Goring’s study about physical features of thousands of English prisoners contradicts that of Lombroso as he found none of the distinctive facial characteristics noted by Lombroso. However, he did determine that a common factor amongst criminals were that they were of low intelligence. Since Lombroso’s main claim was that criminality is genetic, and that intelligence is determined by genes, this provides some support.
Overall, there are many limitations to Lombroso’s study as his findings based on the facial measurements of hundreds of criminals, and the skulls of deceased criminals were not compared to a control group of non- criminals. This is a problem as some people who are not criminals may contain some/ all of the above physical features too. Firstly, it is extremely deterministic as it assumes that people are born a criminal due to predisposed factors, and is unable to escape their destiny meaning that it does not take into account social or economic factors. This may raise...
... middle of paper ...
...sues with social desirability and as it is a self report method, there may be a social desirability bias.
A major problem with this theory overall is that there is little evidence to support it. However, Cochrane found links between the psychoticism and neuroticism, but not necessarily on extraversion. Therefore it can be argued that prison time could affect the rates of neuroticism – Thus, causing them to develop a certain type of personality. Again, it is reductionist and it ignores other reasons for crime by solely putting the blame on the individual ignoring things such as the role society (social inequality) and culture plays on crime.
In conclusion, these explanations of crime are simplistic and therefore it is probably better to take an interactionist approach, seeing genes, society, upbringing and personality all interacting to cause criminal behaviour.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- As the act of criminality is a global phenomenon, there must therefore be some explanation as to why this is; some schools of thought strive to explicate this by means of genetics, whilst others take a more socially influenced approach. Although at the time, the micro-criminological theories of Lombroso and Sheldon may have appeared credible, modern research has attempted to refute such notions. In an epidemiological context, the act of crime is seen by some as a positive contribution to society, as noted by Durkheim (Kirby et al, 2000), although too much will lead to social instability, or anomie.... [tags: Psychology, Micro-Criminological Theories]
1900 words (5.4 pages)
- Criminals are born not made. The basic definition of the word criminal is someone who commits offending behaviour within society (Harrower, 2001). The crime may range from petty theft to murder. Criminals are born not made is the discussion of this essay, it will explore the theories that attempt to explain criminal behaviour. Psychologists have come up with various theories and reasons as to why individuals commit crimes. These theories represent part of the classic psychological debate, nature versus nurture.... [tags: Crime, Psychology]
2147 words (6.1 pages)
- What makes a criminal. This is a question that I hope to divulge a plausible answer for. Criminals are people who are liable of deplorable rough unlawful acts, which maltreat the laws of a nation. Criminality is the act of carrying out a crime, which therapists have concocted numerous speculations and reasons regarding why individuals perpetrate criminal acts. The two primary illustrations lie in hereditary and natural components, which identifies with the nature vs. nurture debate. Criminality has been in presence from the beginning of time, where Cain killed his sibling capable.... [tags: criminals, criminality, crime]
1153 words (3.3 pages)
- There are many ways to get a point across or tell a story, but the ones that are mainly used are photographs and narratives. The differences between these two are in the details because they both tell a story. When you tell a story with a photograph you tend to add filters. Sometimes you even choose to capture only a certain part of the story with absolutely no context surrounding it. However, with a narrative you are able to go into complete detail, be it personal or factual, as well as be able to describe all of the story by also giving stories and examples.... [tags: Narrative, Narrative mode, Born into Brothels]
1072 words (3.1 pages)
- By 1978, roughly thirty women were dead and mutilated by the same man with little explanation as to why. Ted Bundy, one of the most infamous serial killers in history brutally took the lives of numerous women for seemingly no reason at all. His justification for these murders was simply that he felt like committing them. A serial killer is defined as someone who has killed more than three people over a period of a month or more for seemingly no reason at all. Most serial killers have no real motive for killing; for them it is an urge that they must satisfy.... [tags: ted bundy, serial killer, abusive childhood]
1552 words (4.4 pages)
- Who Says They are Criminals. The stereotype common in American minds is a juxtaposition of Mexicans being illegal aliens versus hard workers who will work the least desirable jobs for low pay. This ethnography was an enlightening backstory into the lives of ten men born in Léon, Mexico. Some were friends, some were family, but they all came to Chicago in search of a better wage to support themselves and even their family. When comparing the American way of life with the Mexican way of life, as Gomberg-Muñoz writes, Alejandro “went from making $30 a week to $150 a week” (63).... [tags: Immigration to the United States]
1264 words (3.6 pages)
- Fathers every year in Washington go to jail for nothing more than being broke (Deadbeat). They are called “dead beat dads” by their peers, scorn by society, and treated as subclass citizens (THE, ASSOCIATED). This is a very grim reality that men of every age range face daily. Both men and women make the choices which result in babies. However, women are given a choice at every stage of the child’s development to adopt out, abort, or even use contraception (Why). Thus, men and women share equal responsibility in the acts that conceive children.... [tags: Argumentative, Persuasive]
2046 words (5.8 pages)
- Freakonomics “Where Have All the Criminals Gone?” Makalynn Brown Pols 101 Summary: Chapter four of Freakonomics starts off by giving background information of the dictator in Romania. Nicolae Ceausescu was the dictator of Romania that made abortion illegal. With this new abortion law Ceausescu wanted to strengthen Romania’s population. Before the abortion law, there were four abortions to every live birth (Levitt and Dubner, 2009). However, women who already had four children and were apart of the communist party were exempt from this law.... [tags: Roe v. Wade, Abortion, Crime, Capital punishment]
974 words (2.8 pages)
- It is widely known that the upbringing of a child plays a large part in how they turn out as a teenager and also how they turn out as an adult. In fact, many parents like to expose their children to the music of Mozart and other classical composers and engage them in as many activities as possible in an effort to increase their chances of becoming successful and well off adults. However, this has the potential to go both ways, and when faced with a violent and often malevolent upbringing, the possibility of the child turning to criminal behaviour increases.... [tags: parents, classical music, violence]
1869 words (5.3 pages)
- Day after day in this country there is a debate going on about the death penalty and whether we as people have the right to decide the fate of another persons life. When we examine this issue we usually consider those we are arguing about to be older men and women who are more than likely hardened criminals with rap sheets longer than the height we stand (Farley & Willwerth, 1998). They have made a career of crime, committing it rather than studying it, and somewhere along the line a jury of their peers decided enough was enough.... [tags: Juvenile Delinquency]
2773 words (7.9 pages)