Socrates states that the Laws exist for its own purpose. The citizen is bound to the laws like a child is bound to a parent. So, to go against the Laws is like striking a parent. The Laws point out the role they have played in shaping Socrates, and how important their relationship is. It was through the Laws that Socrates’ parents were married and were able to give birth to him. Just as you will not break the Laws because you came from this city. The Laws go even further to suggest that one’s ties to one’s family, and so it is even more important to respect the judgements of the laws. Just as one should be willing to suffer and die for one’s country in battle rather than flee to save oneself. One should also be willing to suffer and die according to the Laws rather than to destroy them by trying to save oneself. You are a part of Athens. If you break the Laws, you do not only harm other people, but also yourself. Socrates are arguing that to avoid being executed, he must persuade the Laws that they punished him unjustly rather than simply fleeing, which would disrespect and destroy the Laws.
Two problems arise, the first one is Socrates portrays the Laws as living beings that have nurtured and raised him, who will suffer if he disregards them. The truth is the Law...
... middle of paper ...
... life, but has no life independent of the body. Thus, the soul is the master of the body. Having wrapped up his myth, Socrates remarks that the time has come for him to drink the poison. He states that after his is death, his soul will leave his body and will live on eternally. The body that left behind is not Socrates, because Socrates’ soul will no longer inhabit it.
We thus see, that the two main problems with Socrates’ argument are the state is held by the Laws, and the citizen of Athens have agreement with the Laws are not valid. If the state is not held together by the Laws, the people will not have an agreement with the Laws. The laws are good and are created for good purposes, but must be obeyed no matter what, and it is up to the people to carry that out. Also, the soul would be free without the body. So, then people can concentrate clearly on the problem.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Stratagem of Socrates An Analysis of What Makes Socrates an Intriguing Person What is the definite definition of justice. Cephalus would have argued it is paying what is owed. Polemarchus would have said it’s giving good to the good people and giving evil to your enemies. Thrasymachus would have said it’s nothing else than the interest of the stronger. Although Socrates would have said that justice is what gives you the advantage to be just and what gives you the disadvantage to be unjust.... [tags: Plato, Socrates, Philosophy, Democracy]
1026 words (2.9 pages)
- In accordance to the Gorgias, as Socrates was conversing with Callicles—a possibly fictional character who attempts to refute Socrates’ claims against rhetoric—he makes the claim that the two have suffered due to a common element: loving. Socrates asserts that he himself is in love with Alcibiades, the son of Cleinias and with philosophy and that Callicles is in love with the Athenian people and the son of Pyrilampes. As Socrates develops his argument, he illustrates that love triumphs all other forces and that his love for philosophy and Alcibiades are fundamentally distinct.... [tags: Plato, Philosophy, Socrates, Love]
1282 words (3.7 pages)
- In this paper I will give an in depth analysis of Socrates argument in Plato’s Republic and in Plato’s Phaedo. First I will begin with the analysis of the Republic, a discussion between Socrates and Glaucon on morality of the human being. The argument first defines morality within a good community and proceeds with the application of this definition in the human person. Then I shall analysis Phaedo, Socrates argument of immortality of the soul. Using his argument of death, reincarnation, change and invisibility, I shall explain Socrates rejoice of death.... [tags: Plato, Soul, Reincarnation, Philosophy]
2176 words (6.2 pages)
- In Plato’s Theaetetus, Socrates examines the first definition of knowledge that theaetetus gives that knowledge is perception. Socrates gives us many example that both supports and refutes that knowledge is perception. The basic claim from Protagoras is that truth is based on the perception of every man. This means that things are to any person as they seem to that person. Socrates explains to us Protagoras’s view with the cold wind example. He say that through Protagoras theory, the wind is cold to the person that feels cold, and the wind is warm to the person that feels warm.... [tags: Knowledge, Truth, Philosophy]
1436 words (4.1 pages)
- Given what Socrates states in the Phaedo through his arguments about the afterlife and the definition of death, I argue, that he would he say, that we are alive when we are no longer in our body. This paper will argue that an individual is not only alive after death, but that we are most alive when we are not in the body, through an outline of premises picked from the book Phaedo, in The Last Days of Socrates by Plato. Socrates defines death as the separation of body and the soul through his dialogue with Simmias, “Is it simply the release of the soul from the body.... [tags: Life, Soul, Death, Plato]
1130 words (3.2 pages)
- ... With little more questioning he was being initiated and the Clouds were shown to him, and Socrates was telling him of the their properties and disproving the existence of the god Zeus (Clouds 256-409). This event shows Socrates quick to act to help a man see and learn the truth about the world. It seems that Socrates did want men to be learned; he was happy to explain the clouds to his new student, although frustrated with his ignorance at times. When Strepsiades’ lack of education was made evident by his misunderstanding of the simple topics that Socrates tried to teach him originally Socrates did not just give up on trying to educate him, but instead found something that he did know we... [tags: soul, philosphy, arrogant]
1074 words (3.1 pages)
- ... “Does one man do them [horses] harm and all the world good. Is not the exact opposite the truth?” (786). He goes on to say that the world would be a much better place if all but one person were virtuous. He, then, asks if it is better to live among the good or the bad. Meletus agrees that it is better to live among the good (786). Socrates asks if his corruption of the children is intentional or unintentional and of course Meletus says that it is intentional (787). Socrates dismisses this accusation by indicating that either he unintentionally corrupts the children or he does not corrupt them at all (787).... [tags: Socrates, literary analysis, classics]
1518 words (4.3 pages)
- Comparison of Sophists and Socrates’ Views Sophism and Socrates ideologies continue to influence the world today in many facets. Though there was repulsion in the application of thoughts of Sophists and Socrates, manipulation and unfairness seems to be the major born of contention among their views. Question of whether Socrates was a Sophist too have erupted in different platforms. Irrespective of all the analysis and speculations of Sophists’ and Socrates’ philosophies, it remains true that their philosophies not only continue to influence the world, but also span across many topics and portray many elements of both similarities and differences in opinions.... [tags: Philosophy, Plato, Socrates, Rhetoric]
956 words (2.7 pages)
- Plato was the author of the Apology of Socrates, which was one of the four major works of ancient Greek literature. Though the title was the Apology of Socrates, the text referred to the defense speeches of Socrates against the Athenian council. At the end, Socrates was found to be guilty and was sentenced to death. However, the Athenian council was not acting justly because Socrates did nothing wrong as he had successfully developed a reasonable logic against the charges. I will address this notion through the analysis of the arguments and the logic that Socrates used to conduct his defense.... [tags: Socrates, Plato, Question, Socratic method]
1614 words (4.6 pages)
- “If you are willing, let’s first find out what sort of thing justice is in cities, and afterward look for it in the individual, to see if the larger entity is similar in form to the smaller one” (Republic 368e8-369a2). This idea that there will be more justice in a city as compared to a single person sets Socrates off on an extended tangent trying to create the just city, Kalliⲑpolis. Theoretically, he was making a utopian society. By utopia, I mean that the city possesses perfect elements, or more simply put, there would be no better city.... [tags: Dystopia, Society, Analysis]
1286 words (3.7 pages)