In this paper I discuss several assigned articles with regard to the assumptions, focus, time and space contexts, stated purpose, and comparison between certain articles. Except for one article, all articles in this weekly reading are assumed to use post-structuralist paradigm. In their article, Lobao & Meyer (2001) encourage the readers to use combination of macro, meso, and micro approach in understanding agricultural transformation rather than only macro approach. For example, they urge the Human Ecology Theory (PEP), which is micro theory about individual’s adaptation to the dynamic of environment like population density, culture and technologies, and bio-physical environment. They criticize the PEP paradigm as heavily oriented in structural approach, neglecting the dynamic of socio-psychological factors of individual and social practices. For Lobao & Meyer, micro level of the household dynamic is crucial to understand the survival mechanism of the smallholder farmers to seek “strategic business behavior” (p. 112). Moreover, gender division, particularly with regard to the struggle of women in on-farm and off-farm activities is important. The Lobao and Meyer’s article also highlights the regional context of agri-related policies, such as agricultural loans which tend to be biased to certain ethnic groups, a fact that may be overlooked by the PEP. For comparison, Bernstein’s article is also in similar vein, in which he looks at the case of Green Revolution in India as not “resource neutral” (p. 61), by giving more access to the richer farmers to any program innovation packages (like credits, supply of inputs, and information). Lobao & Meyer’s article’s on famers’ action in politic to defend their interests ...
... middle of paper ...
...le. Similarly, but with different case, Pechllaner and Otero (2008) describe the recent case resistance of the Mexican toward the introduction of biotech foods by international companies via trade liberalization.
To sum up, while most of the articles have similar post-structural paradigm --which assume that local and regional factors are crucial factors in understanding agricultural transition— the focus of study, time-space contexts, and purpose of study, are different. The articles provide excellent perspectives and various examples in different time and across geographical boundaries regarding the needs of assessing the complexity of agricultural stakeholders, particularly the struggle of farmers as individual, household, or community (including the food consumers), to adapt with the change of external forces, which influence their livelihoods and interests.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Discussions about advertisements and its effects on mass media as well and the audience who consume mass media have long been ingrained into the premises of this course. In the same light, concepts such as discourse, bias, propaganda and intertextuality have been used to measure the differences between commercial broadcasting and private broadcasting with the concept of advertising playing a crucial role in a comparison between the two. However, for the purposes of this paper, such concepts will only be used to analyze advertising in the mass media.... [tags: Advertising, Broadcasting, Mass media, Propaganda]
2087 words (6 pages)
- ... Ideologically, the concept of mass society has been used by conservative thinkers to express dismay about the leveling tendencies of industrial society and the declining influence of family and community (Swingewood, 1977). It has also been used by radical thinkers to bemoan the manner in which large bureaucratic institutions (especially in the guise of mass culture) can pacify populations and reinforce the status quo (Marcuse, 1964). C. Wright Mills 1956 recognized these dangers in his analysis of the power elite.... [tags: Sociology, Mass media, Propaganda, Media studies]
777 words (2.2 pages)
- ... The media effects debate however is extremely deterministic as it suggests that we passively absorb information from the media that leads us to behave in certain ways which we have no control over (Neuman, 1992). This therefore suggests that another explanation of the media may be more palatable. The uses and gratification model contradicts the media effects model and suggests that the media has no effects. It focuses not on the content of the media but instead on the audience themselves (Zhao, 2008).... [tags: censoring debate, perceptions, violence]
2265 words (6.5 pages)
- Take a second to think about the word propaganda. What comes to mind. Do events such as World War II or The Cold War. According to The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, propaganda is a noun which means “the systematic propagation of a doctrine or cause or of information reflecting the views and interests of those advocating such a doctrine or cause.” In other words, propaganda, in this particular definition, is viewed as the deliberate transmission of an idea or document that a group of people believe in.... [tags: Propaganda]
667 words (1.9 pages)
- According to William Jenkins (1989) public policy is a set of interrelated decisions taken by a political actor or a group of actors concerning the selection of goals and the means of achieving them within a specified situation where those situations showed in public policy be within the power of those actors to achieve. In this case, public policy involves making policies that are involved in enhancing health care reforms in the Canadian situation. Policies are often as a result of a multiple decisions but multiple decisions taken by multiple decision makers through government organs.... [tags: Health Care ]
1263 words (3.6 pages)
- Propaganda in the media Today, propaganda is used in many different ways to promote or publicize a point of view in the mass communication in forms of television advertisement, newspapers and magazines. The role of propaganda is to manipulate an audience with misleading and biased information to exaggerate the truth, control their emotions and manipulate their opinions so that the point proven is being seen through one picture perfect lens. There are five types of propaganda used in advertising.... [tags: Propaganda, Advertising]
1406 words (4 pages)
- In the movie The Music Man con man Harold Hill, adeptly tricks the townspeople of River City, a small town in Iowa, into believing that they are need of a boy’s band. In the song “You Got Trouble,” he uses three types of propaganda to achieve this end: faulty cause and effect, exigency, and name-calling. Faulty cause and effect is a propaganda technique where one thing is presented, without proof, as if it caused another. Hill uses a pool table that was just put into one of the shops as the cause of a fall in morality among the youth of River City.... [tags: Propoganda]
573 words (1.6 pages)
- Propaganda in today’s world is at its all time peak due to the inability of humans to comprehend information on their own. One may define propaganda as a form of communication that is aimed towards influencing the attitude of a community toward some cause or position. Realistically, however, this form of communication is nothing more than information, ideas, or rumors spread deliberately to help or harm an institution. In Tom Downey’s “The Insurgent’s Tale,” anti-war propaganda is used by telling the story of an actual Jihadist.... [tags: War Propaganda Literary Analysis]
1859 words (5.3 pages)
- Propaganda has been used throughout history. It is used to get people to accept ideas and beliefs by using specific devices to reach their goal. There are different types of propaganda that can be deceitful, honest, or repeatedly promoted. Some individual think it is only used for evil because it involve half-truths and distort the facts, but it can spread good ideas. By using logical and emotional reason, the propagandist can connect with their audience to get them to believe in whatever they want.... [tags: Adolf Hitler, Nazi Germany, Germany, Nazism]
1183 words (3.4 pages)
- Many see propaganda as undermining reason. Propaganda works with the emotions to get a mass to do a certain action. Since propaganda tries to remain hidden, are there any in the world who see it and try to uncover such propaganda. Satirical television and radio shows as well as newspapers challenge the conceptions of which we take for granted and of which are propaganda. How does satire function in relation to propaganda. First, one must define propaganda and since many have done so already, I shall use the Sheryl Ross model.... [tags: Propaganda]
1612 words (4.6 pages)