The Argument Culture: Rhetorical Analysis Essay

The Argument Culture: Rhetorical Analysis Essay

Length: 1457 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Argument Culture: Rhetorical Analysis

An old adage says, “In quarreling, the truth is always lost,” (Bolander, 1987). The truth is often considered subjective; it depends on circumstances, time, and many other variables. We understand that what is truth to one may not be truth to another, and after reading Dr. Tannen’s work, I realized that she has done exactly what she said exacerbates the argumentative culture we live in today. She has looked at only two sides. Due to this, I would call into question Dr. Tannen’s truthfulness in her book The Argument Culture. Tannen has successfully shown this attitude in our culture but her arguments and writing style force one to conclude that there is a lack personal credibility.
Dr. Deborah Tannen’s thesis, “we have plunged headfirst into what I call the ‘argument culture,” (Tannen, 1998) in her book The Argument Culture, is intended to pique one’s curiosity. Upon reading Dr. Tannen’s work I soon found myself nodding my head in agreement. How can one not agree that our society is not the pillar of chivalry it once was? After fulfilling the requirements for our last session, I find myself questioning Dr. Tannen’s work a little more. I agree that our society has been inundated with a lack of courtesy from all areas. However, I doubt that this is a new condition. Ms. Tannen has brought to the forefront of our minds the condition that our society is in, and is challenging us to change.
Dr. Tannen initially appears to do an excellent job of establishing her credibility through stories. She used examples from public arenas, such as the Holocaust debaters she refers to in The Argument Culture (Tannen, 1998), as well as her interview with National Public Radio (NPR, 1998). ...

... middle of paper ...

...tems from. Author Erastus Wiman once said, “Nothing is ever lost by courtesy. It is the cheapest of the pleasures; costs nothing and conveys much. It pleases him who gives and him who receives and thus, like mercy, it is twice blessed” (Bolander, 1987).

Bolander, d. o. (1987). courtesy. In The new webster quotation dictionary (2nd ed., pp. 59-60). , MA: career publishing, inc.
National public radio. (1998, April 25). Npr weekly edition. In Retrieved March 23, 2011, from Lexisnexis (Transcript # 98042502-213).
Tannen, D. (1998, March 15). For argument's sake; why do we feel compelled to fight about everything. The Washington post. Retrieved March 15, 2011, from

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Rhetorical Analysis: The Argument Culture Essay

- “We have new arrivals for spring season. What about this new style checked sweater. This sweater is vastly popular nowadays because many popular actresses are wearing this in several TV dramas. I think this sweater would be great for you because it matches with your sky-blue skirt. Also we are making an allowance of 40% for this item. It would be good for you, ma’am.” You can often see this situation in every shop, but this shop assistant gives prominence to that new style sweater by saying that it is a low risk of trend style, considering guest’s figure, and also letting guest know that it’s on sale....   [tags: persuasion, ethos, pathos, logos]

Powerful Essays
1353 words (3.9 pages)

The Culture of Thin Bites Fiji by Ellen Goodman Essay

- ... And it will make me to decide what stuff I want to buy. Also, I think I am a member of control weight, because every day I would like to keep a good image to others. So as a result of control weight, I have the same problem of eating disorders as well. Besides, the actors are “going thin” because they have to suffer huge pressure than ordinary people. And in order to keep good image, they may control their weight but some of them seems to have eating problem. For example, from the image of Calista Flockhart on Screen Actors Guild Award, she looks very thin with eating problem in 1998....   [tags: rhetorical analysis, eating disorders]

Powerful Essays
766 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Response to Bitzer's Rhetorical Situation

- In The Rhetorical Situation, Lloyd F. Bitzer argues that what makes a situation rhetorical is similar to that which constitutes a moral action as he writes that, “an act is moral because it is an act performed in a situation of a certain kind; similarly, a work is rhetorical because it is a response to a situation of a certain kind”.(3) By defining the rhetorical situation in this way, Bitzer further contends that rhetoric is a means to altering reality. (4) It is through the use of discourse that one is capable of changing reality through thought and action....   [tags: Analysis, Bitzer]

Powerful Essays
2243 words (6.4 pages)

Essay on Rhetorical Choices Analysis

- In 2009 I wrote an essay Importance of Keeping Traditions for my Philosophy course where my audience was the professor and classmates. The requirements for the project were to be able to write an argumentative essay, to show a student’s point of view and his/her writing skills as well, to implement a good reasoning. In order to write a strong argumentative essay I had to follow requirements such as: structure it correctly and provide enough evidence to support my arguments. In the essay I argued about the importance of keeping traditions for immigrants and I assumed that it was suitable for philosophy class but now, by rereading and analyzing it I can see how the rhetorical choices I’ve made...   [tags: quotations, personalization, generalization]

Powerful Essays
1221 words (3.5 pages)

The Audacity of Hope: A Rhetorical Analysis Essay

- Hope, by definition means to look forward to something with reasonable desire and confidence. Hope also means a person or thing in which expectations are centered. When discussing the word hope, one must consider the core values by which the word works around. You could hope for financial success, world peace, or simply hope for some good out of your day. In 2006, Barack Obama wrote the political biography The Audacity of Hope to outline his core political and spiritual beliefs, as well as his opinions on different aspects of American culture....   [tags: Politics]

Powerful Essays
2124 words (6.1 pages)

Essay about The Rhetorical Force of Landscape Art

- The Rhetorical Force of Landscape Art Why talk about a rhetoric of images. The most obvious answer is that we live in an image-saturated society and a relevant rhetoric must pay attention to images, that W. J. T. Mitchell is right when he suggests that the rhetorical turn is being displaced by the pictorial turn. Beyond the obvious, the answers are multiple and layered. I want to suggest some answers by looking at some old pictures: Carleton Watkins' landscape photographs of Yosemite and William Henry Jackson's landscape photographs and Thomas Moran's water colors and paintings of Yellowstone....   [tags: Art Artistic Arts Essays]

Powerful Essays
1513 words (4.3 pages)

Goodman’s Countering the Culture of Sex Essay

- Goodman’s Countering the Culture of Sex In this essay I will discuss the effectiveness of Goodman’s Countering the Culture of Sex. I will argue Goodman’s beliefs on sex and cautions she mentions through the text on underage/unprotected sex, the experiences I have witnessed and been through; and how that effects my beliefs, and suggest some things that could have made this argument more convincing to the intended audience. Countering the Culture of Sex convinces one to change his or her beliefs on pre-marital sex and unprotected sex because the arguments made are based upon fact and other opinions and realities....   [tags: Rhetorical Analysis Pregnancy Essays]

Free Essays
1024 words (2.9 pages)

Future Identity of America Essay

- Are black people that different than white people. This is both a question and concern society focuses much attention on today, is there cultural assimilation in the United States or does the country still remain segregated. Realistically, America has a long way to come before saying it fully integrates both races equally. Donnell Alexander, author of “Cool Like Me” approaches the topic of the prejudices whites have of blacks, arguing that there exists no cultural integration and the United States is still separated....   [tags: Cultural Assimilation, Race, Rhetorical Analysis]

Powerful Essays
1732 words (4.9 pages)

Rhetorical Analysis of McKibben’s Article, Power Play Endangers Hawaii's Rain Forest

- Rhetorical Analysis of McKibben’s Article, Power Play Endangers Hawaii's Rain Forest Protecting Hawaii’s rain forest from the invasion of Corporate America is Bill McKibben’s intention as an environmentalist. His 28-paragraph article, “Power Play Endangers Hawaii’s Rain Forest,” appeared in Rolling Stone, a popular culture magazine, on May 31, 1990. He argues that producing power through geothermal drilling harms the Wao Kele o Puna rain forest, the environment, and the people that live nearby....   [tags: Power Play Endangers Hawaii's Rain Forest]

Powerful Essays
735 words (2.1 pages)

An Argument Analysis of “The Three Souths” in the Views of Kimberly Glanding

- John Shelton Reed says that the South embodies three different regions. Do all of these regions still exist. Or have they become incorporated into what is considered the South today. “The Three Souths,” by Reed, divides the South into three categories: Dixie, Southeast, and Cultural South. Southern agriculture and the growth of cotton established Dixie. The Southeast region is a metropolitan region that relies on commerce and communication to grow. The valued qualities, such as religion, sports, and manners are characteristic ways that set apart the Cultural South....   [tags: American Society]

Powerful Essays
1513 words (4.3 pages)