Are Immigrant Workers Imperfectly Substitutable? Essay

Are Immigrant Workers Imperfectly Substitutable? Essay

Length: 1693 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Many wage studies suggest that immigrant workers are imperfectly substitutable for native-born workers who have similar educational attainment and experience. Relying on U.S. Census and ACS data, I ask, to what degree do language skills drive this? I suggest that immigrants who arrive to the United States at young ages, both have stronger English skills and exhibit greater substitutability for native-born workers than immigrants who arrived later. Similarly, immigrants with poor English skills will be more responsive to the supply of immigrants and their relative wages will suffer more than English-speaking immigrants. In large cities, where Spanish speakers are concentrated, I observe the emergence of a “Spanish-speaking” labor market. In these markets, the benefit of English language proficiency is low. Finally, in Puerto Rico, where almost all workers speak Spanish, immigrants and natives are perfect substitutes.
Studies by researchers ranging from the more conservative George Borjas to the liberal David Card have all found that the massive flow of immigrants into the U.S. has had little negative impact on the average wages of native-born workers. However, many of these same studies find that new immigrants have substantially depressed the wages of previous immigrant arrivals (Card, 2001). In Card’s research, for example, the largest impact of immigration that could be found since 1990 was a 0.1% drop in the average wages of native-born high school dropouts, compared to an 8.1% drop in the wages of other immigrants. By this evidence, the lack of immigrant competition in the native labor markets may contribute to the high poverty among immigrants, and more importantly, it may help to inform and enlighten policies aimed at redu...

... middle of paper ..., and the Local Labor Market Impacts of Higher Immigration,” Journal of Labor Economics Volume 19, January 2001, p. 27-49.
Card, David. “Immigration and Inequality,” The American Economic Review. May 2009, pp. 5-18.
Card, David, and John DiNardo, “Do Immigrant Inflows Lead to Native Outflows?” The American Economic Review, May 2000, p. 357-363.
Card, David, and Ethan Lewis. “The Diffusion of Mexican Immigrants During the 1990s: Explanations and Impacts.” Mexican Immigration to the United States. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2007.
Lewis, Ethan, “How Do Local Labor Markets in the U.S. Adjust to Immigration?” Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, November 2004.
Peri, Giovanni, and Chad Sparber, “Task Specialization, Comparative Advantages, and the Effects of Immigration on Wages,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics July 2009, pp. 120-158.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

We Need Health and Safety for Immigrant Workers Essays

- The slaughtering, processing, and packaging of meat has long been associated with a high incidence of accidents, injuries and illnesses. When the Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA) of 1970 became law, the meat and meat products industry was designated by the Department of Labor as one of the five Standard Industrial Classifications (SICs) to receive priority attention as part of OSHA's efforts to target those industries having the highest rates of occupational injuries. In this paper I will explain why I agrees with the conclusions and recommendations of the Human Rights Watch in regards to worker safety concerning immigrant workers and why new laws need to be written that ensure work...   [tags: illegal immigration, undocumented immigrants]

Powerful Essays
2594 words (7.4 pages)

Immigrant Workers in Phoenix Essay

- Immigrant Workers in Phoenix Before the sun even rises in Phoenix, out of the closing shadows of night, dark and quiet silhouettes begin to appear. They are the silhouettes of working men who rise before the sun rises, each with the hope of obtaining work and earning money to help support their families. These men are usually assumed to be immigrants without the proper paperwork to work in the United States. They are also better known as day laborers. These so-called “day laborers” congregate on street corners or in the parking lots of builders’ stores awaiting the arrival of employers who will hire them for a day’s work....   [tags: Immigration Labor Immigrants Essays Papers]

Free Essays
948 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Immigrant Labor workers: Enduring the Pain

- Introduction Despite being one of the smallest countries of the world, Lebanon ranks among the top when it comes to ethical and cultural mixture. Threw history, Lebanon was the destination for several migrants that were forced to leave their beloved country due to circumstances that were beyond their control. Nevertheless, Lebanon has repeatedly opened its borders to shelter those refugees. Ranging from the Armenians that were terrified by the ottoman's intolerance in the early 1900s, to the Palestinians that were forced to leave Palestine by the Israelis back in the 1950s, and up until nowadays with the Syrians that are esc...   [tags: Lebanon Population, Monopolistic Parties]

Powerful Essays
1324 words (3.8 pages)

Immigrant Labor in the United States Essay

- The United States cannot afford to lose the economic gains that come from immigrant labor. The economy would be suffering a greater loss if it weren’t for immigrants and their labor contributions, especially during the 2008 U.S. recession. The U.S. economy would most likely worsen if it weren’t for the strong labor force immigrants have provided this country. Despite the mostly negative views native-born Americans have towards immigrants and the economy, their strong representation in the labor forces continues today....   [tags: economic gains, immigrant force]

Powerful Essays
1273 words (3.6 pages)

Unfair Treatment of Immigrant Workers Essay

- As the airbus 300 made its final approach along San Francisco international airport, I saw the Golden Gate Bridge sitting on its splendor lit by the rising sun. I then closed my eyes and said to myself “I am finally here.” Thus, my journey in search of a better life began. A few minutes later I was off the plane and was already making my way to the customs and immigration check point. I handed my papers to the immigrations agent, he took a look at my passport and documents and without asking any questions handed them back to me, smiled and said, “Welcome to the United States.” Two months after arriving in the United States, I found myself working long hours and struggling with homesicknes...   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1133 words (3.2 pages)

Migrant Workers in the U.S. Essay

- During the 20th century, there was an urgent need for migrant workers in Florida due to several factors. Many migrant workers, my family, and myself included saw better ways of life in Florida. The term migrant worker is used to refer to individuals who enter The United States or another country legally or illegally as temporary or seasonal workers, typically in agriculture such as pineapple farmers, or in semi-skilled or unskilled industries such as hotel maids or waiters. My name is John O....   [tags: Migrant Workers]

Powerful Essays
1411 words (4 pages)

Essay on Upton Sinclair's The Jungle

- Employment is hard to find and hard to keep and a job isn’t always what one hoped for. Sometimes jobs do not sufficiently support our lifestyles, and all too frequently we’re convinced that our boss’s real job is to make us miserable. However, every now and then there are reprieves such as company holiday parties or bonuses, raises, promotions and even a half hour or hour to eat lunch that allows escape from monotonous workloads. Aside from our complaints, employment today for majority of American’s isn’t totally dreadful, and there always lies opportunity for promotion....   [tags: immigrant workers]

Powerful Essays
1143 words (3.3 pages)

Cesar Chavez, Larry Itliong and Immigrant Labor Essays

- When you try to describe Californians today, a common term that would probably appear more often than not, is diverse. California truly is a melting pot of different cultures that span the globe, from the Chinese and other Asian immigrants trying to attain the “golden mountain” to the Chicano community that was absorbed into American culture after the Mexican government ceded control of what is now, the Western United States. A common link between the past and present in California is the hard working immigrant laborer that put up with the harsh working conditions and got down and dirty to make a living....   [tags: California history, farm workers union]

Powerful Essays
984 words (2.8 pages)

Ewen's Immigrant Women in the Land of Dollars Essay

- Ewen's Immigrant Women in the Land of Dollars Throughout history, the concept of Americanization has been studied in order to better understand the effects of a mass culture on immigrants. On one side stands the view of an immigrant engulfed in American ideology who leaves behind his past....   [tags: Immigration Capitalism Women Immigrants]

Powerful Essays
1023 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Immigrant Worker Ethics

- INTRODUCTION The purpose of this report is to discuss my opinion on the question “Do I agree with the recommendations of the Human Rights Watch (HRW) in regards to work safety particularly when it comes to immigrant workers?” I will provide information on past and current safety related issues as they apply to the meat packing industry and immigrant workers. I will discuss the recommendations of the HRW. I will provide my opinion and consider some of the utilitarian and deontological considerations, and conclude this report with a brief summary of the entire analysis, highlighting some of the most significant parts that the report contains HISTORY “In 1906, Upton Sinclair's novel "The Jun...   [tags: Immigration]

Powerful Essays
1698 words (4.9 pages)