Curnutt believes that the prima facie wrongness of animal-eating has not been defeated by additional factors which serve as the overriding reason. From his argument, David Curnutt claims that animal-eating is Ultima facia morally wrong. He further explains there are at least four grounds for overriding this wrong which include traditional-cultural, aesthetic, convenience, nutrition.
First, Animal-eating is a social practice that embeds well in today 's culture. Slavery and racism used to be part of modern culture at their time of occurrence; however, having that status is not what makes practices morally right or wrong. Take Slavery for example. It is wrong because it requires the coercion and degrading of innocent people; not because it no longer exists in our society. The fact that practice has tradition on its side and a solid standing in certain cultures does not mean it carries any moral capacity, so we need to be careful when analyzing the morally of any practice.
Second, Animal flesh is regarded by most people as esthetically pleasing. For example, animal body parts are prepared for consumption in several ways such as using different cooking techniques and spices. The aesthetic attractions of other practices are regarded as irrelevant to their moral appraisal. The former emperor of Rome, Heliogabalus had several innocent people gathered in fields to be murdered for the sole purpose of the pleasing effect he found in the sight of red blood on the green grass. Who would not condemn this barbaric act in the strongest possible way?
Third, the convenience of animal-eating is largely a function of the other two factors. The general public 's desire to eat animals and its status within a variety of soc...
... middle of paper ...
...sons for going to war and thereby result in several wars. The ultimate consequences of a general rule permitting preventative war would, therefore, be worse than one that forbad it. What we face in effect is what David Rodin calls the impasse problem: two competing and apparently equally possible rule-consequentialist interpretations of the preventative war norm. One explanation claims that a rule permitting preventive war would lead to better overall consequences because wars fought early would have less human cost, and would protect valuable goods such as national or international liberties. The other interpretation claims that a rule prohibiting preventive war would lead to overall better consequences because a more permissive doctrine would multiply the number of wars.
Timmons, Mark. Disputed Moral Issues: A Reader. Oxford UP, 2013. Print.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Animal Testing: Is It Ethically Sound. Throughout decades of scientific study, experimentation on animals has been the most common method of testing a product. Animals have been the innocent victims of harmful experiments for research, medicine, and cosmetics. While using animals to conduct experiments has been the most prefered procedure, it is not the most accurate. While primates such as chimpanzees share 99.9% similarities to humans, and rats are 98% genetically similar, they are not the same (Hajar).... [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights, Experiment]
1304 words (3.7 pages)
- Eating out is easily accessible as the economical hawker center, coffee shop, fast food restaurant, food court, restaurants and higher-ends restaurants are spread all over the Kuala Lumpur. Foods of all types and form are readily available at the doorsteps of its population. Such convenience, coupled with the abundance of variety, and reasonably price food has prompted a significant proportion of its population to eat out regularly. Convenience food where no preparation and cooking are needed is readily available and consumed by many as their mid-day meal.... [tags: Health Care, restaurant, eating out, dining]
2465 words (7 pages)
- ... 1). Even though, people who are vegetarian or vegan can include complementary proteins in their diet to supply the body with essential amino acids, there is always a deficiency in micronutrients. According to Craig (2009), “Vitamins B-12 and D, calcium, and long-chain n-3 (omega-3) fatty acids” are absent in vegan diet and people who are vegan commonly take the supplements to replace that (p. 1). In my own opinion, if the diet is not balanced, meaning that it does not provide all nutritional value and I have to take the synthetic substance instead, that diet should be reconsidered.... [tags: consuming livestock is morally correct]
1184 words (3.4 pages)
- Somalis have a unique eating style compared to other people, it is the fasting. They would strictly obey the rule to abstain food, drink, and smoke from sunrise to sunset at the ninth month of Islamic calendar. This cultural tradition really affects the medication experience of Somalis, as a result, they only take their medications at night when fasting. To deal with this cultural conflict with medications, pharmacists should respect the culture differences, and then they may try to change the medication frequency or duration to help Somali patients get the best outcomes from the diseases.... [tags: Medicine, Health care, Health care provider]
1037 words (3 pages)
- At the ripe age of fourteen, my life consisted of friends, school, family and the latest social media networking sites. Lacking commitment and ideals, I went with the flow and considered myself a normal teen. I liked shopping and adored cute animals, the typical generic qualities of a freshman girl entering high school. One night while I ritually logged onto my Facebook checking my notifications, I received a message from one of the Facebook group pages I had recently joined named “cute puppies.” I clicked the message describing a link to an animal rights video.... [tags: Animal Rights]
1796 words (5.1 pages)
- Forks Over Knives Honest Thoughts Out of the four documentaries given as an option to watch, I chose the documentary: “Forks Over Knives”. The title alone grabbed my eyes immediately like a kid in the candy store. Multiple questions flooded my mind. What was the titles meaning to this documentary. That one question furthered my interest to find out what the title of the documentary is truly trying to express. I then came up with some solutions like; maybe the title is trying to let the audience know how less and less people have eating etiquette.... [tags: Nutrition, Food, Chef, Eating]
748 words (2.1 pages)
- “Open your lunchboxes. Let me see that lunch kids, don’t hide” Something you would hear every single day during school before going to recess, the teachers shouted those words to check our lunchboxes to see if our mothers where sending us a complete and “balanced” meal. Everyone lined up to show that they had their portions of vegetables, fruit, a form of carbohydrates and of course, the most important one, your protein. It could be from a ham and cheese sandwich to a small milk box but you needed to have those animal products.... [tags: Nutrition, Eating, Plant, Animal]
1056 words (3 pages)
- “Open your lunch boxes. Let me see that lunch kids, don’t hide” Something you would hear every single day during school before going to recess, the teachers shouted those words to check our lunchboxes to see if our mothers where sending us a complete and “balanced” meal. Everyone lined up to show that they had their portions of vegetables, fruit, a form of carbohydrates and of course, the most important one, your protein. It could be from a ham and cheese sandwich to a small milk box, but you needed to have those animal products.... [tags: Nutrition, Eating, Plant, Animal]
1059 words (3 pages)
- Vegetarianism as a Form of Positive Deviance A young American girl becomes vegetarian when, during dinner, she makes the connection between the very cute lamb she just saw at the petting zoo and the lamb chop that now rests on her plate. She declares she will stop eating meat to her family, and in a series of tumultuous events, including her family dancing and chanting, “you don’t make friends with salad,” her sabotage of her father’s neighborhood barbecue, and her sudden desperation to fit in again as she runs to the local convenience store to eat a hot dog, she realizes becoming a vegetarian is quite the challenge in American culture.... [tags: Meat, Ethics of eating meat, Sociology, Morality]
1286 words (3.7 pages)
- Upon Schlegals return from Figel to Mirab, Audrey informed him that she had to take on assistance from two young individuals to assist in the upkeep of the house; not having anticipated the workload from cooking food to washing clothes. The difficulties Schlegal experienced throughout his time completing his fieldwork was evident; it was apparent that as immensely as he wanted to be with his family and experience Figel, Mirab, and Cobato together. He also was passionate about allowing himself to focus in the field and truly learn the spiritual, cultural, economic, and legal ways of the Teduray.... [tags: Western culture, Western world, Law, Culture]
1461 words (4.2 pages)
- What Is The State Of Nature?
- Collectivism And Individualism As Cultural Syndromes By Harry Triandis
- Narrative Of The Life Of Fredrick Douglass
- Learning Styles With Learning Style
- Cell Genetic Elements Of The Field Of Genetics And Model Organisms
- The Is A Netflix Thriller Drama Television Series That Was Created By Todd And Glenn Kessler And Produced By