Essay on Animal Rights, Human Wrongs, By Tom Regan

Essay on Animal Rights, Human Wrongs, By Tom Regan

Length: 1052 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Tom Regan’s article “Animal Rights, Human Wrongs,” he explores three different philosophical “accounts” and talks about their view and stances on animal rights and the treatment of animals. The first account that Regan looks at is the Kantian account, which is that humans have obligations to treat animals right only because if humans treated animals poorly it would lead to humans treating one another poorly. Regan says this account to be amiss because it makes us assume that animal interests do not matter and that we are not concerned with the poor treatment of the animal, yet instead we are concerned with the effect the action will have on humans in the future. The second account that Regan analyzes is the cruelty account, which revolves around the idea of cruelty. Cruelty is described by saying people who are inclined to get joy in or get a sort of pressure in causing pain to a living creature. Regan expresses this account as inadequate because the idea of the cruelty account does not take into account animal welfare issues, however it puts way too much emphasize on the prevention of cruelty against animals it overshadows the moral issues that are involved with animal rights. Regan addresses that the cruelty account implies that someone who is cruel to animals takes pleasure in it. With all that being said, Regan says it is inadequate mainly because it does not put animal welfare as the top priority, but rather explains the issues involving the people conducting the cruel act. The final account that Regan talks about is the Utilitarian account. The Utilitarian account states that having consequences for everyone and everything explains how we should treat animals. Regan claims the utilitarian account is inadequate, due to th...


... middle of paper ...


...the way they treat humans. Nevertheless, I agree with Tom Regan’s plan to bring light to the conversation of animal rights by acting today and speaking for the animals because they cannot speak for themselves and without humans speaking for them, rights for animals will not ever happen. Moreover, I agree with many of the points that Tom Regan made in his article “Animal Rights, Human Wrongs,” but I conclude for his argument about animal’s rights to be strong all around, he would need to make sure to broaden the variety of animals that he is talking about being restrained and killed by humans. In conclusion, I believe that if one animal has rights, then EVERY animal should have rights. If Regan was to talk more about the life of controlled animals, he would really be able to show that humans are taking away the basic rights that animals should have, uniform to humans.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Case For Animal Rights Essay

- In Tom Regan’s “The case for animal rights.”, Regan argues that animals deserve to have rights because of many reasons. He believes that humans mistreat animals and that we are taking advantage of them. Regan states that not only do we slaughter animals for food, but we use them for multiple tests, clothing, and entertainment as well. To me, although Regan’s argument is very broad, his argument passes by many points that many people don’t think about. Regan believes that animals are a subject of life, they therefore deserve rights of their own....   [tags: Animal rights, Tom Regan, Human, Animal testing]

Better Essays
1172 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Animal 's And The Exemption Of Their Rights

- Animal’s and The Exemption of Their Rights Do all animals have the same rights as humans. Some animals do but not all. Humans use and exploit animals in every way as if people are entitled. Animal rights activist believe animals have legal and moral rights the same way humans do. On the other hand there are several cooperations and scientist who disagree and want to use these animals for different purposes. The idea of whether animals are entitled to rights and the involvement of those rights is not as debatable as the aspect of animals having their rights and the consequences what are involves....   [tags: Animal rights, Animal testing, Tom Regan]

Better Essays
1329 words (3.8 pages)

Animal Testing Should Be Banned Essay

- In the 21st century humans live under a constitution which protects their basic rights as a human being, the same does not go for animals though it should (Singer 22). Even though in today’s society people believe that through animal testing and selling animal made products it will accumulate to something positive in the long run, animal testing and the use of animals for clothes should be banned because in the end animals are mistreated and even killed during the process. “Animals deserve respect, argues author and animal rights philosopher Tom Regan, not because it is good to be kind but because as sentient creatures they satisfy the same criteria humans possess for being valuable” (Frey 2...   [tags: Animal rights, Tom Regan]

Better Essays
858 words (2.5 pages)

An Advocate Of Animal Rights Essay

- Analyzing human obligation pertaining to all that is not man made, apart from humans, we discover an assortment of concerns, some of which have been voiced by philosophers such as Tom Regan, Peter Singer and Aldo Leopold. Environmentally ethical ideals hold a broad spectrum of perspectives that, not only attempt to identify a problem, but also focus on how that problem is addressed through determining what is right and wrong. As an advocate of animal rights, Tom Regan presents us with the idea that animals deserve to be treated with equal respect to humans....   [tags: Animal rights, Tom Regan, Peter Singer]

Better Essays
1133 words (3.2 pages)

Animal Rights By Maureen Nandini Mintra Essay

- Animal Rights In today’s society, people are putting up a quite substantial fight for animals to receive the same rights as humans, as far as freedom from cruelty and suffering. Animal rights activists are stating that innocent animals should not be exploited for work, food, or testing just because they are “non-human”. Author, editor, and animal activist, Maureen Nandini Mintra, presents her argument of the importance of supporting animal rights in her magazine article “Animals Are Persons, Too”....   [tags: Animal rights, Animal welfare, Tom Regan, Law]

Better Essays
1663 words (4.8 pages)

Animal Experimentation And Its Effects On Human Animals Essay

- Animal experimentation is contentious issue in today’s society that, whether it continue or should stop. Many animals such as monkey undergo painful suffering or even death as a result of scientific research for the sake of humans’ health. Among the animals monkeys are the main victims of the scientists’ experiments because of their human-like characteristics and physical process to humans. Monkeys’ similarities allow the scientists to test effectiveness of the new discovered drugs, food additives, and chemical and even cosmetics products....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights, Tom Regan]

Better Essays
1302 words (3.7 pages)

The Case For Animal Right Essay

- The Case for Animal Right Recently, some philosophers began to take action on fighting for animal rights. One of them, philosopher Tom Regan, is well-known for his animal rights theories. In his book The Case for Animal Rights, Regan argues that animals should have their rights, and we should not allow speciesism to happen anymore. By using the term inherent value, which is referring to experiencing subject of a life, Regan starts his argument by saying that all of us, despite being human or non-human animals, have equal inherent value, which provides the basis for rights claims, yet inherent value and rights require equal respect....   [tags: Human, Morality, Animal rights, Tom Regan]

Better Essays
1133 words (3.2 pages)

Animal Testing Is Inhumane And Ineffective Essay

- If animals have feelings, Then is animal testing wrong. The relationship between humans and animals has been a controversial and heated debate for decades. Many people have joined animal rights movements to advocate for the fair treatment of animals. Animals have no syntax and so there is no way to accurately communicate with them. Because of that there is currently no proof if animals can feel the same level of emotions as humans. Peter Singer is a supporter of animal rights. In his essay “Animal Liberation” he talks about what animals can feel....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights, Tom Regan]

Better Essays
1329 words (3.8 pages)

Animal Testing Should Not Be Banned Essay

- Animal Experimentation You walk into a room with a mirrored wall that you can see through; you see a dog bed full of young puppies with doctors getting prepared for something. One of the doctors picks up the one of the adorable puppies, with their eyes barely open, and takes it to an operating table; he straps the puppy down as he applies one of your favorite make-up brands to the puppies’ skin, causing it to whimper because of the harsh chemicals that are in the make-up… Need I say more. Animal testing has been going on since early AD....   [tags: Animal rights, Animal testing, Tom Regan]

Better Essays
1147 words (3.3 pages)

Be The Change : Cruelty Free Essay

- Be the Change: Cruelty Free Dogs are known as a “man’s best friend” and the thought of abusing a dog would be sickening, each year hundreds and thousands of innocent animals are being locked in cages inside laboratories. This includes cats, rabbits, mice, and even your best friend (dog). These animals are put through a test, when they are being injected with diseases, chemicals, and other potentially toxic foreign entities. Animals were put on this Earth to walk among us, so they should have the right to live a safe and free life....   [tags: Animal rights, Animal testing, Rights, Tom Regan]

Better Essays
1048 words (3 pages)