Essay about Analysis Of The Book ' The Odyssey '

Essay about Analysis Of The Book ' The Odyssey '

Length: 1059 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In all stories, a central conflict is paramount in creating an interesting narrative that keeps readers engaged throughout the totality of a tale. The different ways in which different writers can achieve this through literary devices while telling the same story speaks to the diversity of literature, and to the fickle nature of translation, as exemplified through The Odyssey. One great moment of contention is on Circe’s island. Shewring acknowledges Odysseus’s resistance to Circe’s magic, “…Never has any other man resisted this drug, once he has drunk it and let it pass his lips. But you have an inner will that is proof against sorcery. You must surely be that man of wide-ranging spirit, Odysseus himself; the Radiant One of the golden wand has told me of you;” (Shewring 121). Shewring presents Odysseus’s will as one that is proof against sorcery, something that allows Circe to identify him. Fitzgerald maintains this same stance of Odyseus’s resistance to sorcery, but with a slight difference, “Never a mortal man that drank this cup / but when it passed his lips he had succumbed. / Hale must your heart be and your tempered will. / Odysseus then you are, O great contender, / of whom the glittering god with golden wand / spoke to me ever,” (Fitzgerald 167). Fitzgerald takes a different approach and distinguishes Odysseus’s will as hale, or strong. This creates a clear distinction between the Odysseus of Shewring’s translation and of Fitzgerald’s translation. Soon after this, Circe offers her bed to Odysseus, and Odysseus promptly refuses. In Fitzgerald’s translation, this makes sense as he is a man of strong will and, for some reason despite his culture being accepting of a husband’s infidelity, refuses Circe’s and all other advance...


... middle of paper ...


...he shield as a stormcloud, and this imagery provides an insight into understanding the epic. All of Odysseus’s travels have been tumultuous; a storm of troubles brought his way. Under Fitzgerald’s translation, it can be viewed that Athena brought this upon him as a method of preparing him for the trials at home. Under Shewring’s translation, this cannot even be considered because that imagery of the shield as a stormcloud is entirely gone from the text. Through both translations, the central conflict maintains the same, as it should for translations from the same literature, but an understanding of the conflict through the lenses Fitzgerald and Shewring apply change reader’s perception, altering the overall flow of the story. This is particularly prevalent in the possibility that Athena is the one presenting these trials to Odysseus in preparation for his homecoming.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Analysis Of The Book ' The Odyssey '

- In all stories, a central conflict is paramount in creating an interesting narrative that keeps readers engaged throughout the totality of a tale. The different ways in which different writers can achieve this through literary devices while telling the same story speaks to the diversity of literature, and to the fickle nature of translation, as exemplified through The Odyssey. One great moment of contention is on Circe’s island. Shewring acknowledges Odysseus’s resistance to Circe’s magic, “…Never has any other man resisted this drug, once he has drunk it and let it pass his lips....   [tags: Odyssey, Athena, Odysseus, Poseidon]

Better Essays
1059 words (3 pages)

Analysis Of Homer 's Book ' Five Of The Odyssey ' Essay

- Odysseus was very persistent to his son Telemachus. Throughout his journey, he could have fallen into the deceit of a charm filled woman and had a life there with her but he didn’t for he remember his son. No matter the situation whenever Odysseus wanted to give up for he was always being discouraged in his journey, he persisted to continue to return to his son and wife. In book five of the Odyssey is says, “He found her at home. There was a large fire burning on the hearth, and one could smell from far the fragrant reek of burning cedar and sandalwood....   [tags: Odyssey, Odysseus, Penelope, Marriage]

Better Essays
1031 words (2.9 pages)

An Analysis of Three Subsystems in The Odyssey: Book 9 Essay

- In the giants cave is where the relationship between subsistence, trade and communication, and technology are most described. The analysis of these three subsystems from Colin Renfrew’s systems theory reveals how the diverse ways of the giant and man corresponded with one another when they were put to interact with each other in book nine of The Odyssey. Subsistence in the Cyclops cave When Odysseys and his men arrive to the land of the Cyclops and find the cave, they find objects that would be fit to fall under the category of subsistence....   [tags: cyclops, communication, hierarchy]

Better Essays
530 words (1.5 pages)

Left or Right? Essay

- According to J.K Rowling, “It is our choices that show who we truly are, far more than our abilities.” This conclusion postulates that it does not matter whether a person is fragile or robust, brilliant or dull, gifted or challenged, it is the choices that they make in life that crystallize who they are as people. Yet, can these words be ripped from their simple format and be plastered to the pillars of life themselves. For example, does the child protégé always have the will power to use their knowledge and select the right path....   [tags: Of Mice And Men, The Odyssey, Book Analysis]

Better Essays
1160 words (3.3 pages)

Analysis Of Homer 's ' Odyssey ' Essay

- The goddess Athena intrigues and fascinates readers, compelling an in depth look at the role which she plays within Homers, Odyssey. Throughout the epic poem Athena is depicted as a strong leading voice who aids in helping the development of maturity within Odysseus’s son Telemachus. From persuading Telemachus to hold an assembly, debate what to do about his mother’s suitors, and consider the matter of his father, Odysseus, Athena begins a slow accession into a guiding or mentoring role of Telemachus....   [tags: Odyssey, Homer, Odysseus, Athena]

Better Essays
1399 words (4 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The Book ' Telemakhos 's Journey '

- The story of Telémakhos’s journey, in many ways a smaller parallel to his father’s lengthier and more taxing journey, begins nearing the end of Odysseus’s. Thorough examination of any one episode in Telémakhos’s journey could provide insight to this relationship and the importance of each of the journeys detailed by the text. One such episode, found in Book IV, details Telémakhos’s visit to the home of Meneláos and Helen. As a story of the (really, really) long journey to return home, The Odyssey capitalizes the importance of hospitality....   [tags: Odyssey, Athena, Odysseus, Helen]

Better Essays
1239 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Analysis Of The Book ' Cold Mountain '

- Blood, pouring from the wound, effuses out into the world never to be drawn back into its maker’s corpse. This body will never retrieve that lost blood; one does not consume his own gore. That blood may be lost, but the scar endures. Charles Frazier, throughout his novel Cold Mountain, employs many allusions to the classic Greek epic The Odyssey, with specific intent of adjoining the two pieces of literature with particular regard for an allegory with scars. Frazier’s text establishes a connection to the epic through a flourish of references both explicit and opaque, however one of the more tender allusions within the two works beholds this regard to the scars worn by both male protagonists...   [tags: Odyssey, Odysseus, Wound healing, Epic poetry]

Better Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)

2001: A Space Odyssey Compare and Contrast Essay

- ... I also think it would have been more entertaining as an audience member if Stanley Kubrick could have made the man-apes possessed. The initial destination of Discovery is another major difference between the book and the movie of 2001: A Space Odyssey. In the book, Bowman and Poole both think that they are going to Saturn, but find out later the real purpose of the mission. The three men that are hibernating and Hal all know that they are going to Jupiter to find out about the monolith, which eventually leads to their demise....   [tags: film versus book analysis]

Better Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' II ' Essay

- Book VI: While Odysseus sleeps in a forest, Athene visits the house of King Alcinous in Scheria, the city of the Phaeacians. She appears to the king’s daughter, Nausicaa, in a dream, disguised as the girl’s best friend. She tells Nausicaa to wash her clothes in the washing cisterns in preparation for her wedding. Nausicaa is being courted by many men and will likely not be unmarried for very long. When Nausicaa wakes up, she obtains a wagon and mules from her father. She and her maidservants drive down to the washing cisterns, which are some distance from town....   [tags: Odyssey, Trojan War, Greek mythology, Cyclops]

Better Essays
1905 words (5.4 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' Odysseus ' Essay

- Joshua.Sikarevich 1-20-14 Book 1: The narrator calls upon the Muse to avail him tell the story of Odysseus. We pick up ten years after the fall of Troy in the Trojan War (the subject of The Iliad). In endeavoring to return home, Odysseus and his shipmates had numerous adventures, but now Odysseus has been isolated on the island of Ogygia for the last eight years, captive of the resplendent goddess Kalypso. We are told that Poseidon, god of the sea, will make Odysseus ' journey home to Ithaka even more arduous (he is exasperated that Odysseus has visually impaired his son, the Cyclops Polyphemus), and trouble awaits the surmounting hero back in Ithaka, additionall...   [tags: Odyssey, Trojan War, Odysseus, Greek mythology]

Better Essays
1359 words (3.9 pages)