Animal Testing Discussion Essay

Animal Testing Discussion Essay

Length: 2305 words (6.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The major ancient philosophers, Thomas Aquinas and Rene Descartes, argue that animals lack a moral status because they do not engage in rational thought, are not conscious, and do not behave morally (Wilson, 2001). However, contrary to their beliefs, non-human animals do display the characteristics that Aquinas and Descartes claim qualifies humans for a moral status. In this paper, I will argue that animals should have an equal moral status to that of humans. This is due to the lack of relevant differences between humans and animals in the areas of thinking rationally, having a conscience, and behaving morally.

This paper will be organized into three main sections. The first section “Background Information” will introduce the broader subject of animal ethics. The second section, “The Argument,” will begin by presenting arguments from philosophers, including Rene Descartes and Thomas Aquinas. In this section, I will discuss why these philosophers refuse to give non-human animals a moral status. Next, I will be supporting the second premise by appealing to recent examples in the animal kingdom, and by referring to arguments from Peter Singer and Robert Garner. Finally, I will conclude in the final section, “Conclusion,” by asserting that because humans and animals have a lack of relevant differences (with respect to what makes humans moral beings), animals do have a moral status.

So, what does the animal ethics issue deal with? First, there are still many problems with the way we treat animals today. It is not an exaggeration, as some say, when animal rights activists point out that humans submit animals to unimaginable atrocities. To test for the safety of a shampoo, for example, rats are subject to ex...


... middle of paper ...


...als may not have exactly the same emotions and interests as humans, but their respective properties must be taken into consideration because every life form must be treated with respect.

Finally, as a way to wrap up this paper, I will appeal to a video from Chile that involves a stray dog rescuing a second stray dog (“Hero Dog”). In this video, a dog spots another dog who had been hit by a car. The dog goes to the middle of the highway and attempts to help the injured dog by using its front paws to drag it to the side of the highway and into safety. The dog had no benefit in helping the second dog. In fact, it put itself in danger because it was crossing a busy highway and could have been hit. Therefore, the dog went above its basic instinct (contrary to Aquinas’s argument that non-human animals act on pure instinct). What can this “hero” dog’s behavior tell us?

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Animal Testing Should Not Be Banned Essay

- The use of animals in research has created a diverse range of attitudes, as some individuals support the use of animal testing and others are against it. Sometimes people do not have enough background knowledge on this topic to be involved in a discussion. Animal testing dates back to around 400 years ago, when one of the first famous researchers William Harvey was curious to discover how blood circulates around the body. The modern era of animal testing began around 150 years ago, although the conditions were quite different; the animals suffered severely as there were no anesthetics (Understanding Animal Research 2013)....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights, Medical research]

Powerful Essays
1289 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on A Controversial Debate About Animal Testing

- 1. Learned from the book- Animal testing is the use of animals for experimentation. There is a very controversial debate about animal testing because of ethical issues. Animal testing is considered invasive research because the researchers who test on them are causing physical harm to the animals. One of the cruel procedures they perform on these animals involves producing lesions in the brain. These lesions are created by surgery and are put there to observe the effects on animal behavior. The goal of this research is to understand how the brain effects the animal’s behavior and if this research can be applied to humans....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights, Psychology, Science]

Powerful Essays
869 words (2.5 pages)

The Pros and Cons of Animal Testing Essays

- The argument as to whether or not animal testing should be done has been going on for decades. Medical laboratories and shelters are common places where most animals are tested. Animals are typically used because they are cheap and easily obtainable. Some believe that the usage of animals is morally and ethically wrong because animals are still considered thinking and breathing living things. Others believe that because they are not human, that they can do whatever they want with them. The implementation of laws has also been in discussion to avoid inhumane treatment of animals....   [tags: animal rights, inhumane treatment of animals]

Powerful Essays
1035 words (3 pages)

Essay about Another Look at Animal Testing

- Another Look at Animal Testing When it comes to animal testing, one of the first thing most people think of, is that animals are used simply for bettering and improving cosmetics. Many would argue that using helpless animals for tests without a huge benefit to society is not fair, and their innocent lives are worth more. However, animal testing is actually crucial and beneficial for society. Animal testing may be cruel, nevertheless the animals allow the medical practices to advance, the military to attain knowledge and the population of both human and animal is not effected in anyway therefore, animal research should continue....   [tags: animal cruelty, exploitation and abuse]

Powerful Essays
1142 words (3.3 pages)

Animal Testing Should Be Banned Essay

- In the 21st century humans live under a constitution which protects their basic rights as a human being, the same does not go for animals though it should (Singer 22). Even though in today’s society people believe that through animal testing and selling animal made products it will accumulate to something positive in the long run, animal testing and the use of animals for clothes should be banned because in the end animals are mistreated and even killed during the process. “Animals deserve respect, argues author and animal rights philosopher Tom Regan, not because it is good to be kind but because as sentient creatures they satisfy the same criteria humans possess for being valuable” (Frey 2...   [tags: Animal rights, Tom Regan]

Powerful Essays
858 words (2.5 pages)

Animal Experimentation Should Be Banned Essay

- Although many pro-test members claim that animal experimentation is a necessary proceeding, these practices should be removed from the research process. The statistics from numerous researches and investigations have revealed what many are refusing to see, that the outcome of these experiments is vague and indefinite. Cosmetic companies and health institutions kill millions of animals each year. Animal testing is imprecise, expensive, unethical, unnecessary and ancient science that should be punished severely....   [tags: Human, Mammal, Animal rights, Science]

Powerful Essays
1283 words (3.7 pages)

An Informative Documentary On Animal Rights Essay

- Animal Rights Introduction: Along the list of ‘rights movements’, the animal rights movement has its place. Just as the internet has helped further the cause of the protesters of of wall street in the 2000’s and the “Black Lives Matter” movement in 2015, Animal Rights activists has flourished in the readily available spreading of information. Earthlings, an informative documentary on the suffering of animals, has more than half a million views on YouTube alone. Animal suffering stems from regions such as the industry and research and testing....   [tags: Animal rights, Animal welfare, Animal testing]

Powerful Essays
1851 words (5.3 pages)

The Ethics Of Animal Experimentation Essay

- At the turn of the new century, activists begun to protest the morality of animal experimentation: “… such methodology is far too cruel on beast, it cannot better mankind, but its lead to it demise…” Despite the rising concern for animal safety in laboratory research, federal legislations approved the practice. According to the federal bureaucrats, it is an essential tool to improve our current medical knowledge. Hence, most of the tested animals have a relatively shorter life span than human....   [tags: Animal rights, Human, Primate, Animal testing]

Powerful Essays
755 words (2.2 pages)

Detrimental Aspects of Animal Experimentation Essay

- An intense and polarizing deliberation concerning the issue of animal experimentation and the utilization in research has been raging for years. This issue often catches newspaper headlines and strikes the heart of the American public. The opinion of advocates of animal research and the opinion of those who oppose it are quite visible in the media. Both sides tirelessly strive in advancing their unique beliefs. So far as this discussion is specifically focused on the attainment of favorable legislation by one side or the other, special interest groups have been formed by both parties in order to sway the legislators and numerous bureaucrats to their desired side....   [tags: Animal Rights]

Powerful Essays
2177 words (6.2 pages)

Essay on Animal Rights And The Human Rights Movement

- Research Paper The animal rights group PETA has over five million members, making it the largest of it’s kind (About PETA). The goal of this group and others like it, is to give animals rights on the basis that they are equal to humans. They do this because they believe that we are currently manipulating animals and not treating them properly. This is the basis for the animal rights movement. Animal Rights has been a topic of discussion within the United States for decades, however, with the recent rise of the internet and social media, the size of the groups advocating for animal rights has increased dramatically, the same can be said for the demands of these groups....   [tags: Animal rights, Animal welfare]

Powerful Essays
1454 words (4.2 pages)