The Analysis : The Cider House Rules Essay

The Analysis : The Cider House Rules Essay

Length: 1573 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

As is the case with most moral debates, too often a black and white approach is taken in order to choose a stance on the issue. Perhaps this is most true in the abortion debate as the majority of people seem to be polarized into one of two extreme opinion sets. However, the reality of life rarely deals in absolutes or black and white circumstances but rather in a varying shades of gray. Thus, a set of definitive and rigid viewpoints infrequently provides intelligible solutions when faced with actual situations and moral dilemmas. In consideration of the inherent limitations presented by the classic liberal and conservative viewpoints on abortion it is imperative that conventional arguments be challenged by the presentation of realistic circumstances. This exploration of allows individuals to apply an ethical decision making framework to the presented situation and question the traditional opposing stances.
The film the Cider House Rules provides an excellent theoretical case study to examine the moral, ethical, and actual implications which surround the decision to have an abortion. The film accomplishes this by presenting two young women contemplating undergoing an abortion procedure. While these two situations occur in the same geographical setting and within a short period of time the situations surrounding each woman and the motivation behind their decisions is extremely very different. Each abortion therefore allows an opportunity to view the different arguments for and against the availability of abortion. Furthermore, the two different spectrums of circumstances allows the characters in the film to confront their own personal beliefs and challenge convention by examining the actual human element as well as the vari...


... middle of paper ...


...ly respect the value of human life these aspects must be considered for both the mother and the child. Only when the biases of the liberal and conservative agendas are removed can a rational and ethical decision be obtained. By allowing thoroughly examining the spectrum of value by correctly assessing the biological, personal, and social investments present in both the woman’s life and the unborn child’s life it seems possible to grasp a new understanding of the abortion debate. Moreover, if both liberals and conservatives accurately employ Dworkin’s logic it seems inevitable that the two groups will come to see their common ground in their attempt to defend the sanctity of human life. This in turn could lead to a new and less polarizing abortion debate in which unbiased and rationale thought as opposed to emotional rhetoric is applied to protect life in earnest.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Cider House Rules By John Irving

- Section One: Introduction Imagine being told that you do not have the right to choose what you do with your own body. You are presented with a situation that you are not mentally, physically, or financially prepared for, but you are told that you are not allowed an opinion that could change the outcome. You are forced to deal with it, ruin your life for the next eighteen years because you made a mistake and you do not have the option of fixing it. During the 1980’s, those against abortion attempted to get a constitution amendment passed that would ban abortions nationally (Newsman)....   [tags: Abortion, Abortion law, The Cider House Rules]

Better Essays
1540 words (4.4 pages)

The Struggle for Acceptance in The Cider House Rules Essay

- The Struggle for Acceptance in The Cider House Rules      In The Cider House Rules, John Irving brings the orphan Homer Wells to vivid life in a rather unusual way.  Homer’s life and existence are part of a large symbolic link to the actual book itself.  Homer’s life as an orphan struggling for acceptance and to “Be of Use” is shadowed by The Cider House Rules struggle for acceptance in the mass literary market and its need to purvey its views on abortion.         After writing his first few books, Irving was left disappointed that although the literary critics embraced them, for the general masses his books fell on deaf ears.  (Hill 250) Unfortunately it is the general case tha...   [tags: Cider House Rules Essays]

Better Essays
1705 words (4.9 pages)

The Abortion Arguments of Cider House Rules Essay

- The Abortion Arguments of Cider House Rules I am writing this essay on a Saturday evening, not with any real contemplation, or even planning. I am writing this because I was just minutes ago watching the movie Cider House Rules. I won't go into the plot of the movie, but, to explain my motivation for writing this, I will simply describe one portion of the movie. The scene at issue in my mind right now is one where a fourteen-year-old girl comes to the orphanage which is the setting for part of the movie....   [tags: Movie Cider House Rules Film Papers]

Better Essays
1103 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about The Right to Choose in Cider House Rules

- The Cider House Rules takes place during World War II. The movie opens in a New England orphanage in the early 1940’s, where Dr. Larch takes a specific interest in a young boy named Homer Wells after is returned for the second time after his adoptive parents brought him back. His first adoptive parents thought he was to quiet and then his second foster family beat him. Larch realizes that a twice returned orphan had very little chance of being adopted again, Larch then begins to teach Wells the basics of the medical profession....   [tags: pregnant. abortion, orphanage]

Better Essays
820 words (2.3 pages)

The Theme of The Cider House Rules Essay

- During my senior year of high school, I often had dreams about leaving my parents house. Fantasizing about freedom and, the ability to come and go as I wished took the place of time designated for class work. I was tired of being told what to do, and I grew weary of the monotony of taking out the garbage and cleaning my room. Being told to come in the house by 10 pm while my friends stayed until 12 pm seemed unfair to me. The media bombarded my mind with the idea that being a football captain in senior year was supposed to be filled with keg parties, and orgies with cheerleaders....   [tags: Homer Wells, moral obligations ]

Better Essays
1056 words (3 pages)

Pitfalls Of Critical Thinking : The Cider House Rules Essay

- Pitfalls of Critical Thinking “The Cider House Rules” When I started watching The Cider House Rules I did not know what to expect. I came into this experience completely blind, as I did not watch the trailer or read any of the movie reviews beforehand. In retrospect, I am glad I did this because it prevented me from forming any biased opinions before I watched the movie. The Cider House Rules focuses on many controversial topics such as abortion and incest. It is a coming of age story about a boy named Homer and how he struggles with his own personal demons involving his adoptive father Dr....   [tags: Critical thinking, Reasoning, Thought, Abortion]

Better Essays
947 words (2.7 pages)

Cider House Rules Essay

- The Cider House Rules" is a movie based on John Irving's best selling book. It is a very wonderful, touching, and real 1943¡¦s life story. The story centered on an orphanage child named Homer and a sick doctor, Dr Larch who will have an emotional bond with Homer. I watched the movie before, and my first impression on this movie, I think it is a very good, and relax movie, where you can watch it with your family, although some of the scene may be offended for children. The Cider House Rules, begins in the 1920s in St....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)

Cider House Rules Essay

- The movie Cider House Rules involves many different characters that one can focus on, but the main character I want to focus on is Homer Wells, who is also the main character of the film. Now every character goes through many different situations and are faced with different obstacles that they must over come. Dr. Larch has to over come the ability to realize he is human, and how the board wants to replace him. Mr. Rose has to over come non-diligent workers, and conflicts with his daughter and keep a calm, flowing working environment....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1034 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Cider House Rules: A Rite of Passage, with Dickensian Sympathies

- It doesn't take a cryptographer to decipher the meanings in John Irving's sprawling picaresque allegories. But a reader who wants to savor them must be willing to suspend a psychoanalytic view of human nature descended from Freud through Oprah and surrender to an imagination that is more Dickensian than Freudian. Once you give up those expectations, a visit to the world according to Irving is a little like touring a parallel universe where fate is determined not so much by abusive parents as by wondrous tragicomic events beyond the realm of psychology....   [tags: Film]

Better Essays
791 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on John Irving’s The Cider House Rules

- John Irving’s The Cider House Rules Contemporary society advocates that without love, happiness is impossible. Webester’s Dictionary defines happiness as, “ a state of well being or contentment.” Three types of love which are necessary for contentment are; familial love, romantic love and friendship. In John Irving’s, The Cider House Rules, Melony’s bitterness prevents her from developing these forms of love vital for true happiness. Her hostility towards others prevents her from developing familial love....   [tags: essays papers]

Better Essays
1337 words (3.8 pages)