Analysis Of The Book ' Bring Back Flogging ' By Jeff Jacoby Essay

Analysis Of The Book ' Bring Back Flogging ' By Jeff Jacoby Essay

Length: 1362 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Critical Analysis
In “Bring Back Flogging”, Jeff Jacoby argues why the current criminal justice system in America is not effective or successful. As a solution, he suggests that America should bring back the old fashioned form of punishment once used by the puritans, flogging, as an alternative to imprisonment (198). This article originally appeared in the op-ed section of the Boston Globe newspaper. Therefore, the primary audience of this article is people who want to read arguments about controversial topics and have probably read some of his other articles. His argument that the current criminal justice system is not working is extremely convincing. He appeals to pathos and uses statistics to prove that thesis and to persuade the audience. However, he gives no reason why corporal punishment is the best alternative to imprisonment and never offers any other options. Additionally, he does not make an effort to explain why corporal punishment would be more effective or successful than imprisonment. Thus, in “Bring Back Flogging,” Jeff Jacoby is successful of informing the audience about the dangers and problems with imprisonment, but only offers one solution with very little support as to why it would work.
Jeff Jacoby makes the purpose of his article clear in the title “Bring Back Flogging.” From the title, it is clear that he is going to argue that “flogging” or corporal punishment should be used as a method for punishing criminals once more. Jacoby can be easily perceived as an upset and alarmed individual who blames the rise of criminal activity in the United States on the failure of the criminal justice system. He cares about people and believes that the safety of individuals is decreasing because criminals are not punishe...


... middle of paper ...


...m an opinion on whether or not flogging should be brought back as a method of punishing criminals.
In conclusion, Jeff Jacoby does an excellent job explaining how ineffective, costly and dangerous prisons are, but fails to come up with a good solution to this problem. He suggests flogging, but gives no evidence of why flogging would be more effective. It is unconvincing to the reader that flogging is the best alternatives because Jacoby does not consider any other alternatives to prison such as community service, loss of privileges, or in extreme cases, exile. He also fails to define flogging or give proof that physical punishment would lower the high crime rate in the United States. Thus, while his article raises interesting and compelling concerns about our prison system, Jeff Jacoby fails to persuade his audience that flogging is the best alternative.












Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis Of The Book ' Bring Back Flogging ' By Columnist Jeff Jacoby Essay

- Every civilized society makes laws that protect its values, and the society expects every single citizen to obey these laws. Whenever a citizen of a certain society breaks one of these laws, the rulers of the society dish out punishments they dim fit for the kind of crime committed. With this kind of justice system in place, criminals are either locked up in prison cells, whipped, or exiled from the society. In the essay, “Bring Back Flogging”, columnist Jeff Jacoby argues that flogging is much more superior to imprisonment and should be brought back as a method of punishing crime offenders like the Puritans did in the past....   [tags: Prison, Criminal justice, Punishment]

Strong Essays
1092 words (3.1 pages)

In Defense of Flogging, by Peter Moskos Essay

- What is the best way to punish people. For centuries, humans have sought out for methods to reprimand wrongdoers. We, as a species, have allowed punishment to evolve along with us. From corporal punishment, or flogging as many may call it, to incarceration, humans have searched for the most effective technique to punish people. As time elapsed, imprisonment has become our staple for all crimes and transgressions. With this in mind, many writers have contended that we revisit corporal punishment....   [tags: Aleternative to Incarceration]

Strong Essays
1284 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Jeff Jacoby's Bring Back Flogging

- Jeff Jacoby's Bring Back Flogging      This essay by Jeff Jacoby illustrates an authors use of ironic sarcasm otherwise known as satire to defend and illustrate his platform on his position. Jacoby uses in this essay verbal irony (persuasion in the form of ridicule). In the irony of this sort there is a contrast between what is said and what is meant.      Jacoby’s claim in simple is he believes that flogging should be brought back to replace the more standard conventional method of the imprisonment of violent and non-violent offenders....   [tags: Jacoby Bring Back Flogging Essays]

Strong Essays
1317 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on The Article ' Bring Back Flogging '

- In the article “Bring Back Flogging” Jeff Jacoby writes that prison inmates are given a disservice more than people who used to be flogged in the 1600s. Flogging was a punishment that used for a wide variety of crimes and was usually done publicly with the victim being whipped an appointed number of times. Jacoby writes that flogging is a more educational experience than going to jail because it is an experience that the criminal will never forget. He goes on to say that another reason why prisons are obsolete is because they are so expensive and often times the prisoners do not come out reformed....   [tags: Prison, Crime, Critical thinking, Logic]

Strong Essays
900 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Do Not Bring Back Flogging

- Flogging…What is it. What purpose does it serve. For those of us who have never heard of flogging, flogging refers to “beating with a whip or strap or rope as a form of punishment” (“Flogging” 1). Throughout the 1600s, flogging was utilized by “Boston’s Puritan Forefathers” (Jacoby 1) as a method of corporal punishment for various crimes. Progressing forward, Jeff Jacoby, columnist for The Boston Globe, provides readers with his view of “Boston’s Forefathers’” system of punishment in his essay, “Bring Back Flogging.” Within the contents of his work, Jacoby describes how flogging was utilized as punishment in its day....   [tags: Article Review, Jeff Jacoby]

Strong Essays
1040 words (3 pages)

Essay on `` Bring Back Flogging `` By Jeff Jacoby

- Imprisonment VS flogging within the world, comparing the amount of criminals from today to 100 years ago, it is assumed that the numbers have gone up drastically. In “Bring Back Flogging” by Jeff Jacoby, he starts his essay off with giving out the history of flogging, beginning with what the criminal did and then explaining the type of punishment that the criminal would receive. While reading “Bring Back Flogging” it is shown how one would get beaten for blasphemy while one would be put into prison today....   [tags: Prison, Criminal justice, Punishment]

Strong Essays
999 words (2.9 pages)

Bring Back Flogging Essay

- In “Bring Back Flogging” Jeff Jacoby, a columnist for the Boston Globe, presents the use of corporal punishment as an alternative to the current system of imprisonment. Published in February of 1997, the article states that flogging would be a more effective means of punishment than jail. He insists it would be less expensive and serve as a deterrent to first time offenders. Jacoby’s thoughts on prison reform are legitimate, but his reasoning behind the use of corporal punishment is flawed. He fails to provide reasonable support for his argument which leaves the reader guessing as to the seriousness of his claim....   [tags: Criminal Justice]

Strong Essays
1071 words (3.1 pages)

Book Report: Return of the Pharaoh Essay

- ‘Return of the Pharaoh’ is the English version of the prison memoir of Zainab al-Ghazali. The book aims to expose to the world the cruelties and savagery she had to suffer at the hands of the Nasir regime. Zainab al-Ghazali was one of the leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood and the founder of the Muslim Ladies Group. While the Brotherhood held a pan-Islamic view and worked towards incorporating Islam as a way of life rather than a religion, the Muslim Ladies Group trained women for the same purpose and also participated in welfare and relief activities....   [tags: memoirs, literature, Egypt, feminism, Islam]

Strong Essays
1145 words (3.3 pages)

Jeff Jacoby’s Bring Flogging Back Essay

- In Jeff Jacoby’s essay Bring Flogging Back, he discusses whether flogging is the more humane punishment compared to prison. Jacoby uses clear and compelling evidence to describe why prisons are a terrible punishment, but he lacks detail and information on why flogging is better. In the essay he explains how crime has gotten out of hand over the past few decades, which has lead to the government building more prisons to lock up more criminals. His effort to prove that current criminal punishment is not perfect or even effective is nicely done, but he struggled with discussing ways that flogging could lower the crime rates and provide a safer environment for America....   [tags: Argument Analysis]

Strong Essays
1009 words (2.9 pages)

Bring Back Flogging Essay

- Bring Back Flogging" During seventeenth century flogging was a popular punishment for convicted people among Boston's Puritans. Fortunately, those times have passed and brutal and inhuman flogging was replaced by imprisonment. Columnist for the Boston Globe, Jeff Jacoby in his essay "Bring back flogging" asserts that flogging is superior to imprisonment and advocates flogging as an excellent means of punishment. He is convinced that flogging of offenders after their first conviction can prevent them from going into professional criminal career and has more educational value than imprisonment....   [tags: Personal Essays]

Strong Essays
476 words (1.4 pages)