Essay on Are Fresh Organs Commodities Or A Gift?

Essay on Are Fresh Organs Commodities Or A Gift?

Length: 1436 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Are ‘fresh’ organs commodities or a gift?

 Treated as commodities and masked as a gift the harvesting of ‘fresh’ organs has become more and more of a controversial topic and one of considerable interest to medical anthropologists around the globe as transplant tourism continues to expand crossing geographic and ethical boundaries. Within the ‘biomedical perspective’ that individuals who are either donors or recipients of a ‘fresh’ organ have, ‘fresh’ organ transplantation is viewed as an ethical procedure, but to what extent and by what means? This question can be answered by looking at how ‘fresh’ organs are viewed/thought of, or in other words by answering if ‘fresh’ organs are commodities or a gift. To respond to this question, I will be discussing four major parts of this issue including what (the views of ‘fresh’ organs)/ why (the reasons for using ‘fresh’ organs), who (who are the recipients and donors), and finally the outcomes.

‘Fresh’ organs are defined as organs that have been removed from a living and healthy donor. The procedure to obtain a ‘fresh’ organ is extremely invasive and just as in any surgery it can have severe complications both during and after the procedure is complete. The introduction of the use of ‘fresh’ organs as a viable way of obtaining organs needed for ill patients was introduced after there were no longer enough cadaver organs to help the number of patients in need of a donor organ. When this idea was first presented as can be expected red flags went up. For example in the US, the Hippocratic oath specifically the portion reading ‘ first do no harm’ seemed to clash with this new procedure, but bioethics quickly cleared up this issue by justifying the procedure with two points:
‘(a) the assuran...


... middle of paper ...


...Facing Human Dignity. ' (Michael, "Medical Exploitation and Black Market Organs: Profiteering and Disparities in Global Medicine", p. 1)
The issue of masking the use of ‘fresh’ organs as a gift to justify their use as a commodity is still present. The reasons for this occurrence are many, but they all stem from the basic economic principle of supply and demand. This issue has surpassed both geographic and ethical boundaries far enough that brain death in some countries is something that may be redefined in the future (Ikels, 2013, p. 99) along with the practices of ethical organ donation for poor individuals to get money so that they can survive (such as in the Philippines) (Scheper-Hughes, p. 161). All of these things collectively come together to define ‘fresh’ organs as nothing more than a commodity, in the practice of transplant medicine, which is called a gift. 

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about THE SELLING OF ORGANS: RIGHT OR WRONG

- I Introduction All humans have organs. The organ is very important to the humans because without organ humans will not be able to live well. At present, there are many actions that are done by irresponsible people to sell organs. Organ sales cases occur when a person sells or transfers an organ from one body to another body for the purpose of replacing the recipient’s damaged organ. There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney, and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney because of the lack of organs availability....   [tags: Ethical Issues, Human Organs]

Free Essays
687 words (2 pages)

To What Exetent Does Recycling Decrease the Carbon Footprint Essay

- Introduction to Recycling Recycling is defined as the process of the collecting and the processing of materials (materials that on many occasions thrown away) ,and then shaving them into fresh commodities and turning them into new products. Recycling is important to the world today due to new technologies and new products constantly being devised. Without recycling Earth would plausibly end up as a planet of waste , a scenario depicted in the Disney Pixar movie ,Wall-E. So in all the questions being evaluated digress from “What occurs after they put that plastic bottle into the recycle bin?” to “To what extent is does recycling actually decrease the carbon footprint.” Hence is recycling s...   [tags: processing materials into fresh commodities]

Better Essays
3211 words (9.2 pages)

Essay on The Gift of the Magi

- Many critics agree, “The Gift of the Magi” is, in all respects, an amazing and one of a kind story. One critic says, “Ironically, Fagin arrives at something utterly crucial to the success of 'The Gift of the Magi': that it has everything—an absorbing (if short) narrative drive and a twist ending that makes it wholly original” (Korb). Even renowned critic, Rena Korb, agrees; O.Henry did an excellent job with this story. Though O. Henry wrote many great stories, one of his most famous, and favorite, stories of all time is “The Gift of the Magi.” “The gift of the Magi” is a classic about a couple who sacrifices their happiness for the other....   [tags: The Gift of the Magi]

Better Essays
4443 words (12.7 pages)

The Transplantation of Organs and Tissues Essay

- Medicine has made great strides in the past few centuries. One such advancement is the transplantation of organs and tissues. Those who receive transplants are often times patients with fatal diseases, and these transplants give them a second chance at life. Unfortunately, the number of people needing a transplant is growing more rapidly than available organs; statistics say that in the United States, seventeen people die daily while hoping for an organ transplant (Friedman & Friedman, 2006). Laws restrict transplantable organs to those organs that are donated; the donor must be of sound mind and be a minimum of eighteen years of age....   [tags: buying and selling organs]

Better Essays
1130 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Legalizing the Sale of Human Organs

- A human is born completely as he must end his life completely. No one on earth can buy a life. But people are buying part of a human life causing people to live with a body that’s not completed. In general, many people in the modern world are unwilling to legalize the sale of human organs even if it was a part of a dead human body (Mill, 2009). Also, selling organs is mostly against the moral values to some religions like Islam. However, in the modern world the increase of organ transplants is affected by the shortage of supply of the organs....   [tags: moral, values, transplants, organs, supply]

Better Essays
745 words (2.1 pages)

The Gift of the Magi, by O. Henry Essay

- Stories of love and sacrifice abound in literature. Perhaps one of the most well known stories among teens and adults is the tale of a poor, young couple struggling to find the perfect Christmas gifts for each other using their very limited means. They each manage to get what they think is the perfect gift for the other, but only accomplish this by selling a prized possession which effectively makes the new gifts impractical. This bittersweet narrative, “The Gift of the Magi” by O. Henry, illustrates the moral idea that a person, motivated by nothing but love for another, can possess a willingness to give in a self-denying way which necessitates that the reader consider that wealth be m...   [tags: The Gift of the Magi]

Better Essays
1228 words (3.5 pages)

The Gift Of The Magi Essay

- One dollar and eighty seven cents.That was all.Three times Della counted it.One dollar and eighty seven cents and the next day was Christmas.In the story “The Gift Of The Magi” the main character Della cuts her hair,which is her prized possesion to buy a tab chain for her husband.Jim’s pocket watch.In this story the author shows us how people sometimes sacrifice for love.Unfortunetely Jim sells his watch to buy Della a set of combs for her hair. In the story the main literary element is theme,which is impacted by character, conflict,irony,setting point of view,symbolism,tone and mood.The theme in this story is love is a better gift than any item.The setting of the story impacts the theme b...   [tags: Love, English-language films, Gift]

Better Essays
1185 words (3.4 pages)

The Perfect Christmas Gift: A Watch Essays

- Beyond the joy that causes cold and the snow coming season, there are other reasons to expect more interesting winter. Christmas is one of the exciting holidays of the year and if you look in terms of gifts, is the most beautiful and awaited celebration. Most times, however, this event involves some headaches because choosing gifts for your loved ones, often proves to be an impossible task. Therefore, one of the most efficient codes that you can enjoy presenting your loved one is watches. Do not be impressed by a watch that uses a large number of gemstones....   [tags: gear, design, features, gift]

Better Essays
531 words (1.5 pages)

Essay about Glossolalia: A Gift of the Spirit

- Glossolalia: A Gift of the Spirit The ‘Gift of Tongues’ (Glossolalia) as described by many Christians in present day is said to be evident proof of the manifestation of the Holy Ghost in an individual. Although many outsiders see it as a new belief or ideology, Christians believe that it is not a new practice but rather a forgotten gift of the spirit given to the early church right after Jesus’ departure. Many believers provide proof of that by recalling the biblical event with the Apostles at the Pentecost, found in Acts 2 and also the twelfth chapter of the first Pauline letter to the Corinthians....   [tags: christians, gift of tongues, holy ghost]

Better Essays
847 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on A Continuation of The Gift Of The Magi

- It was one week from Della's 30th birthday and Jim didn't have enough money to buy her a present. "Well," Jim thought, “if I don't have a watch then why should I have a chain for one?” So, he sold his watch chain in order to have money for Della's present. “Now, what do I buy Della?” he asked himself. “I think I'll go to the flea market and look for something, because one little rusty old chain won't buy me very much,” Jim stated as he started riding his bicycle to the market. At the market Jim found many things, some very pretty and expensive, some very pretty and cheap, and some just plain ugly things that had been there awhile and always would be until they were finally thrown a...   [tags: The Gift Of The Magi]

Better Essays
1310 words (3.7 pages)