reading. He provides an example of consequences with the fat man and the cave. This was the only selling point for me with utilitarianism. Killing the fat man to save six other innocent people makes sense, because you are saving more people. Obviously, it is not the best decision having to kill anyone, but in these circumstances, one dead versus six is preferable. But in Nielsen’s theory, he does say only consequences are important, which is not true for me. Mill also says in his reading that intentions are not significant, and that we should only look to an actions consequence when deciding what to do. Throughout these theories, I believe it is important to look at the consequences and the intentions equally to discover the goodness of an individual.
An important detail in Mill’s reading is that he believes every moral action comes from happiness. It seems to me that morality is more than happiness. Something debated in earlier discussions was the idea that goodness does not always equal happiness. Some goodness does not make the individual happy. Normally, when someone...


... middle of paper ...


...els are more important that moral rules. We should follow other virtuous people in order to know what we need to do to be virtuous ourselves. The criticism of the virtue theory being too general, doesn’t work if you add Mayo’s argument. So, I find that there are not any valid criticisms of the virtue theory like there are with the other theories. This is why I have chosen the theory as the best.
The three theories discussed in the second tern of this ethics class all have their own positives and negatives that come with them. However, with the utilitarian and deontological theories, the flaws in the readings were too big to ignore. They just couldn’t be fixed, in my opinion. With the virtue theory, though, the criticisms were few and far between. They were easily solved, as well. Because of this, the virtue theory is superior in my mind when compared to the others.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

War Theory, Utilitarianism, And Virtue Ethics Essay

- When it comes to nuclear war, most people will have mixed feelings on it. Nuclear war is a difficult area to touch on. Whether or not someone sees it as ethically right or wrong, all depends on the person and their moral values. The reason I chose this was because I don’t think it is necessarily right to engage in nuclear warfare even if it is the only means to end war. Just-war theory, utilitarianism, and Virtue ethics all help show a different perspective on nuclear warfare. There are many solutions to it, however....   [tags: Nuclear weapon, World War II]

Better Essays
1702 words (4.9 pages)

Ethical Theories Are Focused On Three Principles, Deontology, Utilitarianism, And Virtue

- Ethical theories are focused on three principles, Deontology, Utilitarianism, and virtue. Each one of them demonstrates different aspects of an ethical dilemma and leads to the most ethically correct resolution according to the guidelines within the ethical theory itself. Deontology The deontological theory states that people should adhere to their obligations and duties when analyzing an ethical dilemma. What does this mean. It means to make the correct moral choices; we have to understand what our moral duties are and what correct rules exist to regulate those duties....   [tags: Ethics, Virtue ethics, Morality]

Better Essays
1157 words (3.3 pages)

Utilitarianism, By John Stuart Mill Essay

- In the article Utilitarianism, John Stuart Mill argues that happiness, or pleasure should be the root of all human decisions and behaviours. Mill claims that “pleasure and freedom from pain are the only things desirable as ends”(Mill, 94). This quote is the conclusion that pleasure is the only intrinsic good and pleasure means absence of pain. According to this argument, Mill 's theory is defined by the person seeking happiness or pleasure....   [tags: Utilitarianism, Ethics, Hedonism, Robert Nozick]

Better Essays
1036 words (3 pages)

The 's Argument On The Personhood Of A Fetus Essay

- “I argue that it is personhood, and not genetic humanity, which is the fundamental basis for membership in the moral community” (133). This is the central idea in Mary Anne Warren’s argument on the personhood of a fetus. She argues that in order for a genetic human being to be considered a person, he or she would have to possess all of the six criteria’s of personhood which include sentience, ability to reason and emotionality. In order to determine the viability of the personhood of a fetus she argues two things....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Virtue ethics, Human]

Better Essays
2083 words (6 pages)

Utilitarianism And Kant 's Theory Of The Categorical Imperative Essay

- Moral decision-making constitutes an important part of the everyday human life. In this paper, I will examine and contrast Utilitarianism and Kant’s theory of the Categorical Imperative, both, which provide people with a moral structure, and how the issue of etiquettes relates to Kantian Theory. It is important to note that both the theories have their advantages and drawbacks, thus to enable one to make a methodical decision, it is important to understand the basic principles of each. However, in this paper there will be a main focus on Kantian Categorical argument and then discussing the issue of etiquettes....   [tags: Immanuel Kant, Categorical imperative, Morality]

Better Essays
1620 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Utilitarianism

- Classical utilitarianism, the theory as described by 17th century philosopher John Stuart Mill, states that the only thing that matters is that are the happiness and unhappiness that is created as a consequence of an action; those actions are to be judged right or wrong solely by virtue of their consequences, everything else is irrelevant. The theory also states that each person’s happiness is equally important. According to Mill, the right actions are actions that produce the greatest possible balance of happiness over unhappiness....   [tags: Philosophy]

Better Essays
1269 words (3.6 pages)

Utilitarianism, by John Stuart Mill Essay

- In John Stuart Mill’s work Utilitarianism, Mill is trying to provide proof for his moral theory utilitarianism and disprove all the objections against it. Mill defines utilitarianism as a theory based on the principle that "actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness" (Ch. II, page 7). He calls this the “greatest happiness principle. Mill says, “No reason can be given why the general happiness is desirable, except the fact that each person desires his own happiness, so far as he thinks it is attainable....   [tags: Morality Principle, General Happiness]

Better Essays
2028 words (5.8 pages)

Life's Guidelines to Know the Difference Between Right and Wrong are Ethics

- With the diverse nature of society, it is often difficult to define what is right and what is wrong, which emphasizes the need for a set of guidelines that is consistent with ideals of the majority of individuals. The guidelines are known as ethics, which is “the systematic reflection on morality,” meaning it provides a set process for analyzing morality, where morality is “the totality of opinions, decisions, and actions with which people express, individually or collectively, what they think is good or right” (Poel and Royakkers 71)....   [tags: morality, utilitarianism, virtue]

Better Essays
907 words (2.6 pages)

An Argument Against The Morality Of The Concept Of A Person Or Person 's Pleasure

- With Utilitarianism as a whole, I view the idea as a concept that has the potential to be good in theory, but only to an extent, and as one that will, without a doubt, always fail in actual practice. In an argument against it, I view that with this mindset, while we try to focus on how to maximize a person or person’s pleasure/happiness/etc. we gloss over far too many other factors that can have a major effect on the morality of the concept. Along with the morality, sometimes when a person may find pleasurable can be detrimental to their physical and emotional health, their mental stability, and their relationships with others....   [tags: Utilitarianism, John Stuart Mill, Jeremy Bentham]

Better Essays
2126 words (6.1 pages)

Essay on Philosphy: Criticism and The Way People Perceive Utilitarianism

- Utilitarianism is a ethical belief that if an deed seized creates extra good than bad for all than that deed ought to be taken. It is the calculation of the conclude result of meteorological conditions your decision will lead to a good cause or not. If the deed brings happiness to all, than you are acting the right thing. John Stuart Mill, acknowledged for this theory, explains that utilitarianism is a theory established on the pursuing, “actions are right in proportion as they incline to advance happiness, wrong as they incline to produce the reverse of happiness”....   [tags: ethical thinking, hapiness]

Better Essays
1103 words (3.2 pages)