Analysis Of Holton 's Unruly American Essay

Analysis Of Holton 's Unruly American Essay

Length: 1292 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

My interpretation of the purpose of Holton’s Unruly American’s in general is that he wanted to convey a more accurate understanding of the development of the United States constitution, as appose to other perspectives that focus mainly on the framers. The constitution wasn’t just developed by the framers alone; it was heavily influenced by the many average American citizens during this time. Influences such as public demonstrations of outrage due to taxation as well as the influence of debt generated by farmers that couldn’t financially maintain themselves due to the country’s poor infrastructure. Holton also informed his readers about the importance of the creation of the Bill of Rights. All of the following events helped shape the constitution in one way or another. The major significance of this is to inform the reader about how this document, that our country still follows to this day, was shaped by events that happened in the past in order to prevent them in the future.

To understand each group of individuals from the farmers, framers, to the common individuals that displayed their grievances in public demonstrations such as rebellions against the government. To examine their lives and put into perspective why they carried out the actions they did. Putting these pieces together and understanding the development of our country on a macroscopic scale is the true significance and purpose portrayed by this book.

2. Relation to course:
The constitution is the bedrock in which our country is based off of today. When it comes to learning and understanding the origins of our country the constitution is a highly important piece. This book goes into great depth explaining how the constitution was forged which makes its relevance to ...


... middle of paper ...


...ys 2006." Professor Holton has also contributed to co-writing a comparative analysis of three centuries of Atlantic slave revolts.

5. Thoughts:
My initial impression from reading the first couple of sections was somewhat harsh. Perhaps this is due to my lack of reading experience, but none the less I found that Holton was very wordy in his descriptions. This made it a bit strenuous on me to keep reading seeing as I was not very drawn to the subject in the first place. Getting past my personal difficulties I found that this is a great secondary source that offers a very good perspective and accurate depiction of the shaping of our nation’s constitution. I understand that Holton had to be wordy with his in order to properly make his point while being historically accurate. In all I would recommend keeping this book due to its excellent perspective on the constitution.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Unruly Americans and the Origins of the Constitution by Woody Holton Essay

- After American colonialists had succeeded in over throwing British rule, the thirteen states were troubled by a complicated dilemma, an economic crisis with some calling for tax relief while others demanded stringent fiscal enforcement. Some believed that the revolution had not gone far enough, while others believed it had gone too far. The Framers who created the American Constitution took on the task of appeasing these two seemingly incongruous views. Woody Holton, in Unruly Americans and the Origins of the Constitution, attempts to reveal how the Framers acted in favour of those who believed the Revolution had gone too far, while trying to appease the majority – American farmers – were...   [tags: American History]

Better Essays
1427 words (4.1 pages)

Analysis Of Woody Holton 's Black Americans Essay

- There are many contradictions pertaining to slavery, which lasted for approximately 245 years. In Woody Holton’s “Black Americans in the Revolutionary Era”, Holton points out the multiple instances where one would find discrepancies that lie in the interests of slaveowners, noble figures, and slaves that lived throughout the United States. Holton exemplifies this hostility in forms of documents that further specify and support his claim. The first of many documents to address these contradictions is Document 3, focusing on James Otis....   [tags: American Civil War, African American, Black people]

Better Essays
1667 words (4.8 pages)

Essay The Unruly Wom Gender And The Genres Of Laughter

- Throughout the history of cinema, men have been the focal point of attention while the woman was always used as nothing but eye candy. Melissa McCarthy is living proof that women are no longer taking a back seat to men in the entertainment industry. Throughout her career, McCarthy has adopted the persona of an unruly woman. Kathleen Rowe, author of The Unruly Woman: Gender and the Genres of Laughter, described the traits of an unruly woman as, “often a voluptuous, noisy, joke-making rebel”. Because McCarthy has received critical acclaim for her work, you can say that she is an unruly woman who is changing the face of comedy....   [tags: Woman, Gender, Amy Poehler, Female]

Better Essays
1030 words (2.9 pages)

Review Of Woody Holton 's Secondary Source Essay

- ... History, 88) during this particular time. The reasoning behind this was in hope the federal convention would reimagine the democracy the country knows. Holton holds strong in his argument and reasoning when referring to James Madison, who was (and is) highly respected. Holton explains early in the Constitutional Convention, Madison states “the evils… which prevail within the States individually as well as those which affect them collectively” (Hollitz, Holton, Founding Fathers, 88). These powerful words “contributed more to that uneasiness, which produced the Convention, and prepared the public mind for general reform” (Hollitz, Holton, Found Fathers, 88)....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Better Essays
725 words (2.1 pages)

The Revolutionary Generation In Woody Holton's Forced Founders Essay

- In Woody Holton's Forced Founders, that most revered segment of the revolutionary generation, the elitist gentry class of Virginia, comes across very much as a group of self-serving reactionaries, rather then the idealized revolutionaries of the great patriotic myth of popular history. He sets about disassembling a central portion of the myth created by earlier generations of Consensus historians, by asserting that rather then gallantly leading the charge for independence, Virginia's elitist gentry resorted to independence as their last and only means of saving their elite ruling status, their economic futures, and even their very lives many feared....   [tags: independence, boycott, slavery]

Better Essays
855 words (2.4 pages)

An Analysis of “American Pie” Essay

- American Pie” is an impressionistic ballad by Don Mclean which features unique and intriguing lyrics. It has imaginative changes in tempo, vocal delivery and instrumentation, and imparts a wide range of emotions ranging from pure joy, to melancholy and despair. The song takes the listener on an autobiographical journey through the turbulent 1960’s with references to the events that shaped the era. Don Mclean was enshrined in the Songwriters’ Hall of Fame in 2004 for his work on “American Pie” (Don McLean: Songwriters Hall of Fame Inauguration)....   [tags: Music Analysis ]

Better Essays
897 words (2.6 pages)

Andrew Jackson's Unruly Rise to the Presidency Essay

- Andrew Jackson's Unruly Rise to the Presidency In what many have called the dirtiest presidential election ever, Andrew Jackson reigned supreme over John Quincy Adams in the election of 1828. For the first time in a political campaign, the main focus was to slander the reputation of the opponent. Issues seemed to be disregarded in favor of personal attacks upon the individual. The days of standing for office and remaining silent towards the American public before elections took place were over....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2455 words (7 pages)

Essay on American Eagle Outfitters Analysis

- American Eagle Outfitters SWOT Analysis The Silverman family first founded American Eagle Outfitters in 1977. They operated specialty clothing stores under the name Retail Ventures. In 1980 the Silverman’s encountered financial troubles when the Schottenstein family bought out 50% of the Retail Ventures. In 1991 the Schottenstein family bought the rest of Retail Ventures and opened 153 American Eagle Outfitters. By late 2000 the company had introduced 46 new stores in Canada. American Eagle had approximately $2 million in annual sales in 2003 and now operates over 800 stores in the United States and Canada (http://www.hoovers.com/american-eagle-outfitters/--ID__17231--/free-co-factsheet.xh...   [tags: American Eagle Business Essays]

Better Essays
1692 words (4.8 pages)

Reader Response Essay - Slave Purchases and Breeding: Unruly Slave

- Reader Response Essay - Slave Purchases and Breeding: Unruly Slave My initial response to G. B. Wallace’s letter was one of confusion. As I reread the piece given the title “Slave Purchases and Breeding: Unruly Slave, Wallace, G.B” I realized that it was nothing more than a business letter between a slave owner and an associate of his that could presumably help him out of his situation. The language of the letter created a small barrier, since it was out of date in comparison to contemporary American language, but with a little effort, I could see the author’s intentions....   [tags: Reader Response Essays]

Free Essays
643 words (1.8 pages)

Historical Anyalysis Essay

- There is a common mistake that people make when concerning history. They make the mistake of assuming that history is what happened in the past, but history is much more than what happened in the past. History is formed from analyzing evidence from the past and making a connection. Many historians have different personal perspectives on history, and by using the historical method they can all draw conclusions as to what happened and advocate a theory. We find that history is much more than what happened in the past from reading, "The Strange Death of Silas Deane." This is a good example of applying the historical methods and producing a new theory based on reliable evidence....   [tags: American History]

Better Essays
2121 words (6.1 pages)