The debates between applied and pure anthropologists’ demonstrate the difficulties which those engaged in native title litigations encounter. Debates to whether anthropologists’ engaged in native title hearings are morally and intellectually adequate are discussed in contemporary anthropology. These debates between anthropologists’ cause various ambiguities to the role and ability of those practicing engaged anthropology. David Trigger’s article, ‘Anthropology Pure and Profane: The Politics of Applied Research in Aboriginal Australia’, outlines some criticisms engaged anthropologists’ face and attempts to disprove them. Trigger’s points in this article caused debates amongst applied and pure anthropologists’ revealing many ambiguities and complexities. Firstly, I will discuss Trigger’s arguments to the uncertainties of the moral and intellectual ability of engaged anthropology in native title cases. Secondly, through citing anthropologists’ such as Diane Austin-Broos, Rohan Bastin and Francesca Merlan, I will display the ambiguous role engaged anthropologists’ have and the complex relationship held between pure and applied anthropology. Thirdly, by discussing Bruce Kapferer and Barry Morris’s responses to Trigger, I will show the complex relationship between anthropology, the state and corporations. Then the difficulties which engaged anthropologists’ face in the legal realm will be highlighted. Finally, I will discuss the difficulty those engaged in native title cases face to whether their work is assisting or subjugating Aboriginal communities. These ambiguities, difficulties and complexities which arise from anthropologists’ participating in native title are deliberated in the following essay.
Ambiguous Nature o...
... middle of paper ...
Austin-Broos, D 2012, ‘Three Points and Three Replies’, Anthropological Forum, vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 68-69
Bastin, R 2012, ‘Comment on Trigger’s Manichean Dualism’, Anthropological Forum, vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 71
Merlan, F 2012, ‘Different, Not Impure’, Anthropological Forum, vol. 22, no.1, pp. 75-78
Morris, B 2012, ‘Expert Knowledge and the Tide of History’, Anthropological Forum, vol. 22, no.1, pp. 79
Peterson, N 2012, ‘Comment on Trigger’s Paper’, Anthropological Forum, vol. 22, no.1, pp. 81
Trigger, D 2011, ‘Anthropology pure and profane: the politics of applied research in Aboriginal Australia’, Anthropological Forum, vol. 21, no. 3, pp. 234-248
Trigger, D 2012, ‘Response to Comments’, Anthropological Forum, vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 85-89
Vaarzon-Morel, P 2012, ‘Intertwined Anthropologies’, Anthropological Forum, vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 84
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Applied Anthropology is difficult to fully implement into a being’s existence. When using applied anthropology, many factors must be taken into account such as the Darwin approach, theological approach, or any other specialized field of anthropology. All can have an effect on human culture and relationships, but all have their benefits and harms that can behoove or dismay a human individual in their field of study. The study of humanity is unfortunately as fallible as humanity itself, and to gage what applied anthropology actually is—we must understand the harms and benefits of the many different approaches.... [tags: Physical Anthropology]
1505 words (4.3 pages)
- What is applied anthropology and how can it be applied to almost every facet of society. The answer is obvious when we look at what the field of anthropology encompasses. Anthropology, as defined by the American Anthropological Association is, “the study of humans, past and present.” In the United States, anthropologists are educated in one of the four areas, sociocultural anthropology, biological/physical anthropology, archaeology, and linguistics. Active within these four subfields is Applied Anthropology, which is the application of the method and theory of an anthropological subfield to the analysis and solution of real world situations and practical problems.... [tags: Physical Anthropology]
1518 words (4.3 pages)
- Urbanization is the process of life for many and the desired way of life for many others. Human beings both inhabit urban and rural areas today all over the world. Many people may be disappointed with the development of an increasing number of urban areas. Many peoples once rural areas are now swallowed up directly as cities sprawl outward. The effects of urbanization both positive and negative get examined in the following paragraphs. In addition, who is most effected by urbanization and who plays a role in preventing and/or properly planning development will also be revealed.... [tags: Anthropology ]
1818 words (5.2 pages)
- Though women have played an integral part in the history of the discipline of anthropology, it was not until the early 1970’s that the field of anthropology and gender, or feminist anthropology emerged. Sex and gender roles have always been a vital part of any ethnographic study, but the contributors of this theory began to address the androcentric nature of anthropology itself. The substantial gap in information concerning the study of women was perceived as a male bias, a prejudice made more apparent because what little women-centered fieldwork was done received insufficient attention from the academic community.... [tags: Feminist Anthropology ]
1582 words (4.5 pages)
- This paper seeks to show the inter-relationship of bio- medical professionals such as doctors and nurses in comparison with medical anthropologists and try to show their relevancy in the healthcare system and their collaboration in inter-professionalism. Medical anthropology is an advancing sub-discipline of anthropology. Medical anthropology is intended to provide a framework, which should enable students to identify and analyze social, cultural, behavioural and environmental factors in relation to health and disease/illness in any given society.... [tags: Medical Anthropology]
940 words (2.7 pages)
- There is a lot of conflict to the question “is anthropology a science?” A lot of this conflict leads from defining what a science is, in the dictionary science is, “a branch of knowledge or study dealing with a body of facts or truths systematically arranged and showing the operation of general laws.” (Dictionary.com, 2011) Anything that can be studied is considered a science. Without science anthropology would be nearly impossible to study, science makes everything quantifiable.... [tags: Anthropology ]
959 words (2.7 pages)
- The Devlopment of Reflexive Anthropology Reflexive anthropology has pressured scholoars to recognize their own biases and look increasingly inwards when studying “other” cultures. Reflexive anthropology is a break away from the traditional study of a clearly defined “us” and “them,” that seeks to shift towards indentification rather than difference. It attempts to uncover the politics behind ethnography. Reflexivity shows how “we” are effected by “others”, and how “others” are effected by “us.” It holds anthropologists accountable for what they write, and how they represent culture.... [tags: Cultural Anthropology Essays]
737 words (2.1 pages)
- Physical anthropology “is in large part, human biology seen from an evolutionary perspective” (Jurmaln, Kilgore & Trevathan, 2011). By this statement, I believe the authors mean that physical anthropology studies human biology with an evolutionary viewpoint rather than a scientific or medical viewpoint. Anthropology, as a broader science, is concerned with and studies human culture and the evolutionary aspects of human biology. Since culture affects human beings and human beings affect culture, the two are intertwined, and it therefore, makes sense to study them together.... [tags: anthropology, human biology, genetcs]
916 words (2.6 pages)
- Anthropology Today In society today, the discipline of anthropology has made a tremendous shift from the practices it employed years ago. Anthropologists of today have a very different focus from their predecessors, who would focus on relating problems of distant peoples to the Western world. In more modern times, their goal has become much more local, in focusing on human problems and issues within the societies they live. This paper will identify the roles anthropologists today play, such as where they perform the bulk of their work, and what it is they do in both problem solving, as well as policy making.... [tags: Anthropology]
1735 words (5 pages)
- Anthropology - Lucy in Hadar In a search to find our ancestors, several anthropologists have found evidence to support their conclusions. In the films about Don Johanson's discovery of Lucy in Hadar, one may be very intrigued by the first film but very disturbed by the second film. I was very intrigued by the findings of the Australopithecines. The idea that Lucy, the skeleton found in Hadar, Africa, was closely related to the human species was amazing. Lucy was bipedal and her brain was smaller than that of modern humans.... [tags: Anthropology]
557 words (1.6 pages)