The Argument For Intellectual Property Essay

The Argument For Intellectual Property Essay

Length: 1115 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Question 4:

The argument for intellectual property tends to provide a source of profit and income for a person who has meritoriously developed a new idea through their own independent volition. In contrast tot his, there are aspects of intellectual domain that were collectively designed, and cannot possibly be “owned” by an individual corporation or individual. Of course, all of this tends to be defined through the economic system of capitalism, which tends to find individual ownership a valid rationale for intellectual property due to the fact that owners receive money and power from these “inventions.” In political and economic terms, The clash between collective ownership under communism can be defined in contrast to the individual ownership methodology of American capitalistic culture:
There is of course a difference: the motive for information control in the Soviet Union was political; in the US the motive is profit. But it is the actions that affect us, not the motive. Any attempt to block the sharing of information, no matter why, leads to the same methods and the same harshness. (Stallman, 2015, para.6).
In this argument, Stallman defines the importance of collective ownership of intellectual property in the collectivist mode, which devolves the idea that any single person should be able to own or make profits from so-called “invention.” In fact, “inventions’ are usually the work of many differing people, which makes it difficult to understand why a single person can claim ownership. However, Moore’s (2015)evaluation of the Utilitarian Incentive process defines a balance between the length of time in which a so-called “inventor” may own intellectual property rights, which acknowledges the group or collective use of cert...

... middle of paper ...

... which the greater good is served through freedom of speech. This determined focus on individual rights is part of Mill’s inability to resolve these issues between the public and the individual rights in regards to the exchange of ideas. Certainly, the right for an individual to speak their minds will not always be tyrannical or self-interested, but these are the dangers of an overt focus on individual rights in the necessity of interpersonal relations between people in society. Mill does define the important factor of social interaction as an important and vital part of the community, but the tendency towards individualism is a troubling aspect of this approach to freedom of speech. In this manner, Mill’s utilitarian argument is not very convincing, since it focuses more on individual rights that on the greater good of society on the subject of freedom of speech.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Restrictions to Protect Intellectual Property Essay

- Restrictions to Protect Intellectual Property Most people have heard the term,” Intellectual Property”, which means the creations of the mind, such as inventions, trademarks, or designs. In the contemporary era, people have many arguments about their lives and environment. One of the biggest arguments is about intellectual property. With the development of technology, people can share their ideas more conveniently, which is related to intellectual property. The argument is whether people should restrict intellectual property or not, which means people should protect intellectual property or abandon it....   [tags: inventions, trademarks, design]

Free Essays
1366 words (3.9 pages)

Protection of Intellectual Property Essay

- Protection of Intellectual Property Introduction There is a lot of controversy about intellectual property and its application to software. There are many difficult, fundamental questions that arise, such as exactly what aspects of a piece of software should be protected under copyright or patent. [5] Despite the fact that applying existing laws to software is not very straight-forward, some sort of legal protection for intellectual property is necessary, as it provides a significant amount of positive outcomes, which will be described further in this paper....   [tags: copyright, legislation, politics]

Better Essays
1028 words (2.9 pages)

Copyrights: Intellectual Property and Technology Essay

- Copyrights: Intellectual Property and Technology The Government and many other agencies around the world are continuously at work to improve protections for intellectual property rights and the enforcement of intellectual property laws. In today’s age of digital madness, passing legislation and actually enforcing of those laws becomes a very daunting task. However, the protection of intellectual property has both individual and social benefits. It protects the right of the creator of something of value to be compensated for what he or she has created, and by so doing; it encourages production of valuable, intangible, creative work In order to understand the difficulties surrounding the laws...   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1549 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about Napster and Intellectual Property

- The Internet. It is a vast network of millions of users, surfing and sharing billions of files, all day, every day. To individuals holding copyrights on intellectual property, this is a frightening proposition. After all, there is virtually no protection for these copyright holders from the misuse of their property. But, as Scott Sullivan, writer for The FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin stated, “as history has proven, technological and societal advances usually come with a price.” The price society is paying for the Internet is a loss of copyright protection by laws for their intellectual material....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
1145 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Intellectual Property

- Q. 1 What actions can companies and governments take to ensure that products can not be easily pirated. Be specific. Nowadays fighting against counterfeits is too difficult because counterfeiters are using everything to fake expensive products and then sell them at lower prices. Governments try to avoid counterfeits by using strict regulations against phony products, but there is no way to avoid a huge flow of law quality products that are faked. We think that while producing some products the company should know its distribution channels very well, where and to whom the products are sold, and then control its network to avoid counterfeiting....   [tags: Property Rights Digital Piracy]

Better Essays
1234 words (3.5 pages)

From Goods to a Good Life: Intellectual Property and Global Justice Essay

- This reading for this week was From Goods to a Good Life: Intellectual Property and Global Justice by Madhavi Sunder. The reading I chose to put into convocation with the first article was The Public Domain: Enclosing the Commons of the Mind by James Boyle. In Sunder’s chapter on “Fair Culture”, she specifically references Lessig’s Free Culture, saying that it is insufficient, thereafter extending its claims. Sunder attempts to extend and slightly modify Lessig’s idea by incorporating a thorough analysis of culture and the inequalities in people’s ability to claim intellectual property rights into her argument....   [tags: Madhavi Sunder article review]

Free Essays
557 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on John Locke 's View On Property

- Throughout John Locke’s, Second Treatise of Government, he uses several methods to substantiate his claims on the natural right to property. Locke’s view on property is one of the most fundamental and yet debated aspects of his works within his respective view on politics. Locke views property as one of humankind 's most important rights, contending with the right to life and the right to liberty. However, certain claims made by Locke regarding property are may be unfeasible, which could be deduced from the time period in which he lived....   [tags: Property, John Locke, Liberty, Ownership]

Better Essays
1562 words (4.5 pages)

Defining and Avoiding Plagiarism Essay

- Plagiarism is a bad habit without a definition. Most people have an idea of what it is but its meaning has become so skewed over the years that no one really knows. Plagiarism is the Voldemort in the world of composition and literature; one word of it and you are blacklisted for cheating. How can this be though. How can the mention of plagiarism be so consequential if no one really knows what it means. This paper will not only identify the definition of plagiarism but it will also examine the concept of an original idea and how they both tie into each other....   [tags: composition, literature, intellectual property]

Better Essays
961 words (2.7 pages)

Intellectual Property Essay

- Intellectual Property As I begin this narrative, readers will have to understand that I have been and always will be a Trekkie. The very first movie I was ever taken to see was Star Trek III: The Search for Spock. I was six months old and I did nothing but scream the entire time, but the fascination has nonetheless been there my entire life, and there is no twelve-step program to help me recover. That having been said, you might have some degree of understanding when I say that Viacom’s attempts in 1997 to eliminate all use of copyrighted material on fan sites, ranging from still pictures to movie and sound clips to the logos themselves, was war for me....   [tags: Star Trek Trekkie Websites Essays]

Free Essays
594 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Zombie Detection Of The Zombie Apocalypse

- During an intense night during the zombie apocalypse, Jimmy had developed a product to help prevent the spread of the biological outbreak with a zombie detection device. He planned the development of a company and the product under the protection of United States intellectual property laws but was unsuccessful because his Aunt Jane pulled out from investing in his “education.” This ultimately led to the extinction of the human race because Jimmy was not truthful to his aunt or fortunate enough to find other investors for his plan....   [tags: Trademark, Intellectual property, Copyright]

Better Essays
991 words (2.8 pages)