1. God is 'that which nothing greater can be conceived'.
2. If someone understands a thing, than that thing exists in someone's understanding.
3. If someone understands 'that which nothing greater can be conceived', then 'that which nothing greater can be conceived' exists in someone's understanding. (from 1 and 2)
4. Someone understands 'that which nothing greater can be conceived'.
5. Therefore, 'that which nothing greater can be conceived' exists in someone's understanding. (from 3 and 4)
6. If 'that which nothing greater can be conceived' exists in someone's understanding, then 'that which nothing greater can be conceived' can be conceived to exist in reality as well.
7. Existing in reality as well as in someone's understanding is greater than existing in someone's understanding alone.
8. If 'that which nothing greater can be conceived' exists in someone's understanding alone, then something can be conceived which is greater than 'that which nothing greater can be conceived'. (from 6 and 7)
9. Nothing can be conceived which is greater than 'that which nothing greater can be conceived'.
10. Therefore, 'that which nothing greater can be conceived' doesn't exist in someone's understanding alone. (from 8 and 9)
11. Therefore, 'that which nothing greater can be conceived' exists in reality. (from 5 and 10)
12. Therefore, God exists in reality. (from 1 and 11).
Anselm's argument not only depends on the idea of something being 'that ...
... middle of paper ...
...ed', and this term is that which Anselm's entire argument rests.
If nothing else, Anselm spurred thought on the existence of God. The language it uses is simple enough to grasp, e.g.- greatness, existence, reality, etc. While it probably won't convince the Atheist that he is in error, it can take an already believing Christian and strengthen his conviction, which may have been the purpose in the first place, as some commentators have suggested that it wasn't intended to be a proof at all (Marenbon 121).
Chambers, Timothy. "On Behalf of the Devil: A Parody of Anselm Revisited." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 100 (2000): 102-103.
Cosgrove, Matthew R. "Thomas Aquinas on Anselm's Argument." The Review of Metaphysics 27, No. 3 (1974): 513-514.
Marenbon, John. Midieval Philosophy: An Historical and Philosophical Introduction. Routledge, 2006.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Anselm’s ontological argument was presented in chapter two of Anselm’s Proslogion. The actual argument is as follow: (1) If God exists only in understanding, then we can think of a being greater than God. (2) We can’t think of a being greater than God. (3) Therefore not the case that God only exists in the understanding. (4) Either God exists in reality or God exists in the understanding. (5) Therefore God exist in reality (conclusion). To put this argument in conclusion argument form it would look like this: 1. If P then Q 2. Not Q 3. Not P 4. R or P 5. Therefore R This argument is in modus tollen form, so since it is modus tollen it is valid.... [tags: religion, theology]
986 words (2.8 pages)
- It is important to show why the topic you are discussing is important, especially if there are other topics that could be studied in place of the one you are discussing. In this case, the discussion is on Saint Anselm and his Ontological Argument. There have been other arguments made before Saint Anselm on God's existence, and the first paragraph will show why it is important to study this particular argument. Then the argument itself is given and discussed. And just like most arguments in the field of philosophy, the Ontological Argument has an objection.... [tags: Philosophy]
959 words (2.7 pages)
- Exposing the Weakness of Saint Anselm of Canterbury’s Ontological Argument In a world of scientific inquiry, atheism, and the assassination of God, we are often neglectful of our Glorious God’s existence. With new theories of neuropsychology, quantum physics, gene therapy, evolution, and psychobiology, we are constantly forced to edge God out of our lives, to be replaced with cold, empty scientific thought. What, with meme theory, genetic predisposition, evolutionary spontaneous generation, dark matter, super string theory, multi-layered universes, and the neurological reasons behind consciousness, we are becoming more and more distant from the reality that is God.... [tags: Philosophy Essays]
1183 words (3.4 pages)
- Exploring the Ontological Argument For nearly a thousand years, the ontological argument has captured the attention of philosophers. The ontological argument was revolutionary in its sequence from thought to reality. It was an argument that did not require any corresponding experiment in reality; it functioned without the necessity of empirical data. Despite flaws and problems found in some ontological arguments and the objections raised to those arguments, ontological arguments still provide a phenomenal vehicle for ontological discussion through St.... [tags: phylosophy, Anselm's argument]
1752 words (5 pages)
- Due to the preconceptions I have concerning Anselm’s Ontological Argument, as learnt through course research and lectures. I will like Descartes in his ‘First Meditation’, put these preconceptions to one side and present an essay that explores both sides of the argument in an attempt to reach an independent conclusion. However, I hope to reach the same conclusion as I had before – that is, that the Ontological Argument can be refuted on the basis that there exists a fundamental dissimilarity between the concept of existence in our minds, and that of existence in reality.... [tags: existence of god, ontological argument, descartes]
1515 words (4.3 pages)
- The Ontological Argument In Anselm's ontological argument he is trying to prove the existence of God, his argument is an argument purely based on the mind and does not require the moral agent to venture into the real of the senses. Ontology is to do with being, or what something is. Anselm's ontological argument concerns existence and whether it is an attribute of God in the same way omnipotence, omniscience and benevolence are believed to be. The argument is an a priori argument.... [tags: Philosophy Religion]
681 words (1.9 pages)
- The Ontological Argument The Ontological argument is a group of different philosophers arguments for the existence of God. "Ontological" literally means talking about being and so in this case, that being is the existence or being of God. The main component of the Ontological argument can be found in the Anselm’s "Proslogion" which is a short work that tries to demonstrate both the existence and the nature of God. His main aim in writing the Proslogion is not to directly prove the existence of God but to moreover, to show the relationship between faith and reason.... [tags: social issues]
1591 words (4.5 pages)
- The Ontological Argument The Ontological Argument, put forth by Saint Anselm in his Proslogium, attempts to prove the existence of God simply by the fact that we have a particular concept of God - that God is "that than which nothing greater can be conceived." Saint Anselm presents a convincing argument that many people view as the work of a genius. It is also quite often considered a failure because, in William L. Rowe's words, "In granting that Anselm's God is a possible thing we are in fact granting that Anselm's God actually exists." In other words, it "assumes the point it is supposed to prove", primarily because is assumes that existence is a great-making quality, and for God... [tags: Philosophy essays]
1436 words (4.1 pages)
- Most people have not witnessed or experienced God and therefore are confused about its existence. In Western theology, three theories have emerged to demonstrate the existence of God. These theories are the ontological argument, the cosmological argument, and the teleological argument. St. Anselm of eleventh century, and Descartes of seventeenth century, have used the ontological argument for proving the existence of God. The God, for them, is supreme, "needing nothing outside himself, but needful for the being and well-being of all things." (Pg.... [tags: essays research papers]
2908 words (8.3 pages)
- Anselm Anselm was born in 1033 to noble parents in a place called Aosta in Italy. He and his mother always had a strong relationship, but his relationship with his father was quite different. They never did get along well at all. Anselm knew at an early age that he wanted to be a monk. While a child, he imagined that heaven rested in the mountains of Jupiter high above his home and this possibly helped to foster that dream. Anselm later went through a brief period in which he no longer wanted to become a monk, but at the age of fifteen he tried to become a monk and failed.... [tags: Papers]
661 words (1.9 pages)