Essay about Analysis of Singer´s The Life You Can Save

Essay about Analysis of Singer´s The Life You Can Save

Length: 1016 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In this paper I will begin by explaining Singer’s utilitarian argument in “The Life You Can Save” regarding the obligation of affluent nations to give in order to alleviate global poverty. Secondly, I will analyze one objection to Singer’s argument that opposes charity. Thirdly, after examining the objection to Singer’s argument, I will present Singer’s noteworthy reply. Finally, after offering both an objection to Singer’s argument, as well as Singer’s rebuttal, I will offer my own view on whether or not Singer’s refutation is convincing.
In discussing Singer’s argument, it is important to explain his definition of global poverty. Singer clearly states that extreme poverty is “not only a condition of unsatisfied material needs” but also a “degrading state of powerlessness” (6). Singer’s argument asserts that citizens of affluent nations are behaving erroneously because they fail to contribute to the end of poverty they know to exist in impoverished countries. He postulates that the common person has the ability to point fingers at others, while he or she nevertheless ought to do as much as they can. Singer's argument is a direct criticism of a capitalistic system where extreme wealth exists next to extreme poverty. For Singer, the ethical call to assist in eradicating poverty rests in a person’s ability to help another. In his full argument, Singer considers three premises. The first is common knowledge that suffering and death is inherently bad. Singer’s argument for the Golden Rule is encapsulated in this premise: “doing unto others, as you would have them do unto you” (16). No sane person would like to suffer; therefore, it is only moral to help those who are suffering. Singer contends in the next premise that individuals ha...

... middle of paper ...

...impoverished conditions could be saved. It is often said that people are generally motivated by self-interest. Singer believes that the existence of altruism in society is higher than most people assume. Therefore, if people give priority to this altruism, there existences will be additionally satisfying and just. It brings me to the question of whether material items are nearly as important as saving a child from dying? Singer’s interpretation of morality and the steps to alleviate global poverty reflect a truly utilitarian perspective. In deciding between what is right and wrong he often considers what people ought to do. He recognizes deep down people understand the honest truth is always the one they’d rather not do out of selfish desires. Singer’s novel is a paradigm of moral philosophy as it is well contended, engaging, and an important topic in society today.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Life You Save May Be Your Own

- What if you were given a chance to start over and do things differently. To make up for your mistakes, right your wrongs. This idea is featured as a theme in Flannery O’Connor’s short story “The Life You Save May Be Your Own”, published in the 1953 Spring issue of The Kenyon Review (Kenyon College). The story is about a homeless man by the name of “Shiftlet” who approaches an isolated, run-down farm where “Mrs.Crater” and her mentally retarded daughter “Lucynell” lives. Crater offers Shiftlet a home to stay in if he’d do some fix-up jobs around the place, mainly on the car he’s been eyeing....   [tags: Flannery O'Connor, Short Story, Literary Analysis]

Better Essays
1134 words (3.2 pages)

The Life You Save May Be Your Own: Antithesis To A Fairy Tale Essay

- Nostalgic finales just seem too good to be real with the quaint happy endings that typically conclude fairy tales; not with Flannery O'Connor's writings, which depict sarcasm with disquieting twists and mordant characters. One of O'Connor's most successful works, "The Life You Save May Be Your Own" epitomizes her writing style that is characteristically seen by many as grotesque and sardonic. This short story represents the antithesis of a fairy tale, ingeniously warping its vital elements—damsel in distress (Lucynell, the daughter), the mother (Mrs....   [tags: Flannery O'Connor Author Book Analysis]

Free Essays
993 words (2.8 pages)

Save A Life By Edgar Allen Poe Essay

- To Save a Life (An analysis of the characters and the title of The Life you Save May Be Your Own) What does it mean to save a life. How many ways can a life be saved. Do things such as wearing a seatbelt count as saving a life. There are so many ways that lives can be saved. Physically, doctors work every day to preserve the health and safeness of the general public. Often times, accidents take away lives and it is often wondered what could have happened to save that life. One of the most prominent places of death and despair are in stories....   [tags: Short story, Life, Flannery O'Connor]

Better Essays
1465 words (4.2 pages)

Analysis Of The Movie ' Save Me ! ' Essay

- ... The China depicted in New Woman features a progressive veneer, replete with bustling urban centers and a glamorous elite, but a Confucian social structure underlies this cosmetic modernity. In New Woman, the most pervasive aspect of this structure is its rigid gender hierarchy. Confucianism, as a religious philosophy and cultural tradition, relies on a system of familial and communal obligations; this system mandates the subservience of the female gender, requiring women to obey, in turn, their fathers, husbands, and sons....   [tags: Sociology, Suicide, New Women, Han Chinese]

Better Essays
1048 words (3 pages)

Essay on Analysis of Song How to Save A Life by The Fray

- The Fray's hit song, 'How To Save a Life,' tells a story of a mentor, also a friend, who is trying to 'save a life' of a troubled youth. The story starts off with the teenager and this friend sitting down to have a talk about what is wrong in the teen?s life. The second line reads, 'he walks, you say sit down it's just a talk,' this showing anger and fear of what might be brought up in conversation, so he tries to run away from the problem. Although neither individual wants to have the talk, they both respect each other enough to be polite, 'He smiles politely back at you/ You stare politely right on through.' Then the narrator mentions a metaphorical 'window to your right/As he goes left a...   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
838 words (2.4 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' The True Law Of Life ' Essay

- When Old Koskoosh, the hunter, and the correspondent give up in their respective life and death situations, they resign themselves to death. In each story, they have all been fighting against nature to stay alive. The fight with fire and oars, but they get tired of battling. The underlying question the men have to ask themselves is: Is this fight worth it. For how long can I sustain the pain in hope of furthering the length of my life. The true “law of life” is coming to terms with the fact that nature does not care about the individual nor does death in nature need to have any meaning....   [tags: Death, Life, Debut albums, Afterlife]

Better Essays
1030 words (2.9 pages)

The Secret Life Of Walter Mitty Essay

- “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty” as written by James Thurber is an interesting short story. Walter Mitty, the protagonist of the story, is in a constant battle with his wife, the antagonist of the story. Mr. Mitty is, simply put, a daydreamer with a creative mind. His wife does not appreciate this aspect of Mr. Mitty and is constantly nagging him and bringing him back to reality. Mr. Mitty’s character is flat, as he is never portrayed as a deep and unknown character with some type of third dimension to his personaility....   [tags: The Secret Life of Walter Mitty, Fiction]

Better Essays
1098 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Analysis Of Its A Wonderful Life

- This was an extraordinary movie that showed the homely small-town moral values through glossy studio production. I really enjoyed this movie. It has very quickly become one of my favorite movies of all times. The characters were very good. I thought this movie to be beautifully told and acted, with Reed, Barrymore, and other ensemble members perfectly cast. The actors were very convincing. George Bailey was an ordinary guy. An example of this was went he was at the train station waiting for his brother, Harry....   [tags: Its A Wonderful Life]

Better Essays
615 words (1.8 pages)

Analysis Of Mitch Albom 's ' The Five People You Meet ' Heaven ' Essay

- In The Five People you Meet in Heaven, authored by Mitch Albom, there are many themes on life lessons. One that stuck out in particular was that love can heal all wounds. Eddie, an old war veteran and head of maintenance at Ruby’s Pier, dies while trying to save a young girl from being crushed by a falling roller coaster cart. Eddie goes to heaven, and with the help of five people who affected him on Earth, realizes that his life was not as worthless as he had thought. As the Blue Man states, “You may not have known the reason at the time, and that is what heaven is for....   [tags: Marriage, Love, Life, The First Man]

Better Essays
982 words (2.8 pages)

Interracial Dating Explored in Save the Last Dance Essay

- Interracial Dating Explored in Save the Last Dance The movie, Save the Last Dance, goes along with all of our discussions and conversations about the visual difference between the black and white cultures and the stereotyping that Hollywood does of the two cultures. The movie shows the difference in the two cultures, according to have your typical white middle-class suburban girl (Sarah) and your typical low-class black boy (Derrick). Save the Last Dance is a love story about the pros and cons that comes along with interracial dating....   [tags: Films Movies Analysis Relationships Essays]

Better Essays
942 words (2.7 pages)