Analysis Of Howard Mumford Jones 's Critique Of The Declaration Of Independence

Analysis Of Howard Mumford Jones 's Critique Of The Declaration Of Independence

Length: 1520 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Purpose and Contradiction: A Reexamination of Howard Mumford Jones’s Critique of The Declaration of Independence


The Declaration of Independence2 can be broken down into five distinct sections according to Stephen Lucas’s, “The Stylistic Artistry of the Declaration of Independence.”3 These sections are the introduction, preamble, indictment section, “Denunciation of the British People”, and the conclusion3. According to Howard Mumford Jones, who is a well-known scholar and author in American History, the document can be invalidated by its lack of evidence and outrageous claims. Jones believes the Declaration of Independence is, “firm in structure and laconic in expression.”1 (Jones 3) In further explanation of the Declaration of Independence, Jones accuses the indictment section of lacking sufficient evidence, and that the idea of ‘inalienable rights’ is an outlandish idea because life and liberty are limited by law.2
Considering Jones’s strongly worded critique of The Declaration of Independence, some may find it odd that Jones himself calls the document, “one of the two most powerful public papers ever issued in this country…" (Jones 3) as he seems to be in strong opposition to this short but wonderfully structured document.2 By stating this, Jones begins to regard the power of the Declaration of Independence without fully acknowledging the legitimacy of the document. Jones views the document as a more persuasive document rather than an insightful, scholarly article, which does not necessarily disregard its legitimacy. However, Jones’s assertion that this document is not legitimate due to its so called lack of evidence and excessive persuasiveness leads the reader to believe that a persuasive document is not able to...


... middle of paper ...


...e indictment section was referencing with this being one of 26 examples.
The Declaration of Independence was a radical document for its time. It began a quest for the ‘inalienable rights’ that many still do not have in 2015 and while Jones critiques the document based on its lack of evidence and overcompensation of how many rights can truly be inalienable, the purpose of this document is overlooked in Jones’ critique. The purpose of this document was to spark a social and political revolution, leading the colonies out of oppression and into a brighter future where people can overcome. History shows that since The Declaration of Independence has been published, we have created great change and opened the doors for so many other countries, people, and minority populations with the ideas and even some of the same language from this document.






















Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Miller's Critique of American Society in "Death of a Salesman" Essay

- In Death of a Salesman Miller offers a critique of American society. What is this critique and how is it conveyed to the audience. In Death of a Salesman Miller explores and exposes modern American society in a brutal and scathing manner. His analysis and critique is conveyed clearly to the audience concluding that society is based on a corrupt and immoral capitalist dream. Miller implies this through the Loman family and their struggle to survive and compete. Techniques Miller employs to illustrate this are symbolism, characters and structure....   [tags: Death of a Salesman, Aurthur Miller, USA,]

Better Essays
1876 words (5.4 pages)

Argument Analysis - Declaration of Independence Essays

- Argument Analysis - Declaration of Independence In May of 1776 a resolution was passed at the Virginia Convention in Williamsburg that asked the thirteen American colonies to declare the United Colonies free and independent from the British crown. At the second continental congress the resolution passed and on June 11, 1776 a five-man committee led by Thomas Jefferson was established to write the Declaration of Independence. On July 4, 1776 the members of the second continental congress signed into existence one of the most influential documents in history....   [tags: Argument Analysis Declaration of Independence]

Better Essays
765 words (2.2 pages)

Rhetorical Analysis Of Declaration Of Independence Essay

- Rhetorical Analysis: The Declaration of Independence. Our Declaration of Independence, was penned most notably by Thomas Jefferson in response to the atrocities committed by the British Crown against the citizens of the American Colonies. At the time of the drafting of The Declaration, Jefferson was widely known to be a successful practitioner of Law as a lawyer, and an eloquent writer. It is due to this, that although Jefferson was a member of a five-man committee charged with drafting the Declaration of Independence, Jefferson was tapped to be the main author....   [tags: United States Declaration of Independence]

Better Essays
795 words (2.3 pages)

Analysis of Howard Zinn's Argument in his Article Dying for the Government

- Analysis of Howard Zinn's Argument in his Article "Dying for the Government" In June of 2003, Howard Zinn’s “Dying for the Government” was published in “The Progressive” newspaper. He discusses the government’s claim to military victory in Iraq, and he believes that many innocent people have died for an unjust cause in that war. His claim is that soldiers died for their government, not their country. An important part of his argument is his discussion of democracy, which he says is what our country is supposed to be based on....   [tags: Howard Zinn Dying For Government Essays]

Better Essays
1338 words (3.8 pages)

Analysis of The Declaration of Independence Essay

- What is the Declaration of Independence. The declaration of independence states that all individuals have inalienable rights, requiring life, liberty, and property, a document by which the thirteen colonies proclaimed their independence from Great Britain. If these rights are not protected, people have the right to abolish the government and institute a new one that is willing to secure those rights and their happiness. The declaration was written by Jefferson when he had the vision that America should be liberal....   [tags: the declaration, thomas jefferson, independence]

Better Essays
1241 words (3.5 pages)

Qualitative Analysis Critique Essay

- Qualitative Research Critique There are many differences between quantitative and qualitative research. Such things like: quantitative research provides only variables that can predict specific results but it does not tell us very much about how the variables affect an individual’s life course. Qualitative research adversely provides an enriched understanding of characteristics, qualities, attributes, and environmental factors affecting life events. Qualitative analysis can give understanding to the meaning of a specific characteristic, entity, or phenomenon within a context, instead of only measuring how much is present....   [tags: Self Development]

Better Essays
1350 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Science Of Desire Article Summary and Critique

- Summary The article The Science of Desire presents ethnography and its proponents play an important role in modern business world. Author Ante began with an example, the satellite-radio war, to show how ethnography worked in business. In satellite-radio war, Sirius Satellite Ratio made a team of social scientists, designers, and ethnographers. Through studying customers’ habit of listening to music, watching TV and reading magazines, the team concluded several facts that can defeat competitors....   [tags: Article Analysis Critique]

Free Essays
1247 words (3.6 pages)

An Analysis of the Declaration of Independence Essay

- An Analysis of the Declaration of Independence By understanding the framework of time that the Declaration of Independence was written in, we can see its impact upon the peoples of early America and how they dealt with this famous writing. This paper will explain the basic ideas contained in the Declaration of Independence, the impact of the Declaration upon the American War of Independence, and the reasons the Declaration was considered a "radical document". These themes will be discussed and analyzed to demonstrate the premise of the Declaration of Independence, as well as to explain why and how it worked within the time it was written in....   [tags: American History]

Free Essays
746 words (2.1 pages)

Concert Critique of Mozart and The Height of Classicism Essay

- Concert Critique of Mozart and The Height of Classicism      On Sunday, December 07, 2003, I attended the Mozart and The Height of Classicism concert that was held in the Lincoln Theater of the New World Symphony orchestral academy. Conducted by Nicholas McGegan featuring pianist Robert Levin. There were two pieces of music during this concert, one of the movements was performed by the pianist alone as a solo, Mr. Robert Levin. The program’s title was Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Chaconne from Idomeneo....   [tags: Analysis Critique Music Musical Essays ]

Better Essays
1298 words (3.7 pages)

Critique of Hume's Analysis of Causality Essay example

- Critique of Hume's Analysis of Causality Hume's analyses of human apprehension and of causality were the most penetrating up to his time and continue to have great influence. Contemporary Spanish philosopher Xavier Zubiri (1893-1983) has examined both and identified three underlying errors: (1) the failure to recognize that there are three stages of human intellection, and especially that the first, primordial apprehension, has quite unique characteristics; (2) the attempt to place an excessive burden on the content of impressions while ignoring what Zubiri terms their 'formality of reality'; and (3) the failure to recognize that functionality, not causality, is the basis for most of our kn...   [tags: Philosophy Papers]

Better Essays
3300 words (9.4 pages)