Analyzing the Political Thoughts of Immanuel Kant and G.W.F. Hegel Essay

Analyzing the Political Thoughts of Immanuel Kant and G.W.F. Hegel Essay

Length: 1563 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Director Steve McQueen, in his 2013 film “12 Years a Slave” provides four examples of the philosophical arguments of both Immanuel Kant and G.W.F Hegel. Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit argues two forms of consciousness. His categorization on the codependent relationship between lord and bondsman is complementary to Kant’s political thought on the categorical imperative. Kant argues in The Grounding of Metaphysics of Morals, that in the categorical imperative, law of morality, human beings are not subjective ends but rather objective ends within themself.
In Hegel’s account of the self-consciousness here are two forms of consciousness. The first is an independent consciousness, which exists solely for itself and the second consciousness that is dependent on the independent consciousness of another. The first is the lord, and the second is the bondsman. The lord is mediated through another conscious that is an independent object of his desires. The slave is an independent being-for-self able to serve as an end in himself not simply a means. The lord holds the bondsman in bondage making him dependent yet; the lord’s power is merely a façade power struggle. The bondsman takes away his independence but is not all together done with it. He begins working on it. By setting aside desire’s the bondsman gains an independent consciousness. The lord in his relationship has succeeded in achieving his temporary means to acquiring his desires, but since the independence was interposed the bondsman still maintains some aspect of independence that he then continues to develop.
The lord is now unknowingly dependent on the bondsman’s existence and false recognition. Furthermore the new outcome of the relationship is “one-sided and unequal” (Heg...

... middle of paper ...

The film “12 Years a Slave” has no historical or philosophical ties to Immanuel Kant or G.W.F Hegel. Yet portions of the Phenomenology of Spirit and The Grounding of Metaphysics of Morals are clearly exemplified in the film. Hegel’s perverse relationship between the lord and bondsman is reflected in the relationships between the overseers, lord, and the slaves. Kant’s categorical imperative maxim are violated in the treatment of slaves in the film.

Works Cited

Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich, Arnold V. Miller, and J. N. Findlay. "Independence And Dependence Of Self-Consciousness: Lordship And Bondage. "Phenomenology of Spirit. Oxford: Clarendon, 1977. 111-18. Print.

Kant, Immanuel; Ellington, James W. (2011-02-28). Grounding of Metaphysics of Morals, Third Edition (Translated & Annotated). Hackett Publishing. Kindle Edition.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Marx 's Views On Hegel Essay

- Marx, as previously mentioned, seem similar in many ways to Hegel. However Marx addressed rights in a more helpful manner for us, than Hegel did. Whereas Hegel said it presented the self as `atomistic`, Marx worked with it directly and fitted it neatly within his thought. Rights, (and by rights he was addressing A) according to Marx is constructed by the owners of the means of production for their benefit. This makes it rather simple to conclude if A is indeed equal to B according to Marx, as long as one can simply justify this statement by Marx....   [tags: Marxism, Karl Marx, Mind, Materialism]

Powerful Essays
729 words (2.1 pages)

Hegel's Contradiction in Human History Essay

- Human beings have been struggling to learn the meaning of life since the first day. Ideologies are born as human’s interpretation of the world and belief system, also an endeavor to seek the truth of human nature. Ideologies emerge throughout the periods of great changes: the Enlightenment, the English “Glorious” Revolution, the American Revolution, etc. They have become the motivations, the standards, and the roots to modern political systems. Their roots are the philosophies developed by famous philosophers throughout the time....   [tags: History, Philosophy]

Powerful Essays
1242 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Hegel and The Libertarians

- Hegel and The Libertarians ABSTRACT: This paper aims to show how the Hegelian philosophy can contribute to the conceptual discussions between the two strains of contemporary ethical-political philosophy. I argue that the Hegelian political theory is of central import to the discussion between communitarians and libertarians, both in the communitarian criticism of the libertarian — mainly in Michael Sandel's criticism of Rawls — and in the Rawlsian project of a society founded in justice as equality....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Essays]

Powerful Essays
2943 words (8.4 pages)

Essay on Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit

- Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit One of the most difficult philosophical works ever written is Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit. In the "Introduction" to this work, Hegel attempts to aid his readers by describing the project that he carries out. But like so many things written by Hegel, the "Introduction" itself is formidable and very difficult to understand. In this paper, I attempt to "make sense" of the "Introduction" and, thus, contribute to the understanding of the Phenomenology. To achieve this end, I take the great liberty of comparing philosophers with blind men and Reality with an elephant....   [tags: Philosophy Hegel Elephant Papers]

Free Essays
4185 words (12 pages)

The Contributions of Nicolo Machiavelli and John Locke to Political Thought

- The Contributions of Nicolo Machiavelli and John Locke to Political Thought In political thought, there have been many people that have progressed political theory. Nicolo Machiavelli and John Locke are two of those famous individuals. The research here will be focused on them. Each Machiavelli and John Locke support a different political theory. At first, the background and relevant contexts will be discussed. Each person has written something that has influenced modern political thought....   [tags: Political Science, Political Theory]

Powerful Essays
1755 words (5 pages)

The Prince As A Modern Polititcal Treatise Essay

- The Prince As A Modern Political Treatise Written almost 500 years ago by the so called first political scientist in the world, Niccolo Machiavelli’s “The Prince” brings forward a new definition to virtue. A definition which argues against the concept brought forward by the Catholic Church. Machiavelli did not impose any thoughts of his own rather he only wrote from his experience and whatever philosophy that lead to actions which essentially produced effective outcomes in the political scene of Italy and in other countries....   [tags: Political Scientist, Prince, Niccolo Machiavelli]

Powerful Essays
2192 words (6.3 pages)

Essay on The Absolute and the Dialectic in the Philosophy of Hegel

- Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel was born in August 27, 1770; Hegel had three siblings, his parents brought him into a family of Protestant Pietism. Hegel was very close to his sister, Christiane, she was mentally ill and Hegel was worried about her mental state so he made different forms of psychiatry to help her using dialectic. Hegel was a philosophy and theology student from1788–1793, as a student he made friends with other peers such as Friedrich Von Schelling and Friedrich Hegel; two famous German figures in the 19th century....   [tags: Philosophy]

Powerful Essays
916 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on GWF Hegel

- GWF Hegel Imagine studying the political and social developments of the 20th century without ever considering Communism or evaluating the idea of Fascism. Envision a Russia without the effects of Joseph Stain or a Germany untouched by the doctrine of Adolph Hitler. The above statements seem incredible because these systems created so much of the political and social turmoil throughout this century. Just as politics seems incomplete without the prevalence of these ideas, it is also incomplete without the philosophy of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
920 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on The Philosophies of Georg Hegel and Herbert Spencer

- The Philosophies of Georg Hegel and Herbert Spencer The Philosophy of Georg Wilhelm Hegel (1770-1801) Metaphysics Georg Wilhelm Hegel aspired to find a philosophy that would embody all human experiences with the integration of not only science, but also religion, history, art, politics and beyond. Hegel’s metaphysical theory of absolute idealism claimed that reality was the absolute truth of all logic, spirit, and rational ideas encompassing all human experience and knowledge. He believed that in the history of philosophy, many sought to compete with each other’s thoughts in order to find the one true and universal philosophy....   [tags: essays research papers]

Powerful Essays
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Hegel Legitimised the French Revolution but not the Revolutionaries Themselves

- Hegel Legitimised the French Revolution but not the Revolutionaries Themselves Hegel views on the role of the individual can be seen and used to justify the Revolution. Individual freedom can also be woven into these ideas and living in a community or society is how Hegel saw the individual fulfilling their life. Hegel agreed with the ideas of the classical Greeks in as much that he thought the individual should lead an ethical life. In this ideal each individual has obligations to the community in which they live....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)