Analysis Of The Article ' Dear Privileged At Princeton ' Essay

Analysis Of The Article ' Dear Privileged At Princeton ' Essay

Length: 711 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In May 2014, published an article that would soon become the source of no small amount of social contention (1). In the article, “Dear Privileged-at-Princeton: You. Are. Privileged. And Meritocracy Is a Myth,” author Briana Payton lashes out at classmate Tal Fortgang for an article he wrote a month prior (1). Payton, a freshman studying sociology at Princeton University and the political antithesis of Fortgang, takes issue with her classmates’ definition of the word “privilege” (1). She argues that, because Fortgang is white, society inherently affords him “privilege” (Payton 1). Payton’s main flaw is her tone — her condescending, demeaning, and arrogant rhetoric distracts from her content and diminishes her credibility. Conversely, her ad hominem remarks do little harm to Tal Fortgang and the merit of his arguments.
Throughout her article, Payton sounds like a mix between an angry parent reprimanding an unruly child and a moody teenager admonishing a friend via social media. When Payton says, “Is that clear? You. Are. Privileged. It is OK to admit that,” her use of rhetorical questions, punctuation, and capitalization make her intentions abundantly clear (3). Payton’s statement exudes anger and resentment towards Fortgang. In the question, it is clear that Payton does not want an answer but rather, is attempting to scold Fortgang. Moreover, her use of punctuation speaks volumes; periods after each word are the equivalent of Payton raising her voice, out of frustration, to drive home a point. Even her emphasis of the word, “OK” is a sarcastic way of suggesting that Fortgang knows, and is afraid to admit, that he is privileged (3).
Payton’s unprofessional use of rhetoric is not exclusive to a single example — a plethora of...

... middle of paper ...

...ional use of rhetoric undermines the merits of her arguments. The anger that spills from every rhetorical question, sarcastic comment, and personal attack serve only to discredit Payton’s own contentions. While some may argue that Payton’s tone is justified given her personal connection with privilege or the lack thereof, nothing is an excuse for personal attacks and unprofessional language. Regardless of whether or not readers were persuaded by Payton’s arguments, her tone is enough to, at the very least, make readers question her intentions. As a result, if she would reform her language to be more polite, her readers would receive the content of her arguments better. Conversely, those who identify with Payton racially, politically, or socially may be able to identify with her emotions towards Fortgang. If this were the case, Payton’s arguments would be far stronger.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis of Bernard MacLaverty's My Dear Palestrina Essay example

- Analysis of Bernard MacLaverty's My Dear Palestrina My Dear Palestrina’ is a cleverly written short story by Bernard MacLaverty. It is about this young boy called Danny who discovers his musical talent and goes to this piano teacher called Miss Swartz. Their friendship develops and seem to be a formidable partnership until Danny is torn away from his beloved music lessons because of Miss Schwartz private life. Fitted into the story are some important themes that still continue to exist in today’s society....   [tags: My Dear Palestrina Literature Music Essays]

Better Essays
1232 words (3.5 pages)

The Privileged And The Not Essay

- Christian Rosado Tracy Peterchak SOC 102 19 July 2014 The Privileged and the Not The concept of race has no biological merit and is a concept that was invented to oppress the minority group. Historically, this can be seen when studying early European settlement into America when the settlers came in contact with the natives of the land. Based on their darker skin color, and their difference in culture, they were quickly singled out as different and subjugated to torture because they were “savages” and not “civilized”....   [tags: Racism, Race, White people, Race]

Better Essays
1475 words (4.2 pages)

An Analysis of Anne Bradstreet: In Memory of My Dear Grandchild Elizabeth Bradstreet

- An Analysis of Anne Bradstreet: In Memory of My Dear Grandchild Elizabeth Bradstreet   The Puritan woman's life was one entrenched in self-examination; bringing about the assembly of a spiritual armor in order to duel feminine sexuality to the death. In the elegy "In Memory of My Dear Grandchild Elizabeth Bradstreet, Who Deceased August, 1665, Being a Year and Half Old," Bradstreet does not to fight with the expected vengeance against the manifestation of her "evil," her child, as one would expect within the given spiritual context....   [tags: Memory of My Dear Grandchild Elizabeth Bradstreet]

Better Essays
612 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The Movie ' Dear White People '

- When I first viewed the trailer for Dear White People I was more than thrilled. I imagined the film was going to be it was going to be my generations’ version of the Spike Lee Joint School Daze based off of the perverse I viewed, but as I began to watch the movie I realized I was mistaken. Unlike School Daze, a film tailored to a black audience, while the latter is tailored for a broader audience. Dear White People beautifully depicts the different types of black people, how foolish stereotypes are, the struggles college students’ faces in finding themselves, and most importantly, that black empowerment is not the same as black supremacy....   [tags: African American, White people, Racism]

Better Essays
1122 words (3.2 pages)

Analysis Of The Movie ' Dear White People ' Essay

- Dear White People is a film that depicts the white framework of society that pertains to a prestigious college that is predominantly middle-upper-class, white, students. The film follows the perspective of several African American students as they try to develop themselves towards self-actualization despite the oppressive stereotypes that label and sets parameters of socially acceptable behavior. The film provides a great example of ethnic attrition in the character of Lionel Higgins, as well as using the conflict perspective in connection with racism, and provides examples of both individual discrimination, and institutional discrimination....   [tags: Sociology, Discrimination, Racism, White people]

Better Essays
1051 words (3 pages)

My Encounter With Princeton Police Essay

- This analysis will be examining the article “my encounter with Princeton police” by Imani Perry a female black professor at ivy –League University in New Jersey. Perry was pulled over by Princeton police while she was driving 67mph on street with 45mph limit. At which time, the police found warrant for arrest for two unpaid ticket. For these reason, Perry got handcuffed and taken into custody. The conclusion of this argument is clearly police are using inappropriate and disproportionate treatment against African Americans....   [tags: Race, African American, Rhetoric, Police]

Better Essays
706 words (2 pages)

Dear America When Will This Cruel War Be Over by Barry Denenberg Essay

- Dear America When Will This Cruel War Be Over by Barry Denenberg Characters Emma Simpson- She is the main character in this story . The whole concept of the book is about her diary . In her diary she talks about the stress and anxiety the war has brought upon her family .Emma to me is a static character. She still to me doesn't mature as much as she says she has. She complains a lot .If she really matured she would have handled things like her Aunt Caroline. Aunt Caroline-She is one important characters in the book ....   [tags: Denenberg Dear America]

Free Essays
1457 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Love in Anne Bradstreet's "To my Dear and Loving Husband"

- “LOVE”, a simple word with four letters, sounds very simple but has a vast and deep meaning. From the very ancient time till today there have always been a topic called “Love” in every work of literature. Even in the ancient Biblical times, we see “Love” carried a deeper meaning. Several chapters and verses from the Holy Book are the evidence that “Love” existed during that period too, be it God’s love to all His people, or a man’s love to his wife, or vice-versa. The book of Genesis not only talks about the history and origin of the world, but also talks about several things on “Love”....   [tags: Anne Bradstreet, my Dear and Loving Husband, marri]

Better Essays
1396 words (4 pages)

Fitzgerald at Princeton Essay

- Fitzgerald at Princeton While he was a student at the Newman School, called St. Regis in This Side of Paradise, F. Scott Fitzgerald became enamored with Princeton. He attended the first Harvard-Princeton game since 1896 on November 4, 1911 and Princeton won 8-6 on a blocked kick that was returned for a touchdown (Tate, 199). His aunt offered to pay for his education at Georgetown, but Fitzgerald wanted to go to Princeton. When his grandmother died in 1913, she left money that made Princeton available....   [tags: Biography Biographies Essays]

Better Essays
754 words (2.2 pages)

Analysis of Anne Bradstreet's To My Dear and Loving Husband Essay

- Analysis of Anne Bradstreet's To My Dear and Loving Husband Anne Bradstreet's poem, To My Dear and Loving Husband, shows her profound love and undying affection for her husband. For a Puritan woman who is supposed to be reserved, Bradstreet makes it her obligation to enlighten her husband of her devotion. She conveys this message through her figurative language and declarative tone by using imagery, repetition, and paradoxes. Over and over again she expresses her adoration for him with imagery....   [tags: Puritan Poetry Poem bradstreet ]

Better Essays
486 words (1.4 pages)