Essay on Analysis Of Death In Tristan and Story In A Mirror

Essay on Analysis Of Death In Tristan and Story In A Mirror

Length: 2024 words (5.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Both Thomas Mann’s novella “Tristan” (1902) and Ilse Aichinger’s much more abbreviated “Story in a Mirror” (1952) revolve around the topic of death; moreover, both treat their subjects in an aestheticized manner. However, they do so for the sake of achieving different effects. Mann’s purpose is to demonstrate that – for some characters at least – death can lose its emotional impact when it is juxtaposed with beauty and presented in an aesthetic manner; Aichinger’s, in contrast, accentuates the disturbing nature of death by juxtaposing it with the seemingly beautiful, yet ultimately dark imagery.
Defining aesthetics presents difficulty, but it is commonly accepted that symmetry and purity are artistically pleasing. For instance, the opening scene of Tristan describes Einfried as “a long white, rectilinear building with a side wing set in a spacious garden pleasingly equipped with grottoes…” (317, Mann) Einfried, by its very nature as a hospital for the infirm, should evoke unpleasant emotions of sadness and death. However, Mann paints the reader a quite unconventional picture of such an establishment: “Behind its slate roofs the mountains tower heavenwards, evergreen, massy, cleft with wooded ravines.” (317, Mann) And quite abruptly, the notion that people might go here to die is washed out of one’s consciousness and all that remains is the tranquil air of the natural world. Mann mentions that Einfried is a sanatorium extremely abruptly, and then, almost without effort, suppresses the reader’s thoughts of the ailing through an even more powerful distraction: natural splendor. Initially, the author appeals to the reader’s knowledge of a sanatorium by opening with “Einfried, the sanatorium.” (317, Mann) He continues this stylistic...

... middle of paper ...

... the reader interprets the final resting place as a pleasurable one. Or in Mann’s novella, the possibility that Einfried did save Gabriele since her death was never explicitly stated. Many writers shape characters through physical descriptions and narration or through the characters own actions, but Mann and Aichinger decide to shape the readers mood through the use of overpowering imagery that spews over to the characters themselves. The two stories together can demonstrate that an author’s use imagery has absolute rein over the outcome of a story, as well as the reader himself, for it can make a dying woman, Gabriele, look so graceful and full of life, and another women moving towards birth, a universally celebrated event, so dismal and horrendous. Ultimately, death can be accentuated or marginalized solely based on the author’s presentation of aesthetic imagery.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Novel Tristan by Thomas Mann Essay

- Mann’s novella “Tristan” (1902) demonstrates how the reader’s emotional attitude towards death diminishes when juxtaposed to beauty and presented aesthetically, while Aichinger’s “Story in a Mirror” (1954) illustrates how death is accentuated through the presentation of the antithesis. Both stories revolve around death – Aichinger’s is more explicit while Mann’s more implicit. A significant factor in how death played a role in the two stories is based on how the authors set the story as well as the imagery used to convey the finer descriptors....   [tags: death, sanatorium]

Powerful Essays
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Consequences of Passion Exposed in The Romance of Tristan and Iseult

- Consequences of Passion Exposed in The Romance of Tristan and Iseult The story of Tristan and Iseult celebrates the triumph of adultery. When looking vaguely at this romance, readers may think the potion of love that they both drink is the one that makes them to commit adultery. However, this is only a representation of the power of passion and lust Tristan and Iseult have for each other. To better understand this love story, one must realize that Tristan is a marshal hero who volunteers to take a battle against the King of Ireland, in order to redeem the people and the monarch of King Mark....   [tags: The Romance of Tristan and Iseult]

Powerful Essays
918 words (2.6 pages)

The Mirror's Reflection Essay

- Within Frankenstein is a world divided between the egotistical ideas of a mad man and the monster that is created through his insanity: in Lacanian terms, between the Symbolic and the Imaginary Orders. According to Lacan, “the Imaginary [is a] field of images and imagination, and deception” ( ); Victor’s imagination being reflected solely on the monster that is created by his own guilty hands. To Victor, his creation reflects the idea and ego that cultivate through him, it is the spark that takes the ordinary and turns him into the “alienated.” While Victor imagines himself to be a part of society, he soon comes to realize how his work has instead done the opposite, sheltering...   [tags: Literacy Analysis ]

Powerful Essays
1096 words (3.1 pages)

Mirror or Foil? Essay

- Dr. Jekyll took a cautious, but curious sip of his homemade scientific discovery. As agony ripped through him, and his body twisted into a gruesome form he became Hyde a murderous beast hell bent on destruction. Yes, there was a stimulant to the creation of a monster, but the monster in essence was still Dr. Jekyll – just a deeply concealed demon that he tried to disguise. The characters, Bedford and Cavor, in H.G Wells’ novel The First Men in the Moon were not that gruesome but they share a commonality with Dr....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Powerful Essays
1471 words (4.2 pages)

Renaissance Love in Tristan and Iseult Essay

- Renaissance Love in Tristan and Iseult The modern concept of love owes a great deal to the Humanist tradition of the Renaissance. The humanists focused on perfection and exaltation of this life as opposed to the afterlife. In Tristan and Iseult the seeds of Renaissance love are present in the Middle Ages. To the modern eye, it is a mystery how the period of the Middle Ages produced the seeds of the diametrically opposite Renaissance. Yet it is necessary to understand this transformation if one is to fully comprehend the forces that helped produce the modern consciousness....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
614 words (1.8 pages)

Culture as Social Legacy in Mirror for Man Essay

- In Clyde Kluckhohn's Mirror for Man, he explains the differences and similarities among the world's peoples by stating two important ideas: 1) People are similar because they have the same biological equipment and undergo similar life experiences "such as birth, helplessness, illness, old age, and death," but, 2) people are culturally different because of the way they were brought up and they may live in a different environment created by human beings, and acquire a distinct social legacy from their own people....   [tags: Mirror for Man Essays]

Free Essays
891 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on Truth, Illusion, and Examination in Sylvia Plath's The Mirror

- Truth, Illusion, and Examination in Sylvia Plath's The Mirror           Who would be so pretentious as to suggest that they were "silver and exact," and that they "have no preconceptions?" Poet Sylvia Plath dares to "meditate on the opposite wall" in her poem The Mirror to reveal to her reader some of her own insecurities, the theme of this, and several other of her poems. The poet does some introspective exploration in both stanzas; the two carefully intended to 'mirror' each other. It is her use of private or contextual symbolism, her use of symbols to create an atmosphere of truth versus illusion, and her design of the mirror to symbolize her inner-self that make this poem such a vehi...   [tags: Sylvia Plath Mirror Essays]

Powerful Essays
660 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Mirror for Man: Actions and Thoughts Follow Culture

- In a world where everyone has experienced "the same poignant life experiences, such as birth, helplessness, illness, old age, and death," it is incredible to think of the number of ways that peoples can go through these events in life. It is most common that their attitudes and responses are influenced by their environment and society. As Clyde Kluckhohn had explained in "Mirror for Man", the best explanation for any human action is the "concept of culture." One cannot clearly define this idea, but through the comparison of two different groups of people hopefully one can better understand the meaning of culture....   [tags: Mirror for Man Essays]

Free Essays
772 words (2.2 pages)

The Infinity Mirror Essay

- The Infinity Mirror   "Tularecito" is a myth about truth. Tularicito, just a character of that myth, is the focus for this glossed over fable. Steinbeck draws on this form of genre to present the idea that we are all a part of what happens to others, based upon our nature.   The image presented of Tularecito is that of a demon, an idiot savant, a boy with a gift from God, and that gift's cost. He is a freak, a dangerous misfit, an innocent who does not need the constraints of reality....   [tags: The Infinity Mirror]

Free Essays
715 words (2 pages)

A Feminist Analysis of Perceval, Tristan and Isolt, and Aucassin and Nicolette

- A Feminist Analysis of Perceval, Tristan and Isolt, and Aucassin and Nicolette   Currently, there is a debate among feminists as to whether the demeaning portrayal of women in popular media causes or is caused by negative attitudes in modern culture. A similar debate exists among historians of the late middle ages as to whether the rise in popularity of the cult of the Virgin, her portrayal in art, and the code of chivalry caused or was caused by changing attitudes towards women. Many factors in the late middle ages coincided to create an entirely new role for women: contact with the Muslim world in Spain, the rising popularity of religious life, and the aforementioned cultural changes....   [tags: Feminism Feminist Women Criticism]

Powerful Essays
1173 words (3.4 pages)