Essay on Analysis of Julia Alvarez's Book, In the Time of the Butterflies

Essay on Analysis of Julia Alvarez's Book, In the Time of the Butterflies

Length: 1196 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the book "In the Time of the Butterflies" four sisters fight to take their given right of freedom in the Dominican Republic. In order to achieve this freedom the Mirabel sisters had to give up their childhoods, their safety, and even their very own lives. The author of the book, Julia Alvarez, took the readers through the sisters journies of fighting against Trujillo, and the many horrible times they endoured while under his political control. Some sisters had to be leaders while other sisters had to be followers. The one sister that is mostly believed to be the strong one or the leader of the sisters is Minerva Mirabel. Minerva is a very strong-willed indiviual, but she is still not as stroing as she thinks she is. Her physical flaws, her need for reliance, and her loss of her own determination proves that she is not the strontest sister in the story, or the hero of the story.

Minerva is the type of person who makes sure that everyone looks at her as being a strong person, however, this desired image is only a betrayal of herself. Many heros or courageous leaders in stories never have chararcterics flaws or in other words health problems. In the book though, Minerva has many health problems that she has to deal with through out her life. She is always in need of rest, always coughing and getting sick, and is very weak at certain parts of the story. These down falls in the book show that Minerva is not a hero at all, and she can be broken down to an average every day human being like you and me. "I was hurt that he had'nt even said goodbye...Mama, of course, noticed the tightening in my face. My bad headaches and asthma attacks always worried her. "You need rest," she prescribed one afternoon and sent me to bed in Papa's ro...


... middle of paper ...


... and how she is not the hero in the story.

Strong characters and real heroes are people who never fail when they are in need of rescuing themselves or others. A real hero is one who has courage, one who is healthy, one who never fails, one who never gives up, one who keeps fighting for what they believe, and someone who only knows how to succeed. Minerva is a character who is weak and she is not really as courageous as everyone believes she is. These flaws are important to the book and in real life because these are flaws that people don't seem to realize through out the story or in real life. Maybe readers want to believe she is the leader of the sisters because she performed more courageous acts then the rest of her family, but I still believe she is not at all. Minerva is not a leader or a hero in this story, but then again who is the real hero in this story ?

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Real Heroine in the book, In the Time of Butterflies by Julia Alvarez

- ... I'll let you toss for the privilege. You win, you get your wish. I win, I get mine" (115) Minerva not only stands up to Trujillo by telling him she wants to be a lawyer, but she takes a huge risk just to get what she wants and deserves. Minerva meets a young man named Lio who her parents disapprove of and he is also running from the government, why would Minerva take the risk of being with Lio when she has to go against the government and the people she loves. Minerva has started to act very sneaky around the house and she is starting to fall in love with Lio....   [tags: revolution, love Minerva]

Strong Essays
637 words (1.8 pages)

In the Time of the Butterflies by Julia Alvarez Essay

- A beautiful, captivating, and revolutionary story, In the Time of the Butterflies, was written by Julia Alvarez and is a true account about struggle, courage, and love between four sisters, their families, and the people they encountered in their lives. This captivating story is so easy to relate to, as it’s written by a woman, about women, for women. What comes across clearly throughout the story is the Mirabal sisters’ passion for the revolution and how it overwhelmed their lives and the lives of anyone that was involved, or came into contact, with them....   [tags: In the Time of the Butterflies]

Strong Essays
998 words (2.9 pages)

In The Time of The Butterflies by Julia Alvarez Essay

- Defiance in the name of freedom against the political clutch of a powerful dictator can bring about the consequence of inhumane punishment and loss, however, by preserving and telling the story of a great loss, one honors the memory of sacrifice and can find closure, making the cause worth the fight. The legitimacy of this statement is evidently valid when paired up behind the sacrifice of the three Mirabal sisters in the book by Julia Alvarez: In The Time of The Butterflies. Is any life worth living trapped in fear of harm or even death....   [tags: Freedom, Literary Analysis]

Strong Essays
1155 words (3.3 pages)

The Time Of The Butterflies By Julia Alvarez Essay

- Can you imagine a world where women do not have a say and only men are in charge. Well the book “In the Time of the Butterflies” by Julia Alvarez teaches us that women are capable of more than just cleaning and cooking. Also, that women can be braver than many men. The story of four sisters, Minerva, Patria, Maria Teresa, and Dede shows that in a world where men are considered more dominant, women can become great leaders and free an entire country. The theme of women and feminism, including the significance of gender roles in the 1940’s to the 1960’s compared to today’s society has not changed enough where women are treated equally to men because the role of a woman in the 1940’s to 1960’s...   [tags: Gender role, Woman, Marriage, Gender]

Strong Essays
1706 words (4.9 pages)

In The Time of Butterflies, by Julia Alvarez Essay

- The Dominican Republic in the twentieth century can be summarized as brutal. The novel In The Time of Butterflies, written by Julia Alvarez was set during the time period 1938 to 1994. During part of that time dictator Rafael Trujillo ruled the island. Although this book is considered historical fiction, it tells the story of four Mirabal sisters: Dede, Patria, Minerva, and Maria Teresa. They called themselves “Las Mariposas”. The four Mirabal sisters exist in real life. In the book as well as in real life, the sisters are seen as a symbol of courage and strength to the people in the Dominican Republic....   [tags: In The Time of Butterflies Essays]

Strong Essays
3040 words (8.7 pages)

Caterpillars to Butterflies: A Metamorphosis Essay

- From the secretive government agent who foils the plans of dastardly supervillains to the Prince Charming who saves Disney princesses, courage invokes many spectacular images in people’s minds. Yet courage appears in subtler forms as well – the resident nerd awkwardly asking a crush to Prom, the belittled girl holding her head up high amidst gossip, or the concerned citizen stopping to fix a broken-down vehicle on the roadside. As a past resident of the Dominican Republic during Trujillo’s regime, Julia Alvarez understands these differing types of courage, and this knowledge permeates through the pages of her book, In the Time of the Butterflies....   [tags: Julia Alvarez, Time of the Butterflies]

Strong Essays
903 words (2.6 pages)

Minerva, The Hero of In the Time of the Butterflies by Julia Alvarez Essay

- ... She knew that she could get into a lot of trouble but she didn't care. Minerva stated "She didn't mean any harm" (Alvarez 22). Minerva knew that Sinita would have killed El Jefe if she got the chance but she lied to protect her friend. Minerva said "My hands free, I saved the day, according to IN THE TIME OF BUTTERFLIES. !1 what Sinita said later." (Alvarez 22). Minerva started a chant that grew bigger and bigger ¡viva Trujillo. She is also a hero in many more way then just standing up for Sinita because she always does the right thing....   [tags: right, slap, saved]

Strong Essays
556 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on The Brave Sister in In the Time of the Butterflies by Julia Alvarez

- ... Minerva knew what was important to her and what she was fighting for. She believed in love and the revolution. Minerva stated, "I make a mental note that once I'm back, I'm going to make sure these girls are enrolled in school."(Alvarez 69) Minerva knew that her education and women's rights were important to her. She wanted everyone to have the same opportunities, in that way she was a hero. Minerva and Mama's conversation in the book showed Minerva's beliefs, "Mama sighs when I tell her that we have to come back tomorrow "Ay, m'ijita" she says....   [tags: heroine, hero, minerva]

Free Essays
580 words (1.7 pages)

Who Do You Consider a Hero in In the Time of Butterflies by Julia Alvarez

- ... What's more important, romance or revolution. But a little voice kept saying, both, both, I want both. Back and forth my mind went, wearing a yes by night and unraveling it by day to no", Minerva stated Pg 58. In this quote you see that Minerva is conflicted about her feelings, in other words, passionate."Still, when left, I was hurt that he hadn't even said goodbye", Minerva stated pg 58. As you can see in this quote Minerva indeed has a softer side under her tough shell. "What did I want ....   [tags: perspective, passionate, wonderlust]

Free Essays
519 words (1.5 pages)

Essay on Julia Alvarez's In the Time of the Butterflies

- In the Time of the Butterflies Humans have always prized peace, however it always finds itself in a war. War historically has always been all about men, Women have learned to matters into their hands and be strong enough to stand up for themselves too. Without war, how else can people take reprisals against injustices. Is armed revolution necessary. Is it more imperative to be correct than to be happy. Is it our obligation to defy evil and atrocities therein. The three sisters oppose Trujillo’s regime and have various severe consequences....   [tags: historic and character analysis]

Strong Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)