The And Moral Responsibility : The State Of The Debate Essay examples

The And Moral Responsibility : The State Of The Debate Essay examples

Length: 1201 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

According to Greenspan, "Such cases as “impaired” psychopaths, perhaps redundantly, to allow for the possibility of deviant but basically functional cases. Though impaired psychopaths are not psychotic, I think we are intuitively inclined to deny them free will insofar as they lack a crucial resource for self-control. However, I shall argue that we can still hold them responsible" (Greenspan 420). Some people believe that Psychopaths are morally accountable for their actions because they still understand right from wrong, they do not feel guilt but they understand society 's laws. As described in the article Psychopaths and Moral Responsibility: The State of the Debate,
A sports analogy may be apt here; does the basketball player need to have a great jump shot to be a good player? I don’t think that she does. She could be good in other facets of the game and lack a good jump shot and still be considered a valuable contributor to the team (or a moral agent-moral community). She may have a hard time playing against teams that allow one to shoot but defend the drive rigorously—but overall, she could still be considered a good player and even in those cases can. Similarly, it seems that the psychopath could be lacking in empathy which could affect her ability to ethically perceive correctly in many passive cases, however, in active cases it seems he could get by just fine. And, in such cases, it would seem appropriate to hold them morally responsible (Caouette).
It is more than a simple play in a basket ball game, it would affect their over all performance. This analogy is not very effective in the sense that if the jump shot is being compared to morality, then morality would be not just a jump sho...

... middle of paper ...

...someone being that they are confined. They should have the chance to understand why they behave the way they do.
The main two facets in constructing a psychopath is their genetic makeup and their environmental background. Psychopath’s are not neurologically correct compared to an average human. There are areas in the neurological structure that a psychopath lacks, producing an undesirable personality. A psychopath can not be morally guilty if they are not born with morals or judgement. Punishment for those who commit a crime is substantial, if considered a part of society they must follow society 's laws. They should have a second chance at redeeming themselves by treatment, but should not have the chance to be let out of jail. If someone has no self-control and lacks the ability to make clear judgments, they cannot possibly be morally responsible for their actions.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Free Will Debate

- The unique ability that each and every individual possesses that enable him/her to control their actions is known as free will. Free will is directly connected to two other vital philosophical issues: freedom of action and moral accountability, which is the main reason why the debate is so vital. Simply stated, a person who has free will refers to an individual’s ability to choose his or her route of action. However, animals also appear to suit this measure, further adding to the debate because free will is typically thought to only be possessed by human beings (Broad 1990)....   [tags: Freedom of Action, Moral Accountability]

Better Essays
3005 words (8.6 pages)

Abortion is Not Moral Essay

- Abortion; as defined by Merriam-Webster dictionary is, “the termination of a pregnancy after, accompanied by, resulting in, or closely followed by the death of the embryo or fetus. This is the definition of abortion of which I will be reviewing its ethical status. After Roe vs Wade, the supreme court simultaneously decided that women have the right of privacy under the 14th amendment; making it acceptable to abort a pregnancy within the first trimester (Vaughn 119). The main argument on abortion is really a debate on human life, and whether it has value from the moment of conception....   [tags: Argument Against Abortion]

Better Essays
1033 words (3 pages)

The Abortion Debate Essay

- No matter where you stand on the issue, abortion is a highly debated topic in today’s society. In this essay I will examine both sides of the abortion issue. I will begin with a brief overview of the abortion debate, to include the morality of the situation. Next I will discuss the Pro-Life argument. Lastly I will look at the Pro-Choice view. In the final analysis I will show how utilitarianism, altruism, and situational ethical views apply to abortion. Having in mind the extreme controversy surrounding this issue, I will examine the history of abortion and why it is so highly debated today....   [tags: Informative Essay]

Better Essays
1536 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on The Debate Of Euthanasia And Assisted Suicide

- Euthanasia was a term that once was used to describe a peaceful way of gently dying, but over the past two centuries the use of this practice by the medical community has redefined the procedure, how it is applied, and who has the right to make such a directive (Boudreau & Somerville, 2014). This essay will delve into the two primary types of euthanasia (active and passive), the ethical issues rose by each type, and the laws about euthanasia in the state of Arizona. The consideration of legal euthanasia and assisted suicide has numerous proponents and antagonist that belief that it is the ultimate form of relief to those who are health stricken and strong bases who hold religious belief agai...   [tags: Euthanasia, Death, Suffering, Homicide]

Better Essays
773 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about The Debate Over Vaccinations On Children

- Freedom of Religion Nothing means more to a parent than their children. What is at odds in the debate over vaccinations is how they show it. On one side, you have parents that believe that vaccinating their kids is the best way to keep them healthy. On the other side you have parents that believe saving their children’s souls is more important, and vaccinating their children goes against their religious beliefs. The 1st amendment states, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” That right is under attack by mandatory vaccinations in America....   [tags: First Amendment to the United States Constitution]

Better Essays
1154 words (3.3 pages)

Morality and Responsibility - Moral Development in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

- Moral Development in Shelley's Frankenstein    Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is a commentary on the natural disposition of man. By personifying her vision of a natural everyman character in the form of Victor Frankenstein's creation, The Creature, Shelley explores the natural state as well as the moral development of man, and develops conclusions regarding both. But before Shelley could create her commentary on man's natural dispositions, she was in need of a character to represent her "natural everyman." The character she needed had to possess the same qualities as that of a man in his most natural state....   [tags: Frankenstein essays]

Better Essays
1618 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Corporate Social Responsibility

- Corporations have social responsibilities to the communities they serve but they do not take on these responsibilities. Corporations have obligations to use their economic power and influence to protect worker welfare and address environmental issues which are often violated as a cause of their business ethics. A corporation is argued to be a profit devouring machine mainly because its core objective is to gain profit for its shareholders. What if this profit originated at the expense of a worker’s human rights....   [tags: Communities, Business Ethics, Violation]

Better Essays
1439 words (4.1 pages)

The Debate of Abortion Essay

- The Debate of Abortion After more than a quarter-century of frenzied debate and denunciation (which began well before Roe v. Wade), one might think not. But there is at least one viewpoint that polls indicate is widely held but that is hardly ever heard amid the screams of 'Murderer!' and 'Keep your rosaries off my ovaries!' It deserves a full and reasoned exposition, however; it might even shed some light on the controversies about the confirmation of Dr. Henry Foster as Surgeon General and about harassment of abortion clinics....   [tags: Pro Life Pro Choice Pregnancy Rights Essays]

Better Essays
957 words (2.7 pages)

Censorship of Music is the Responsibility of the Parent Essay

- Censorship of Music is the Responsibility of the Parent Censorship in music is a topic that has brought about much controversy over the past two decades. There have been many different arguments on the topic, however the question still lingers is should censorship still remain. Before you can form an opinion on this, you must hear both sides of the argument on this much-debated topic. Some people believe that music should be censored so all audiences can hear it without it containing any offensive lyrics....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
732 words (2.1 pages)

Welfare and Social Responsibility Essay

- Welfare and Social Responsibility   Welfare. Read that word to yourself and ask what popular images surround it. The first thing is probably women and children. This one is correct, because 97% of AFDC (Aid to Families with Dependent Children, the federal "welfare" program) is made up of women and children. Young women. Not really-the average age of a mother receiving welfare is 29, and only 7.6% are under the age of 20. Is she black. Maybe, because the composition of the welfare roles is about the same percentage black and white....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Free Essays
2932 words (8.4 pages)