Essay about Are Memoirs Reliable Sources?

Essay about Are Memoirs Reliable Sources?

Length: 927 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Are Memoirs Reliable Sources?
Memoirs are a type of primary source, yet many historians do not believe they are as reliable as other primary sources. One of the reasons they do not think memoirs should be used as reliable sources is because of the amount of emotion and personal opinions shared through memoirs. Throughout this blog post I am going to dispute this by talking about how memoirs give an inside look into the thoughts and ideas of a person during a period of time. I am going to be specifically talking about Memoirs of a Jewish Extremist: The Story of a Transformation by Yossi Klein Halevi. Although I believe memoirs such as this one are great historical sources, I also believe it is important to realize that they are not to be used as one hundred percent accurate sources and should be carefully scrutinized before being used as a source.
Before diving deeper into these important points, we must first better understand what a memoir is and how it is different from other primary sources. A memoir is often confused with an autobiography, however, there are some major differences. An autobiography goes in chronological order from birth to the current point in the author 's life. In contrast, a memoir does not have to go in chronological order and can start up in any part of a person 's life as well as leave out large chunks of their life. Because a memoir is written by the person it is about it contains all the emotions felt by the person, the reasoning behind the person 's actions, and their thought process during events going on in their lives. Memoirs give us an inside look into why people during history chose to go about events in the manner that they did and make it easier to relate to them and emotionally at...


... middle of paper ...


...ble sources, but I believe they can be. Memoirs encompass the ideas and thought processes of people during a specific time period, often of which are famous or important historical figures. Memoirs of a Jewish Extremist is a prime example for why memoirs are essential primary sources because it gives historians a inside look into the JDL that they otherwise would not have had. They show what people groups in historical events felt rather than us having to assume based on how we believe that event would make a person feel. It is important to be careful, however, when reading a memoir to be aware that they are usually incredibly biased and only talk about one perspective in a time period rather than multiple like other sources. Despite having some drawbacks and limitations, ultimately memoirs are not only incredibly useful sources, but incredibly necessary ones.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Memoirs Of A Jewish Extremist Essay

- Memoirs are a type of primary source, yet many historians do not believe they are as reliable as other primary sources. One of the reasons they do not think memoirs should be used as reliable sources is because of the amount of emotion and personal opinions shared through memoirs. Throughout this blog post I am going to dispute this by talking about how memoirs give a inside look into the thoughts and ideas of a person during a period of time. I am going to be specifically talking about Memoirs of a Jewish Extremist: The Story of a Transformation by Yossi Klein Halevi....   [tags: The Holocaust, Jews, Soviet Union, Nazi Germany]

Better Essays
768 words (2.2 pages)

Examining the Validity of Holocaust Sources Essay

- There are multiple sources with divergent advantages and strategies, which allow humanity to have a clearer understanding of the holocaust; when compared, the resources’ limitations become apparent. The graphic novel Maus appears less valid compared to the diary, Night with its heinous detailed experience of life in a concentration camp. Conversely, Maus exhibits a strong expression of themes throughout the novel; comparably, this is a restriction in the textbook, Europe in the Contemporary world....   [tags: Literature Review]

Better Essays
1602 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Reliable Sources on Prohibition

- Reliable Sources on Prohibition December 5 1933 marked the end of Prohibition for the United States. Utah was the last state to pass the 21st Amendment, which cancelled out the 18th Amendment which prohibited the distilling or brewing of liquor. Source E was written by John D. Rockefeller Jr, an extremely wealthy oil merchant in the 20th century. Source E is a letter that he wrote in 1932, at the end of prohibition. Rockefeller had been one of the main supporters of prohibition; he was a member of the anti-saloon league and was a strong Christian....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
504 words (1.4 pages)

Reliable Historical Sources Essay example

- Reliable Historical Sources History is the study of the past, of what had really happened and who were involved. To study history itself, it is essential that the source from which the information were taken is factual as well as reliable. It is not acceptable if it contains errors and flaws or mixing the truth with some fictions. This essay will investigate and evaluate a piece of historical evidence, the Hollywood movie The Patriot starred by Mel Gibson and Heath Ledger in order to determine whether or not it is reliable and could be used to determine the events that really...   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2758 words (7.9 pages)

A Reliable Information Source Of Disease Essay examples

- a. Locate, cite (quote or paraphrase) and share a reliable information source that discusses a degenerative disease experienced at a higher rate among Native Americans (vs. American majority statistics). Native Americans share a number of degenerative diseases within their race. According to the CDC, they range from heart disease, cancer, diabetes, stroke, kidney diseases, chronic liver disease and cirrhosis, and chronic lower respiratory diseases (American Indian & Alaska Native Populations, 2015)....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Better Essays
782 words (2.2 pages)

Arthur Golden's Memoirs of a Geisha Essay

- Arthur Golden's Memoirs of a Geisha Memoirs of a Geisha is a wonderful novel and very informative on geisha life. The book is written by Arthur Golden. Golden earned a degree from Harvard College in art history and his M.A. at Columbia University in Japanese history and he also studied Mandarin Chinese. He worked at Beijing University in Tokyo. Golden studies, credentials, and experience all make him an experience all make him an expert on geisha and Japanese culture. The novel takes place in 1929 in a poor fishing village....   [tags: Arthur Golden Memoirs of a Geisha]

Better Essays
482 words (1.4 pages)

Reader Response to Memoirs of a Geisha Essay

- Reader Response to Memoirs of a Geisha Memoirs of a Geisha is Arthur Golden's debut novel, written exquisitely with great detail. It was initially written as a novel that would depict the son borne of a geisha and a Japanese businessman, but once he had learned the true nature of a geisha, he changed his topic. Golden discovered the intrigue of the geisha - the attributes that draw in the geisha's customers, that make them an irreplaceable part of Japanese history, that make them human as well as the ideal of what a woman should be....   [tags: Memoirs of a Geisha Essays]

Better Essays
817 words (2.3 pages)

American Teenagers Similar to The Memoirs of Barry Lyndon, Esq; by William Thackeray

- American Teenagers Similar to "The Memoirs of Barry Lyndon, Esq;" by William Thackeray "The Memoirs of Barry Lyndon, Esq;" by William Thackeray, is a story that follows an Irishman who wishes and makes attempts to become a bougeiouse nobleman during the 18th century. Upon first reading the novel, I couldn't help but notice a peculiar feeling I developed towards the story: it has a lot in common with an American teenager's life. Of course, it seems rather absurd to compare the story of an 18th century Irishman to a contemporary American teenager lifestyle, but closer inspection of the novel proves that a lot of Barry's experiences, desires, fears, and emotions have very interesting similari...   [tags: Memoirs Barry Lyndon Thackeray Essays]

Free Essays
574 words (1.6 pages)

Memoirs are Not Completely True Essay

- Memoirs are a Challenging Sources for Attaining the Truth Memoirs have become an increasingly popular genre of literature. In light of not only their popularity but their influence on the audiences who read them, it is important for readers to consider the various motivations and influences that shape the narrative and the details of these stories. This is especially true of memoirs that are intended to educate the public on the instances of human rights abuse, in situations when the general public may know little else about the subject....   [tags: Memoir Literature]

Better Essays
4286 words (12.2 pages)

Essay about Renewable Energy Sources

- A flick of a light switch and the spark of an engine are everyday activities that we take for granted. What if the world ran out of the resources used to make these activities possible. What if heating your house was not a simple task that could be done by pressing a button. This could be the case if we continue to use nonrenewable energy resources. The article, Energy Resources states that the use of these resources "is increasing at an unprecedented rate due to the rapid industrialization of a number of formerly third world countries." At this rate, the oil sand and oil shales will undoubtedly be cleared out in the future, along with the coal mines....   [tags: Alternative Energy Sources]

Better Essays
1744 words (5 pages)