Essay about Analysis Of Posner 's ' Twilight Of Human Rights '

Essay about Analysis Of Posner 's ' Twilight Of Human Rights '

Length: 1087 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Posner’s “Twilight of Human Rights” has a straightforward argument; human rights international law, has become a “regime” since World War II. However, is not a functional regime, since it has not been able to accomplish the main goals proposed in the major treaties. The aim of this brief is to provide a review of this central argument. For doing so, this paper will first tackle the theoretical and methodological strengths and weaknesses. The purpose of the above mentioned is to set a framework for doing an in-depth analysis of his theoretical and empirical arguments, which is hard not to agree with. Nevertheless, more significant and accurate arguments can be set by taking a different methodological and theoretical approach.
The “Twilight of human rights” structure is designed for making the reader familiar with how human rights were created and how they evolved within different socio-historical contexts. The historical chapter sets the basis of Posner’s argument: human rights, in different cultural traditions, emerged as a moral constraint, with the purpose of setting a regulatory standard for social interaction. Despite Posner explains the legal aspects of Human Rights emergence, it is important to recall that this clarification is succinct. Furthermore, he is intentionally avoiding to peruse the scope of these historical declarations. For instance, the Declaration of the Rights of Man was taken out of context. Despite the idea of “natural rights” was revolutionary, since they were a major step within a political struggle, it is noteworthy to remember, that during the French Revolution concept of “man” exclusively referred to European males, members of economic elites. This epistemological omission, goes on through the entire ch...

... middle of paper ...

...ples he provides, he is suggesting that States’ ideology would define the dynamics during conflict. The fact that he justifies some humanitarian interventions and do not condemns all the authors of the atrocities, seems to bolster the Orwellian premise. Moreover, he admits the West would turn a blind eye in some cases, since “the West really had no interest in what was going on in those countries” (133), which seem to be less equal.
Posner conclusions state his disenfranchisement on how international human rights law operates by making evident that the “human rights regime” has failed to its original purpose, as stated in UNDHR preamble. Since the aim of the book is not to start a quest for structural changes on human rights, he just encourages to take into consideration all what he left aside in the book: alternative perspectives, more humane and less ethnocentric.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Analysis Of The Book ' Twilight '

- Stephenie Meyer released one of the best books I have ever read in 2005 called “Twilight.” Although this book was viewed as a typical love story, it set an example of a perfect couple to me as a reader. Throughout the book, the two main characters were Isabella Swan (Bella) and Edward Cullen. As the book began it sets a feeling of displeasure or disgust that Bella seemed to have thought Edward had for her, but as the story went on his feelings were different than she thought. He was definitely obsessed with Bella....   [tags: Stephenie Meyer, Twilight, Bella Swan, Twilight]

Better Essays
813 words (2.3 pages)

The Twilight Saga: Redefining the Vampire Essay

- When the word “vampire” comes to mind, people think of the traditional pale-faced, malicious bloodsuckers, sporting a cape and killing people when they’re sleeping. Wrong. Nowadays, the image of a vampire is a handsome, polite, and loving person who protects humans. The new cultural phenomenon Twilight is building a new degrading image for vampires that slaps the face of all previous authors, directors, writers, etc. who contributed to giving the monster its unique image in the past. Simply searching through articles, databases, and other resources, vampires are depicted as malicious and monstrous creatures....   [tags: Twilight Saga]

Better Essays
853 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Judge Posner's Challenge to the Philosophy of Law

- Judge Posner's Challenge to the Philosophy of Law ABSTRACT: This paper presents a conceptual analysis of Richard Posner's empirical theory of judicial behavior. His theory opposes the conventional view which holds that judges are insulated from external pressures so their judicial decisions will be based upon a disinterested understanding of the law. Since economics holds that all people — including judges — attempt to maximize their utilities, Posner thinks that the conventional view is an embarrassment which presumes judges are not rational....   [tags: Posner Law Essays]

Better Essays
2953 words (8.4 pages)

Essay on Twilight - A Thrilling and Enthralling Read

- Twilight is an absorbing, rapid moving read written by Stephanie Meyer. It was her first book and an international best seller. It follows Isabella (Bella) swan, a seventeen year old girl as she moves to the small rainy town of forks to live with her dad Charlie. The first day of her new school she meets the Cullen’s, a mysterious inhumanely beautiful family, “they were faces you never expected to see except perhaps on the airbrushed pages of a fashion magazine. Or painted by an old master as the face of an angel.” Edward Cullen has chalky alabaster skin, golden enticing eyes and supernatural gifts....   [tags: Twilight Series, Book Review]

Better Essays
511 words (1.5 pages)

Falling in Love in Twilight Essays

- Everyone dreams of falling in love one day. They dream of that perfect soul mate who was put on this earth to love no one but them. To share a love with such intensity that the mere absence from each other can stop the air from penetrating their lungs. A man who will not only die for her but die with her as well. To share a love completely absent of doubt. A love that one only reads about. That special, once in a lifetime love that others have not only told her was non-existent, but no other has ever experienced....   [tags: Twilight, romance, relationships, ]

Free Essays
415 words (1.2 pages)

Compare And Contrast Twilight Movie And Movie Essay

- In the famous novel and movie series, Twilight by Stephenie Meyer, an average teenage girl, Bella Swan, is forced to move from Arizona (where she lived with her mother) to Washington to start an almost new life with her father. She attends a small-town high school with mostly average people, besides one family, the Cullens. As Bella and Edward Cullen get closer, she uncovers a deep secret about him and his family. Their relationship faces many hard challenges and conflicts as the story develops....   [tags: Stephenie Meyer, Bella Swan, Twilight, Twilight]

Better Essays
780 words (2.2 pages)

Book Review of Stephenie Meyer's "Twilight" Essay

- The first book in the Twilight saga as said by the author in the Amazon interview is about finding true love and is conveniently entitled Twilight. Stephenie Meyer was partial to calling it Forks, the name of the little town Bella goes to live. Her name was chosen because Stephenie Meyer would have named her daughter that if she had one. It fit so nicely with Edward. Bella's full name is Isabella Swan. Isabella goes to live in Forks, a little town that really does exist on the map on the Olympic Peninsula in Washington State....   [tags: Twilight, Stephenie Meyer,]

Better Essays
568 words (1.6 pages)

Essay about The Philosophy of Twilight

- The recent vampire craze has encouraged me to discover exactly what makes it so fascinating to audiences today. I will be concentrating on the Twilight films primarily because of its enormous female fan base. The devoted teenage girls that watch the movies are exposed to negative gender stereotypes and abusive relationships, which could have a harmful effect unless it is properly addressed. Many of the fans that idolize Edward say that he is the “perfect” boyfriend, however if you examine his personality and attitude in the context of real life, it would make him a very creepy obsessive romantic partner....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Better Essays
962 words (2.7 pages)

Wizards and Vampires: Exploring the Phenomenal Popularity of the Harry Potter and Twilight Book Series

- “There was a time when no one had heard of Harry Potter,” a title of an article published in the 2007 edition of the Chicago tribune. It attempted to describe the Harry Potter phenomenon. However, if written now it would be “There was a time when no one had heard of Harry Potter and Edward Cullen” the Twilight series has sparked a phenomenon equal to the Harry Potter series. To know exactly why these fictional books have become a vast phenomenon is impossible but gaining thoughts and slight understanding of why helps....   [tags: Harry Potter, Twilight]

Better Essays
1542 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about The Twilight Is Child 's Play Than An Avid Twilight Series Consumer

- Coming from an avid Twilight series consumer, I can justly say Twilight is child’s play compared to True Blood. True Blood is a creation of book from author, Charlaine Harris. In True Blood, Vampires and other super natural creatures not only roam around town, but live and interact as humans in southern Louisiana. Vampires are fighting in a society for their rights which cohere are absurd to think of vampires on the level of rights as minorities. Sookie is the main character and a mixture between a fairy and a human....   [tags: Sexual intercourse, Human sexual behavior]

Better Essays
1846 words (5.3 pages)